De eucharistia, chapter 3, part 4
Against quantity as the subject, and the qualities that stand of themselves
Loserth pp. 65.29–69.21
¶165.29–66.5
But against this it is arguedarguitur per: it is argued by appeal to first by appeal to the fact that no quantityquantitas / qualitas: quantity / quality can be enlarged in such a way; for either the quantity that would be enlarged remains or it does not. If it remains, either it is mixed with the quantity that comes to it, and it is clear 66that then at every point a new quantity comes to be, the old one having been corrupted; but if it remains unmixed, it is not that quantity that becomes greater, but [there is] generally a new one, which is not the sacramentsacramentum (the Eucharist); sacramentum altaris: sacrament; the sacrament of the altar; and from these a quantity comes to be in two parts, sacredsacer; sacrare: sacred; hallow and not sacred.1
¶266.6–66.21
Second, it is argued by appeal to the fact that, when the quantity is rarefied at every point (since experience teaches that it can be rarefied), the old quantity which was the sacrament must be wholly corrupted, and one quantity which is not the sacrament wholly generated. For one must not feignfingere (a miracle): feign something that continually consecrates a new quantity; since nevertheless the body of Christcorpus Christi / corpus Domini: the body of Christ / the body of the Lord does not cease to be there, blessed, while the accidentsaccidens: accident so remain under the form of bread and winepanis / vinum: bread / wine; for otherwise a Christian would tremble to receive the sacrament for however short a time after the consecration, since, for all he knowsex tibi dubio; ex sibi dubio: for all you know; for all he knows,2 heat or another agent, by changing the subject, has made an accident succeed which does not become the sacrament; since the perceptiblesensibilis (in the definition of animal): sentient sacrament is causally prior to the body of Christ’s being there sacramentallysacramentaliter: sacramentally, as is clear from the nature of consecrationconfeccio: consecration (of the eucharist).
¶366.22–66.33
Third, it is argued by appeal to the fact that, a foot-long [piece of] earth being designated, a,3 on which a foot-long quantity is smearedlinire; linitus: smear (on); smeared, that earth is, and would be, formally foot-long in that possible case in which God annihilatedanichilacio; anichilare: annihilation; annihilate that quantity but kept the earth altogether unmoved in the same place; now then it would remain formally foot-long; therefore one may positest dare: one may posit an intrinsic foot-lengthpedalitas: foot-length, prior to that smeared one, by which it is formally foot-long; and that [foot-length] cannot be of itselfper se / per accidens: of itself / by accident; (spatial) apart, by itself, since it is this earth’s being so quantifiedquantus: quantified; and no one can destroy its distinctness. And the same consideration holds of qualityquantitas / qualitas: quantity / quality: that it does not have its own rarity, density and like qualities distinct from the subject.4
¶467.1–67.15
Again, according to the false writersfalsigraphus: false writer5 substancesubstancia: substance can remain quantified without a distinct quantity, and so of every relationrespectus; respectivus: relation; relational; nor is there a reason why, by the same token, the same should not be thought of the whole genus of quality; therefore one may not posit an accident besides substance. Since, therefore, it is evident from sense that material things remain after the consecration, it remains for them to grant that material substances remain. What, then, would that remaining body be but bread and wine, as the decreedecretum; decreta: decree; the decrees of the Roman churchecclesia: church says?6 And since this is an argument to the manargumentum ad hominem: argument to the man, I ask that the major be taken as granted. The minor is clear from this: that there can be motion to quantity equally as to quality; equally do the philosophers posit, and arguments prove, that the other accidents are distinguished [from substance] as qualities are; equally do they posit that qualities cannot be separated from a subject, as [they posit of] the other accidents.
¶567.16–67.24
Hence here the philosophers wonder why the theologians posit that every quality can be of itself, and not a material substantial formforma substancialis: substantial form, which (insofar asin quantum (reduplicative): insofar as [it is] substance) would rather have the account of standing of itself; and so prime mattermateria prima: prime matter could be without form, which they deny.7 If it is said that Aristotle or reason dictates that, it dictates equally or more that a quality could not be of itself; if it is said that faith demands this, what they ought to prove is beggedpeticio (principii) / petitur: begging [of the question] / is begged outright.
