De benedicta incarnacione, chapter 3, part 3
Against a second incarnation: the pierced side and the bride
Harris pp. 36.15–40.15
¶136.15–37.4
But the consequentconsequens / antecedens: consequent / antecedent seems false in three ways. First from this, that then the resurrection of Christ would be his nativity or generation. And so Christ would have a threefold nativity and a manifold generation: one nativity eternal and two others temporal. For the first generation of Christ, in the womb, is a generation for this reason, that it is a production from not being a man to being a man. Since therefore it is so at the instant of the resurrection, it followssequitur: it follows that that is a generation, and by the same token a nativity out of the sepulchre, as it would be if it were posited that the seed of the virgin had been placed by itself in the sepulchre, and successively or suddenly given its lineaments, and a createdcreatura / creator / creatus: creature / creator / created soul joined [to it].1 Nor is place relevant to bodily nativity, except perhaps by reason of preservation, just as it is not relevant to the nativity from the spirit, of which John 3 [speaks]; but on both sides, once the generation is had, the nativity of the one reborn follows proportionally.2 37It is necessary therefore, for the resurrection of a personpersona: person, that the same person who fell in the sleep of death, or by the interruption of the humanityhumanitas: the humanity, rise again; since the rational spirit of the person is the humanity and so man.3
¶237.5–37.19
Second, it is objectedinstatur; obicitur: it is objected against the said consequent by this, that the world through the death of Christ would be imperfect to any degree you please:4 which is impossible, since that was a most just, most precious and most useful death, perfecting the whole world: and the inferenceconsequencia: inference is proved. Christ, insofar as man, is a part of the world, as is clear even to modern speakers, who grant "Christ, insofar as he is man, is a creaturecreatura / creator / creatus: creature / creator / created": and the world is the totality of creaturesuniversitas creaturarum: the totality of creatures. Since therefore "Christ is man" perfects the world more than even the whole heaven5 or any other part of the world whatever, it seems that, this being taken away, that world is made proportionally more imperfect: which is impossible, since as much perfection as pertains to the humanity of Christ is preserved in the soul and in the incorrupt body. Therefore, since the whole is its parts, it is clear that he remained the same man in the three daystriduum (in triduo): the three days.
¶337.20–39.9
Third, this is confirmed from the testimony of scripture. For in John 19 it is written: "But after they were come to Jesus, and saw that he was already dead, they did not break his legs. But one of the soldiers with a spear opened his side: and there came out blood and water. And he that saw it," says John, "hath given testimony: and his testimony is true."6 I ask, how would they have come to Jesus dead, unless that dead man was Jesus? Or how would the soldier with a spear have opened his side, Jesus’ side, if it was not then the side of Jesus? Do we believe that the evangelist, so markedly asserting that he saw these things beyond all the other deeds of Christ, made up a lie? And if it is said that the letter kills, but the spiritual and right sense quickens,7 38of what sort is such [a sense]? — "When they were come to that dead body, which could not be Jesus, but before, not then, was the body of Jesus,8 then one of the soldiers opened, not his side, nor univocallyunivoce: univocally the side of anyone, but a part of one dead body, which was not then Christ or a part of him; and there came out, not the blood of redemption and the water of baptism from the side of Christ, since then it was not Christ." And so the spirit, the water and the blood are not and were not witnesses of the humanity of Christ, since they were not together, as John seems to say, 1 John 4.9 Nor is that which the Apostle says in Ephesians 5 true to the words, that "Christ so loved the churchecclesia: church that he delivered himself up for it: that he might sanctify, cleansing it by the laver of water in the word of life";10 since the church through the whole three days was with [her] bridegroom or head, Christ. Nor is that [word] of the Apostle in Ephesians 5 true to the words, when he expounds that [word] of Genesis 2, said in the literal sense of the first Adam and his wife, in the mystical sense of Christ and the church: "This now," says the text, "is bone of my bones, and flesh of my flesh: for this cause shall a man leave his father and mother: and shall cleave to his wife. And they shall