De potestate pape, chapter 2, part 4
The nine gifts: prophets, doctors, the second and third hierarchies, the body
Loserth pp. 36.28–40.30
¶136.28–37.11
In the second degree are placed the prophets, who can be understood as those who, according to knowledge, preach as gospel prophecies of the past and of the future; for preachers indeed ought to speak out from afar things hidden from the common people, and according to knowledge to fit their 37sermon to the audience; and so the apostles had a higher prophecy, more lively and more fruitful, than the prophets of the old testament, as is clear from 2 Peter 1; and I believe this to be the highest office of the apostles outwardly, after wise contemplation inwardly; therefore Christ and his apostles exercised that office urgently, as is clear from the last chapter of Mark and from 1 Corinthians 1.1 And in this sense some understand that of Matthew 23:34: "Behold I send to you prophets and wise men and scribes and apostles and evangelists."2
¶237.12–37.18
And in the third degree are the doctors, who apart, to one side, whether in the schools or privately, teach what has been preached as gospel or prophesied publicly. And to them corresponds the gift of faith, since they must steadfastly teach the unlearned after the likeness of Christ, who at home taught the parables he had preached, as is clear from Mark 4.3
¶337.19–38.20
Having thus [treated] the threefold feeding according to the first hierarchy, which receives from God three degrees on the pattern of the first heavenly hierarchy, he next sets out how the lower powermotrix (anima, virtus): moving aidssuffragari: to aid by intercession.4 And all these show how God, who is a spirit, shines variously in men by his gifts. For as smoke indicates the fire by which it is produced, so every creature that has the light of power in varying measure declares the light, as a ray does. Therefore the Apostle calls these gifts "the manifestation of the Spirit".5 And others have the power that God works wonders through them; for by this the spirit is fed and the power of the soul strengthened, but this is little in comparison with the former, just as it would be little that the Holy Spirit appeared to the apostles in tongues of fire, had he not enlightened them inwardly; 38and such power the fathers in the primitive churchecclesia: church had, more or less. But they ascribed the powers to themselves only as to instruments made more capable by humility. And in the second degree of the second hierarchy is the grace of healing the sick bodily, and so the two outermost senses, namely sight and touch, were fed in their order to the soul. And the one sense, as to the order of dignity and nearness to the spirit, is prior, but the other sense is put before it in kind, in generality and in nearness to the flesh. But the other two have the power of helping the needy, of feeding all the middle senses; and this is done by the firmness of faith, by which Christ is heard, worshipped and tasted in his members.6 For the apostle of bodily alms feeds the three middle senses, in that the voice of Christ is heard, Matthew 25:40: "As long as you did it to one of my least, you did it to me"; for then "we are the good odour of Christ unto God" (2 Corinthians 2:15), if we taste the inward sweetness of Christ.7
¶438.21–39.5
Now as to the third hierarchy, by which the people is ruled by superiorsprepositi: superiors, God gave to some governments, as to the superiors of both [kinds] of the church’s membersmembrum: member; for this is required the discerning of spiritual gifts, and consequently of the spirits that move [men] to that office, by placing, keeping and protecting each one in that degree to which God has disposed him by his gifts; for this pertains most of all to the office of prelatesprelatus: prelate.8 And since man is by nature an animal that communicates in speech, and a civil one, therefore it is needful secondly that the curatecuratus: curate of such an office of superiorprepositura: office of superior have kinds of tongues, 39by which he will communicate with his subjects, since otherwise he would be a barbarian to them. Nor is this enough, since a bird could form sounds; therefore lastly the interpretation of speeches is required, for the living voice has, from the cooperation of the spirit, much hidden energy.9
¶539.6–39.23