¶667.25–68.11
They wonder, second, what favour quality has earned, which they allow to be able to be of itself; since, just as it can be maintained that figurefigura / figuratum: figure / thing figured is the thing figured8 (and so of beauty, with natural power and the other gifts of God), so it can be held with probabilityprobabiliter: with probability; by probable argument of the whole genus of quality. And yet they posit few other qualities of the third species of quality,9 since equally, because of the variation in the substance’s mode of having [itself], without any accident that could be of itself, the substance can be maintained [as the account] on both sidesutrobique: on both sides; 68for as light follows on the sun as an attributesubiectum / passio: subject / attribute on its subjectsubiectum / passio: subject / attribute, so the primary qualities follow on the elements; and as at the presence of the sun’s light, with a capacity in the medium, its radiance (lumen) or illumination naturally follows, so according to the variety of the mixture of the elements in the other mixed bodiesmixtum; mixta: mixed body; mixed bodies the secondary qualities follow, some regarding light or a past deed, as heats and passions,10 and others regarding figures, as softnesses and hardnesses, smoothness and roughness.11 One holding this opinionopinio: opinion, then, would posit all the qualities that the philosophers posit, and either none of them able to be of itself, or all.
¶768.12–69.5
They wonder, third, that those who so opine posit the unionunio: union, continuationcontinuacio: continuity [and] contiguitycontiguacio: contiguity of substance12 to be qualities that could be of themselves, on account of this principle: "there cannot be motion from contradictory to contradictory without the generation or corruption of a new thing"; and they do not say so of motion, time and the other relations. For if these three could be of themselves, then one may posit a distinct union of them, and so of continuation and contiguity without end. For there seems no reason why, for continuing A with B, a continuation should follow which is a distinct quality able to be of itself, without another, by the same token, following for continuing those continuations, and so to infinity. And, the lack of continuation being posited together with the immediacy of the things that can be continued, contiguity is posited without a new thing formally namingdenominacio; denominare: naming; to name it which could be of itself; and again, at the boundary of the things continued there would be infinite continuations of surfaces, lines or points; which the one who so opines denies. Nor will he give a reason why annihilationanichilacio; anichilare: annihilation; annihilate, transubstantiationtranssubstanciacio: transubstantiation and the like should be distinct truths, and 69so neither substances nor accidents, since they could be of themselves, without its being possible, by the same token, to posit other truths of the categoriesveritas predicamentalis: truth of the categories of twelve genera, as the philosophers once posited.13 And it is clear how greatly the error feigned about this sacrament troubles the philosophers.
¶869.6–69.21
Again, on this way no material substance would be proved conclusivelyconvincere; conviccio: prove conclusively; conclusive proof by philosophy, since every experience of the motion or transmutation of a subject, or of anything one might allegeallegare / allegacio: allege / allegation, could be saved without such a material principle; therefore it is in vain to posit such an imperfect substance, since neither reason nor experience proves it. For in this way infinite substances could be dreamt up without a reason that moves [one to them]. The assumptionassumptum: the assumption is clear according to those who speak so, since they posit that accidents can of themselves act and be acted on just as effectively as now, without a material substance lying under them. Since, then, according to the principles of the philosophers, what can be done by fewer is done in vain by more, and nature acts in the shorter way it can,14 it seems to belong to the natural philosopher to deny such perceptible material substance, and to posit some categoriespredicamentum: category of accident as sufficient for the end of nature.
Notes
- 1 Generaliter nova (66.3) is translated as printed; D reads sed generatur ("but a new one is generated"), which gives a plainer sense. The argument: either the old quantity is corrupted at every point, or a new, unconsecrated quantity is joined to the consecrated one.
- 2 Ex sibi dubio: "for all he knows", literally "from [what is] doubtful to him"; the same idiom as ex tibi dubio (70.25).
- 3 Signata a terra pedali (66.22): the a is taken as the logicians’ letter-label for the case (as A and B at 68.21), "a foot-long earth being designated a". If it is the preposition the phrase does not construe.
