De potestate pape, chapter 9, part 8
The dignity of sees, worship in spirit, and the abomination of desolation
Loserth pp. 218.25–222.18
¶1218.25–221.16
And it is clear in what sense the laws about elections and about the dignity of particular places have force; as in distinction 22, Sacrosancta, it is said that "the Roman churchecclesia: church obtained the primacyprimatus: primacy not from the apostles but from the Lord; and after that first see the second see is at Alexandria, consecrated by blessed Mark, evangelist and disciple of Peter; the third see is at Antioch, where Peter, before he came 219to Rome, sat as bishop and appointed Ignatius bishop, where the name of Christians first arose"; and afterwards a synod decreed that the church of Constantinople should hold the second see after Rome, "because it is in a manner a new Rome".1 These things would be frivolous unless the said sees made up for them with deeds. Therefore Gregory says in the same place: "When fault does not require it, we are all equal by the measure of humility."2 And the confirmation is that these three sees have been cast off by ours as schismatic, and they in turn reckon ours schismatics; and the Asians and other faithful reckon both to be raving madmen, setting up other sees in their own churches, and asserting truly, since not place but virtue sanctifies a people, that whatever church more humbly follows Jesus Christ is the greater. And this is the true teachingsentencia: teaching / sentence, since in John 4:20 Truth speaks to the Samaritan woman, who had set against Christ: "Our fathers adored on this mountain: and you say that at Jerusalem is the place where men must adore"; "the hour cometh," he says, "and now is, when the true adorers shall adore the Father in spirit and in truth."3 For since God is a spirit, filling every place, it is clear that there is no need to go up a high mountain so that God may hear our prayers better, as the Samaritans had believed from the deeds of the patriarchs, nor to go up into Solomon’s temple with the Jews; but to adore in spirit, and as on a mountain, aspiring to heavenly things according to the memorative powerpotencia: potency / power of the soul, namely the understanding.4 And since the soul is where it has affection, according to that of the Apostle, Philippians 3:20, "our 220conversation is in heaven", it is clear that one praying thus is made by God a high mountain to himself.5 And therefore Truth, teaching us to pray to the Father (Matthew 6:9), teaches our consideration to begin from the height of the one adored: "Our Father who art in heaven" etc. As for the temple of the Jews at Jerusalem, one must adore in truth, so that the life does not disagree, lying, with the petition and mind of the one adoring; and then there comes to be a temple infinitely more excellent for the Lord than the basilica of the Jews, for in 1 Corinthians 3:16 the Apostle says: "the temple of the Lord is, which you are."6 For when there is truth in manner of lifeconversacio: manner of life and truth in petition (which truth is adequation to the divine intellect), then, from full conformity to the divine will, the one praying thus in mind and spirit is constituted the temple of God. And then, just as he worthily says the first petition of the Lord’s prayer to God the Father on account of the sublimity of the intellect, so he can worthily say the two following petitions to the other persons, in the second place, since one so unconformed must be drawn to the kingdom, where there will be perfect conformity of the uncreated and the created will.7 Therefore we pray that, as in heaven there is full conformity, so on earth there may be, proportionally, conformity of wills.8 And it is clear from this twofold manner of praying how the decrees in distinction 40 are verified: Non est facile, with the two chapters following, and the chapter Multi sunt sacerdotes, with those like them.9 In these it is plainly taught that any place whatever, as also a sacrament or a perceptiblesensibilis (in the definition of animal): sentient riteritus: rite, is irrelevantimpertinens; impertinencia: irrelevant; irrelevance to this adoration and to a person’s preeminencepreeminencia: preeminence with 221God, unless perhaps it has stirred up holiness by accident. Hence it is a sign that we adore in the Samaritan or Jewish way, like an irrational animal creeping with the head of our mind bowed down, that we observe only places and ceremonies. But Christ ascended into heaven for this: that, setting little store by these temporal things, we may ascend by the ladder of virtues from these sublunary things, in which we are fixed, to spiritual and heavenly goods, which are finally to be desiredaffectare: to desire. Hence Truth, answering to the faith of the woman, by which she truly believed Christ to be a prophet, addresses her: "Woman, believe me";10 as if he said: through the imperfection of your faith you are far from being a bridesponsa / sponsus: bride / bridegroom; but since "salvation is of the Jews", you must believe me, setting for yourself the substance of faith in the foundation of the ladder of prayer.