be two in one flesh." "This," says the Apostle, "is a great sacramentsacramentum (the Eucharist); sacramentum altaris: sacrament; the sacrament of the altar:11 but I speak in Christ and in the church." And that exposition of the Apostle is impossible,12 namely that, as from the rib of Adam, dissolved in sleep, his bride was built according to the bony members, solid and tender, so from the opening of the side of the second Adam the church, the bride of Christ, was built according to the variety of the members of the church. Nor did Christ leave the Father, emptyingexinanicio / exinanire / inanicio: emptying / empty himself and going out from the Father, as is said in John 16; and "his mother the synagogue, in which he was born," Isaiah 50;13 and [nor] will he cleave to his wife, namely the church, as is said in Hosea 2. Nor were the two joined in wedlock in the same common naturenatura: nature, as to the flesh as well as 39the spirit, and concordant in affection both sensitive and intellective, as Augustine and others following the Apostle expound.14 But each of those clauses is impossible by the force of the wordsde vi vocis / de vi sermonis: by the force of the words, since Christ did not suffer death on the cross; for at the instant of death Christ is not Christ; nor was that sacrament in Christ and the church, since for the whole three days there was no Christ, but the bride waited for the espousals until the instant of the resurrection.15 These are ravingsdeliramenta: ravings, and like the words of children.
¶439.10–39.21
Hence all the more modern doctorsmoderni doctores / moderniores doctores: the modern doctors / the more modern doctors whose writings I remember having read say concordantly that in the three days that body was the body of Christ, just as the soul also was then the soul of Christ: because, while the extremes of the unionunio: union of the WordVerbum: the Word to the assumedassumere / assumpcio (naturam): assume / assumption nature remain, the same union remains. Hence they say that "they buried Jesus," that is, the body of Jesus, is a synecdochic locutionsynecdochica locucio: synecdochic locution.16 But I do not see how it would then be the body of Jesus, unless Jesus then were a bodily Jesus, having all the parts of that body as his parts, according to that voice of the Truth, Matthew 26: "She in pouring this ointment on my body hath done it for my burial."17 For certain I believe that Christ himself, as well as every part of his body, was buried.
¶539.22–40.15
Therefore I grant this with these doctors in the first part, since it is of faith; and I grant in the fullest proper sense of the wordsde virtute sermonis: in the proper sense of the words that Christ lay in the sepulchre, since that dead body was the person of the Word:18 not that every quantitative partpars quantitativa: quantitative part of that body was generated at the instant of death, so that Christ was then generated by assuming a new nature, but, remaining continuously the same body, before living and afterwards dead, it is subject perpetually to the same hypostaticypostatice: hypostatically union. For through the whole three days Christ remained man, as to the body as well as as to the soul; and he truly suffered death at the 40instant of separation, since the dead flesh, which then was Christ, suffered privation of life; and truly from the side of Christ there came out water and blood of Christ, for the duration of its issuing;19 for Christ for the whole three days is the same dead body, from which, as its blood and spirits flowed out so that the soul might naturally be separated, the subtler part of the blood was miraculously reserved, with the ichor,20 for celebrating the espousals between the bridegroom, living gloriously in the three days after the triumph, and his mystical body, which is the church. For in Isaiah 11 it is written: "The root of Jesse for an ensign of the people, him the Gentiles shall beseech, and his sepulchre shall be glorious."21 And so the other scriptures of both the new and the old testament are understood literally of Christ. For the scriptures must be fulfilled concerning Christ’s humanity according to the sense which the holy doctors have diligently searched out in them.22
Notes
- 1 36.24 lineatum: A reads creatum (lineatum in the margin), B creatum, C lineatum; A and C double anima. Lineatum: given its lineaments, formed in outline.
- 2 36.27–28 utrobique habita generacione renati: renati is taken with nativitas ("the nativity of the one reborn"); it may hang on generacione ("once the generation of the one reborn is had"). Utrobique: bodily and spiritual birth (John 3:6).
- 3 37.3 spiritus racionalis persone: O reads species racionalis per se. Sive above: A B C sine ("without interruption of the humanity").
