De eucharistia, chapter 4, part 8
The heaviness of the host, the vessel of the celebration, and the worth of the mass
Loserth pp. 110.22–113.28
¶1110.22–111.3
As evidence of this, the ordinary glossglosa: gloss on De consecratione, distinction 2, on the chapter Sacerdotes, says that this hosthostia; hostia consecrata: host; consecrated host is heavinessponderositas; ponderosum: heaviness; heavy but is not heavy.12 But all three ways aforesaid say that the sacramentsacramentum (the Eucharist); sacramentum altaris: sacrament; the sacrament of the altar is something heavy; and it is clear that those who understand falsely about this sacrament equivocate and 111err like idolaters, holdingsentire (an opinion: sensit quod): hold falsely about the Eucharist, since they falsely worship this as God in the signsignum / signatum: sign / thing signified, as if a man were to worship the devil in the likeness of the crucified.
¶2111.4–112.3
Nor is there doubt that error in such things accuses the one who worships falsely; and it is clear that it is necessary to treat this matter of the Eucharist, because without doubt one of these ways is manifestly heretical, since in a principal scripture, namely in the words of the Lord by which the host is hallowedsacer; sacrare: sacred; hallow, one of these ways holds very obstinately a sense contrary to the author of scripture, and lays aside the doctrinedoctrina: doctrine of Christ in things very necessary to salvation, and lays upon itself implicitly the authorization of a most wicked abomination; although famous doctors of the laws of the churchleges ecclesie: the laws of the church, making little of it, reciterecitare: recite among the opinionsopinio: opinion that breadpanis / vinum: bread / wine and winepanis / vinum: bread / wine remain after consecrationconsecracio: consecration; they argue towards it but do not disprove it, as they cannot, although they favour the false side more.3 If therefore those leading doctors of the laws of the church do not condemn as heretical that the bread remains, but prove that this followssequitur: it follows from the aforesaid law Ego Berengarius, it is likely (as before) that less skilled doctors will not attempt to pronounce hereticalcatholicare / hereticare: to declare catholic / to pronounce heretical this teachingsentencia: teaching / sentence;4 but however they have attempted it, I know that they cannot, since they cannot prove this teaching to be false.5 Therefore it does not matter in what vessel, good conduct being kept, the priestsacerdos / presbiter: priest / presbyter sanctifies; but (as has been said) one must stand by the appropriate customconsuetudo: custom of the homelandvia / patria: the way / the homeland and, decency being kept, call Christ to mind virtuously, for this is infinitely better than to celebrate.6 Nor is it out of tune that Christ should be sacramentallysacramentaliter: sacramentally in water or in another [liquid] mixed with wine, indeed in the medium of the air, but preeminently in the soul, since the end of this sacrament is that Christ should dwell in the soul through the virtuesmotrix (anima, virtus): moving;7 so that a layman calling to mind 112the body of Christcorpus Christi / corpus Domini: the body of Christ / the body of the Lord in heaven, better than such a priest consecratingconficere: to consecrate (the Eucharist), makes, more efficaciously and equally trulyvere: truly but in another mode, the body of Christ to be with him.8
¶3112.4–112.7
But the common people believe, exceedinglynimis: exceedingly unfaithfully and blasphemously, that this sacramental sign of the body of Christ is reallyrealiter: really Christ himself. And in this heresy the clericsclerus; clericus: the clergy; cleric and prelatesprelatus: prelate are entangled.
¶4112.8–112.10
And others, overcome by reason, say that this is blasphemous, a thing not to be touched on before the people, but that what is supremely impossible is to be preached to the people to stir up devotion.9
¶5112.12–112.18
But the truth knows whether greed for honour and gain from the laity is the cause of this blasphemy. But it does not stand against these things but accords with them, that it is expedient for the devout to celebrate often, since that man is very unfitindispositus; (se) indisponere: unfit; to make (oneself) unfit in whom the memory of Christ is not, from celebrating, imprinted more and more devoutly, and in consequence so that his prayer may profit the churchecclesia: church; and if this is lacking, it is expedient that such a one should not then consecrate.
¶6112.19–112.30
Hence it is expedient for the people to have many devout presbyterssacerdos / presbiter: priest / presbyter, but it harms them much to have vicious presbyters; hence it is false that the mass of any presbyter whatever is worth as much as the mass of anyone [else], since the mass is the aggregate of the whole ministry of the celebrating presbyter from sign to sign; which the common people measure by the time from when the priest is fully vested to the time when he has put off the chasuble. It is clear thus: one such mass is damnable and hateful to God, and another is meritorious and acceptable to God; therefore they are very unequal in value. This is clear from the fact that the more disowneddeacceptus: disowned by God the priest is, the more unjust is his ministration.