And these nine spiritual gifts are fitted to the members of the human body, so that the triad of the first hierarchy corresponds to the brain, in which are three ventricles, vessels of the lucid spirits and of the five inner senses, by which wisdom, that is, the knowledge of God, is perceived inwardly as the sun or the day. But the organs of the five spirits situated in the head figure the second, the spirit that speaks the knowledge of worldly things; and the neck, which is the organ of uttering, signifies the gift of faith that comes by hearing; but in the region of the breast the heart, stomach and lung correspond by their property to the second triad.10 And in the region of the nutritive [members] the spleen and intestines correspond to the third hierarchy; indeed, as the Apostle "became all things to all", that he might gain all, so there is no member of the church that cannot fittingly cooperate with any member of the body whatever.11
¶639.24–40.17
Yet a threefold agreement and a threefold difference must be noted. For as the members make up one body to which the soul is joined, and again as every member is necessary to every other, since they help one another in their offices, so it is with the members of the church by force of communion and the bond of charitycaritas: charity. And thirdly, as the members behave in their governance, so too do the members of the church, since according to Chrysostom, homily 22 of the Opus imperfectum, "man is a kind of book in which the whole Christian religion 40is written".12 As therefore there is an affinity of the head to the feet, so reason and affection are joined; and as every member, noble or ignoble, serves the spirit without contention, so every member of the church serves Christ without contention over lesser standingminoritas: lesser standing and obedience; and as the members of preeminence do not grow proud of their nobility but do their office according to the governance of the soul for the aidsuffragium sensus: aid of sense of each, so it should be with the members of the church.13 The eyes indeed and the face lack such covering, lest a veil disfigure them and prepare them for ruin: so Christ and the apostles, from the fervour of charity and estrangement from the fervour of covetousness, were not entangled in temporal goodstemporalia: temporal goods in a worldly way. But the less noble members, like the private parts, are covered more hiddenly, more manifoldly and more tenderly, and so it is with the contemptible persons by whom the dregs of the church are purged.14
¶740.18–40.30
And others divide the members of the church into spiritual or right-hand, such as the clergyclerus; clericus: the clergy; cleric, and bodily or left-hand, such as the laity; and the first part, which ought to be like the roof of the house of the church, because it does not admit into itself the cutting up of lordshipdominium: lordship, remains undivided. But the second part is divided into superiors and workers, like the walls and foundation of the church, and so we have three hierarchies of the church with their subdivisions, into a lowest, a middle and a highest part. And others draw from the Apostle’s text nine parts of the church [answering] to the nine simple and spermatic parts in the human body, and others fit them to the organs on account of natural correspondences.15
Notes
- 1 Procul fari, "to speak out from afar", plays on the etymology of propheta as one who speaks forth or from afar (Isidore, Etym. 7.8.1, PL 82, 283B: prophets are quasi praefatores, quia porro fantur, who foresaw ea quae in mysterio abscondita erant). Secundum scienciam echoes "the word of knowledge, according to the same Spirit" (1 Cor. 12:8). Wyclif is following the order of 1 Cor. 12:28 (DR "first apostles, secondly prophets, thirdly doctors"). 2 Pet. 1:19 ("the more firm prophetical word"); Mark 16:20; 1 Cor. 1:17 ("Christ sent me not to baptize, but to preach the gospel"); Wyclif gives chapters only.
- 2 Matt. 23:34. The Vulgate has only prophetas, et sapientes, et scribas (DR "prophets and wise men and scribes"); et apostolos et evangelistas is not in it (cf. Luke 11:49, prophetas et apostolos). Wyclif’s added words are translated.
- 3 The third degree of 1 Cor. 12:28 (DR "thirdly doctors"); the gift of faith, 1 Cor. 12:9; Mark 4:34 (DR "but apart, he explained all things to his disciples"). B omits doctores; A in marg.: tercius (37.12).
- 4 The three degrees of the first hierarchy (apostles, prophets, doctors) are patterned, as Wyclif says (exemplariter ad primam yerarchiam celestem), on the first of the three angelic hierarchies of Pseudo-Dionysius, De caelesti hierarchia 6.2 (thrones, cherubim, seraphim). "He" is the Apostle, whose list (1 Cor. 12:28) Wyclif now follows into the second hierarchy, DR "miracles … graces of healings, helps". Virtus here is "power" in the sense of those "miracles" (virtutes), the "working of miracles" (operatio virtutum) of 12:10. AB in marg.: Ierarchia secunda (37.29).