- 4 37.6 quantumlibet imperfectus: "imperfect to any degree you please": losing Christ’s manhood would cost the world more than losing the whole heaven (below).
- 5 37.13 totum usque celum: usque is taken as intensive ("even"); A B C omit it.
- 6 John 19:33–35, without the Vulgate’s continuo ("immediately"), and with inquit Iohannes added. T. et (37.21), with A B C O, against the print’s ut ("when"), which is the Vulgate’s: "and saw". The source backs Harris, but the "majority backed by the source" clause weighs a split; here all four agree and et construes, so they win. Wyclif may have quoted from memory or from a text with et.
- 7 2 Cor. 3:6: "the letter killeth: but the spirit quickeneth."
- 8 38 quod non potuit esse Iesus, sed: om. A B C.
- 9 1 John 5:8 (Wyclif "4"): "there are three that give testimony on earth: the spirit and the water and the blood. And these three are one." On the moderns’ view the three were never together.
- 10 Eph. 5:25–26: the Vulgate has sicut et Christus dilexit ecclesiam et seipsum tradidit pro ea, ut illam sanctificaret (DR "as Christ also loved the church and delivered himself up for it: That he might sanctify it"). A B C add eam after sanctificaret.
- 11 Sacramentum: "sacrament" in the Augustinian sense, a mystery (Eph. 5:32). Gen. 2:23–24 is quoted in the form of Eph. 5:31 (propter hoc).
- 12 est impossibilis: impossible on the moderns’ position; this paragraph sets out its consequences, as again at 39.3 (quelibet illarum particularum).
- 13 John 16:28: "I came forth from the Father." "His mother the synagogue, in which he was born" is not the text of Isaiah (50:1 speaks of "the bill of the divorce of your mother"); A B C cite Isa. 7. The phrase is Augustine’s, In Ioh. tract. 9.10, PL 35, 1462, Relinquendo synagogam Judaeorum, de qua secundum carnem natus est (verified); the Isaiah reference perhaps points to the mother of Isa. 50:1. Hosea 2:19: "I will espouse thee to me for ever."
- 14 Augustine on Gen. 2:24 and Eph. 5:31–32 (Christ leaving the Father and the synagogue his mother), In Ioh. tract. 9.10, PL 35, 1462: Reliquit Patrem, quia … semetipsum exinanivit; Relinquendo synagogam Judaeorum … et inhaerendo Ecclesiae; Dormit Adam ut fiat Eva: moritur Christus ut fiat Ecclesia (verified).
- 15 39.3–5 cum Christus non passus est mortem in cruce ...: these clauses state what follows on the moderns’ position, not Wyclif’s assertions.
- 16 39.14 synecdochica: Harris’s correction (pro synecdochica, i.e. per synecdochen) of A synochica, B sinodochia, C syndochica, O synodogica: the figure that names the whole (Jesus) for the part (his body).
- 17 Matt. 26:12, without the Vulgate’s enim (DR "For she"); A B C omit hec.
- 18 39.25 persona Verbi: O adds Christi.
- 19 40.3 pro mora exitus: "for the duration of its issuing": the water and blood were Christ’s while they flowed from him.
- 20 40.7 ichore: A B C iecore ("liver"), O ycore. Ichor: the watery humour of the blood.
- 21 Isa. 11:10, without the Vulgate’s in die illa ("in that day") and qui stat ("who standeth"), which A B C add; A B C cite Isa. 7.
- 22 40.13 impleri, with A B C O, against the print’s interpretari, which is Harris’s alone, against every manuscript.
How the Latin of this chapter was established
- Omitted per §3.5 / kept in the English (margin matter): reference John iii. 6. (36.27); reference Eph. v. 26. (38.10); reference Eph. v. 31, 32. (38.14); reference Gen. ii. 24. (38.15); reference Johnxvi.27. (38.28); reference Hos. ii. 16, 19. (38.30); reference Matt. xxvi. 12. (39.17); reference John xii. 35. (40.21).