¶2221.17–222.18
In these images, then, and imaginaryfantasticus: imaginary / phantastic (of the faculty) things, after the endowmentdotacio: endowment and the overturning of affection, the church has been deluded in punishment of sin, and especially in setting up for itself a prince as if he were Christ. And so, with the declarationprotestacio; protestari: declaration; to declare solemnly made above, I understand that of Matthew 24:15: "When therefore you shall see the abomination of desolation, which was spoken of by Daniel the prophet, standing in the holy place: he that readeth let him understand."11 Now the holy place seems to me to be the holy statestatus (disposicionis, virtutis, …): state (of disposition, of virtue, …) which the popepapa: pope claims; therefore it says "standing", and in Mark 13:14 it says "standing where it ought not". In truth, that by the authority and command of Caesar, or by a false election of the cardinals, a supreme vicar of Christvicarius Christi: vicar of Christ should be constituted is an abomination in the abstract. And if faithful souls saw clearly, on both sides, the spiritual state of the church: how there used to preside in it one householderpaterfamilias: householder, who would graciously receive by inviting, feed by refreshing, and defend 222by helping all his domestics whatever.12 But now they would find presiding in the same house of the church a blasphemous hypocrite, of altogether the opposite condition: no wonder if very many are made desolate. It is as if a traveller used to lodge with a householder of magnificent largesse, and afterwards, entering the house, found a monstrous beast which tyrannizes over guests hungrily, slyly and treacherously: seeing such a one sit in the chair of the kind householder, he would be made not a little desolate at the sight. So then I understand the abomination of desolation, prophesied and proclaimed in the gospel, which Christ commands the intellectual part of the church to understand from the effect. Nor is it a wonder if later men, taught by experience, know this sense more particularly than the earlier saints, to whom it was not revealed by the effect or prophetically. For knowledge of the sense of scripture and holiness do not in general correspond.
Notes
- 1 Gratian, Decretum D. 22 c. 2 (Sacrosancta), with c. 3 for the see of Constantinople, as Loserth gives them; the form is ours. Loserth’s italics end the quotation at exortum est and resume at propter hoc … nova Roma; we follow them.
- 2 Decretum D. 22 c. 4, from Gregory, as Loserth gives it. Ibidem is the same distinction.
- 3 Opposite Christo: so Loserth, marked (sic); the manuscripts read oppositi. We take opposite as a participle agreeing with mulieri, "the woman, who had set against Christ" the words of John 4:20, which are hers, not Christ’s; Christ’s answer, "the hour cometh …", is John 4:23. At 219.20 B omits adorabunt. S. Wyclif’s in quo for the Vulgate’s ubi (4:20) changes nothing in the English.
- 4 Montuose, "as on a mountain": the mind’s ascent replaces the Samaritans’ mountain. Memorativa potencia is the soul’s faculty (potencia as "power", not Aristotle’s potency); Wyclif glosses it as intelligencia. Cum spiritus sit Deus echoes John 4:24 ("God is a spirit").
- 5 Inside the Douay quotation of Philippians 3:20, DR’s "conversation" (heavenly citizenship) stands for conversacio; elsewhere it is "manner of life". C. Ubi afficitur: the soul is where its affection is set.
- 6 Wyclif’s templum Domini est, quod estis vos is closest to 1 Corinthians 3:17 (Vulgate templum enim Dei sanctum est, quod estis vos; DR "the temple of God is holy, which you are"); his reference is 3:16 ("you are the temple of God"). We translate his Latin.
- 7 Ad secundas personas alias: taken as the other two persons of the Trinity, addressed "in the second place" by the second and third petitions (thy kingdom come, thy will be done), after the first is said to the Father. Difformem: one not yet conformed to the divine will; the print is read on the plate.
- 8 At 220.23–24 the apparatus reports sic in terra sit proporcionaliter conformitas as missing in a manuscript (the siglum is not legible in the scan); the print governs.
- 9 Decretum D. 40 c. 2 (Non est facile), c. 3 (Nos qui presumus), c. 4 (Non loca), and c. 12 (Multi sunt sacerdotes), as Loserth gives them.
- 10 John 4:21; "salvation is of the Jews" is John 4:22. At 221.11 B reads a fide and creditur; the print governs.
- 11 Cum protestacione predicta: the submission formula Wyclif made earlier, that he will retract what is shown contrary to scripture or reason. S. The words of Christ (Matthew 24:15) agree with the Vulgate; Daniel 9:27.
- 12 The conditional si fideles anime viderent … has no main clause; the period breaks off, and Modo autem invenirent opens the contrast. We keep the break.
How the Latin of this chapter was established
- Plate readings; page · reading · note):
- 218: Et
- 218: apud
- 218: Anthiochiam
- 218: Petrus
- 219: venerat
- 219: Ignacium
- 219: episcopum
- 219: ubi
- 219: christianorum
- 219: exortum
- 219: est
- 219: humilitatis
- 219: Et
- 219: veri
- 219: III
- 220: ∅ (box is on the English side-note (temple / adoring); no Latin word there)
- 221: loco (print "stantem in loco sancto"; the main scan lost loco)
- 222: Nec
- 220: difformem (LEFT-nw: print = printed; line number 20 follows)