- 5 1 Cor. 12:7 (DR "the manifestation of the Spirit is given to every man unto profit"); John 4:24 ("God is a spirit"); the tongues of fire, Acts 2:3.
- 6 Alie due, "the other two", does not fit the count: one gift (helps, opitulaciones) remains in this hierarchy, and the middle senses are three; the reference is uncertain. Adoratur, "worshipped", stands in a list of the middle senses (hearing, smell, taste) where odoratur, "smelled", is expected, and the next sentence turns on "odour"; the print is translated.
- 7 Apostolus … corporalis elemosyne, "the apostle of bodily alms", is translated as printed; the phrase is doubtful (perhaps one who gives bodily alms). Matt. 25:40, where the Vulgate reads uni ex his fratribus meis minimis (DR "to one of these my least brethren"); Wyclif’s shorter words are translated. 2 Cor. 2:15 is the reference printed in the margin (38.32).
- 8 Prepositis utriusque membrorum ecclesie: "both" is taken to mean the two kinds of members, clergy and laity (cf. ¶7). The gifts are those of 1 Cor. 12:10, 28 (DR "the discerning of spirits"; "governments, kinds of tongues, interpretations of speeches"). AB in marg.: Tertia ierarchia; A in marg. sup.: Membra ecclesie quam habent similitudinem ad membra corporis humani (38.18).
- 9 Aristotle, Politics 1.2, 1253a2–18 (man a political animal; speech, not mere voice, proper to man); 1 Cor. 14:11 (DR "I shall be to him to whom I speak a barbarian"). Curatus here is the one charged with such an office of superior, not only a parish priest.
- 10 Figurant secundum spiritum dicentem scienciam mundanorum: secundum is taken as "the second [gift]", knowledge, after wisdom (1 Cor. 12:8); it may instead be the preposition: "figure, according to the spirit, [the gift] that speaks the knowledge of worldly things". Quinque spirituum may stand for the five outer senses. "Faith that comes by hearing": Rom. 10:17.
- 11 Loserth queries coequari, "be matched with", for the printed cooperari (39.23); the print is translated. 1 Cor. 9:22 (DR "I became all things to all men, that I might save all"); ut omnia lucrifaceret echoes ut infirmos lucrifacerem in the same verse. Wyclif’s words are translated.
- 12 Pseudo-Chrysostom, Opus imperfectum in Matthaeum, hom. 22; Loserth: Chrysostom, Opera (ed. Migne) VI (Migne’s Chrysostom vol. VI = PG 56; the column is illegible in the OCR of Loserth’s foot). B in marg.: Membrum (39.30).
- 13 Sine contencione minoritatis et obediencie: taken as contention over lesser standing and obedience (no member disputes its lower place); the genitives may instead describe the service itself, "without contention, in lowliness and obedience". A in marg. numbers the three agreements 1, 2, 3 (40.1, 40.4, 40.6).
- 14 1 Cor. 12:23 (DR "those that are our uncomely parts have more abundant comeliness"); temporalibus seculariter involuti recalls 2 Tim. 2:4 (DR "No man, being a soldier to God, entangleth himself with secular businesses").
- 15 "Simple and spermatic parts": the homogeneous parts of the body (bone, flesh, nerve and the like), which medieval medicine held to be formed from the seed, as against the composite organs (organa) of the next clause.
How the Latin of this chapter was established
- Plate readings; page · reading · note):
- 36: preterito
- 37: ego (print: Ecce ego mitto; missing from main scan)
- 37: ad (print: exemplariter ad primam; missing from main scan)
- 37: ∅ (25 is the line number)
- 37: linguis
- 38: ∅ (English side-note word)
- 38: mihi (h ascender clear, zoomed)
- 40: inscribitur
- Omitted per §3.5 / kept in the English (margin matter): reference 17. II. Cor. II, i5. (38.32).