- 4 The subject of non habet (66.32) is taken as quality: rarity, density and the like are not qualities distinct from the subject. It could also be the earth, "that it [the subject] has no rarity of its own distinct from the subject"; the sense is the same.
- 5 Falsigraphi, "false writers", is the frozen row. The view that substance is quantified without a quantity distinct from it is not ascribed here; it is Ockham’s, De sacramento altaris c. 28 (ed. Birch 1930): Quod substantia sit quanta per suas partes substantiales sine omni quantitate quae dicitur res distincta realiter a substantia et qualitate.
- 6 The decree of the Roman church that bread and wine remain is Ego Berengarius (De cons. D. 2 c. 42, our modern form), cited throughout the treatise.
- 7 Quod negant: the theologians deny that prime matter can be without form, and their premiss implies it. Pure petitur quod probarent: "what they ought to prove is simply begged".
- 8 Figura here is shape, the fourth species of quality, and figuratum the shaped body: the claim is that a shape is nothing but the thing shaped. The frozen rendering is kept because Wyclif uses the same pair of the sacrament.
- 9 The species of quality are Aristotle’s (Cat. 8): the third is the passible qualities and passions, the fourth form and figure.
- 10 Calores (68.8) is the print; E reads colores, "colours", which answers better to lucem. Passiones here are the Categories’ passions (the third species of quality), not the passio "attribute" of 68.1.
- 11 Levitas beside asperitas is lēvitas "smoothness", not levitas "lightness": smooth and rough go with figure (Aristotle, Cat. 8).
- 12 The print has contiguacionem et substancia (68.13), which does not construe; C has subiecta in an erasure, and Loserth’s footnote gives recte: contiguacionem substancie, which is translated. G. Continuacio here is the act of making bodies continuous, as in the De incarnacione row.
- 13 Duodecim generum (69.2): "of twelve genera", as printed; which philosophers counted twelve categories is not said.
- 14 The print reads breviori modo quam poterit (69.18); ABCD read quo, "in the shorter way by which it can", which gives the commonplace (nature does nothing in vain, and by the shortest way) and is translated. The axiom frustra fit per plura is the schools’ commonplace (after Aristotle, Phys. I.4 and I.6: fewer principles are better). Ockham states it, with the rule that no plurality is to be posited nisi per rationem vel experientiam, in the very chapter that makes substance quantified without distinct quantity (De sacramento altaris c. 28). Wyclif’s nec racio nec experiencia (69.11) turns it against that view.
How the Latin of this chapter was established
- Plate readings; page · reading · note):
- 66: bipartita. (print as transcribed) [BT-ONLY]
- Variants (selected; page-foot apparatus, pp. 66–69): 66.3 D sed generatur (n. 1) · 66.11 D continue om. · 66.13 AB Christi om. (C in marg. alia manu); D esse relativum · 66.15 E quantumcunque; E per consecracionem · 66.23 E unitur · 66.28 E unita · 66.30 ABC esse sic · 67.4–5 C accidens om. · 67.6 B remanet · 67.11 D Et minor · 67.16 E qualiter · 67.20 D prima om.; AE possit; D negandum · 67.21 B illud debeat · 68.8 E colores (n. 10); ADE et potestates · 68.9 ABC mollies; D ut levitas, E et levitas · 68.13 substancia: C in rasura subiecta; Loserth recte: contiguacionem substancie (n. 12) · 68.15 E ad contradictoria · 68.18 ABC si om.; E potuerunt · 68.19 ABC illarum · 68.22 D respondetur; ABCD quesit, C corr. est · 68.24 D requiritur · 68.29 ABCD liniares; C punctales · 69.1 ABC nec om. before substancie; DE sic om.; E potuerunt · 69.4 AB hoc om. · 69.8–9 ABC aut quo, C corr. aliquo · 69.9 AB materia · 69.13 ABCD argumentum patet · 69.18 ABCE aget; ABCD quo (n. 14) · 69.19 B esse om.; ABCD philosophicum, D philosophicum veraciter · 69.20 D insensibilem; B exponere · 69.21 D predicamenta alia.