¶7112.31–113.10
Nor does the quibbleargucie; argucia: stratagems, quibbles; a quibble hold by which it is argued that that mass is Christ, or his part, who is equally good in both places, 113for there is exceeding equivocation about the quiddity of the mass. For not every presbyter has authorityauctoritas: authority to send the body of Christ to heaven or to draw him to the people, nor does he make the body of Christ, but he celebrates the mass after and before; indeed Christ existing in the midst of laymen who are gathered in his name is worth as much as Christ himself made present anywhere by any priest whatever; therefore it would be exceedingly frivolous to say that the goodness of the mass is reckoned by the goodness of Christ or of his part, because then the mass of a presbyter would in general be exceedingly good.10
¶8113.11–113.21
But about the equality of the host’s goodness there is a difficulty, since it is the sign of Christ and not his part; since therefore that host signifies, among other things, the unionunio: union of Christ to the church, and the sign of one who makes that union signifies it more efficaciously than that sign which hinders the union, therefore a sacrament of this kind is more efficacious in a good priest than in a bad one; and so are understood many decreesdecretum; decreta: decree; the decrees which command that a man should not hear the mass of a notoriously fornicating presbyter; therefore, I say, it is not to be heard, because it is hateful to God and man and harmful to the church.11
¶9113.22–113.28
From which it seems that not onlynedum: not only the mass but the host is better in one presbyter and less good in another; for as efficacious a sign as it is for calling the life of Christ to memory, so good a sacrament it is; now in one priest it is a more efficacious sign for this, and in another less efficacious: therefore in this way it is proportionally a better sacrament.
Notes
- 1 Loserth notes that the sentence does not stand in the chapter named, and refers to De cons. D. 2 c. 30; the right chapter, as C reads (over an erasure, another hand), is Si per negligenciam, c. 27, with the ordinary gloss at the word In terram (modern form ours), which Loserth quotes at 183.1: Dic quod ponderositas adhuc manet cum accidentibus aliis, et tamen nihil est ibi ponderosum. D and E read Sacerdotum.
- 2 The abstract ponderositas "heaviness" against the concrete ponderosum "heavy [thing]": the gloss gives the host the quality and denies that it is the thing that has it. The next sentence turns on the concrete term.
- 3 Ad quod arguunt: they bring arguments bearing on the remaining of the bread, without disproving it; "the false side" is the side Wyclif holds false. The canonists who recite the remaining among the opinions are not named here; they are the ordinary glosses cited at 107.22–108.1, e.g. that on X 3.41.6 Cum Marthe at transubstantiatis: Tertia dicit quod remanet substantia panis et vini et sub eadem specie est corpus Christi (Rome 1582).
- 4 Sentencia (context-dependent): the position taught, that the bread remains; "teaching", not a judicial sentence. Ego Berengarius is De cons. D. 2 c. 42 (modern form ours).
- 5 AB omit non possunt before probare; C supplies it in the margin in another hand. A has sed … sentenciam in the margin.
- 6 Servatis moribus is taken of the priest’s good conduct; it may instead mean "the usages being kept", which the next clause on custom would echo. Appropriate is the dative appropriatae with consuetudini, "the custom appropriate [to the place]"; ABCD read approbate, "approved". Patria is the earthly homeland here.
- 7 Alio mixto vino is construed "another [liquid] mixed with wine"; ABC read vel aliquo, "or in something". D reads animo for anima. C has sit … virtutes (111.31–32) in the margin in another hand.
- 8 Two comparatives stand side by side: melius quam iste sacerdos (the layman does it better than such a priest) and efficacius (the mode of the body’s being with him); eque vere sed modo alio sets equal truth against a different mode. Iste is taken as "such a [consecrating but undevout] priest".
- 9 The two gerundives are parallel: non est populo tangendum / est … populo predicandum, with summe inpossibile the subject of the second ("what is supremely impossible is to be preached"). Alternatively summe inpossibile est is a main clause, "it is supremely impossible [for it] to be preached to the people to stir up devotion".
- 10 Mittendi: a play on missa and mittere "send". Post et ante: before and after the consecration, which the presbyter does not make. In suo nomine congregantur recalls Matt. 18:20 ("gathered together in my name, there am I in the midst of them"). D reads mens equivocatur; ABCD in de quidditate.
- 11 The decrees are not named; the best-known is the canon Nullus missam audiat presbyteri quem scit concubinam indubitanter habere (Gratian D. 32 c. 5, Nicholas II, repeated by Alexander II in c. 6; modern form ours). At 113.15 E reads sacerdotis for facientis; at 113.20 ABCE read inquit for inquam.
How the Latin of this chapter was established
- Plate readings; page · reading · note):
- 111: adorantem; (print as transcribed) [SUB]
- 111: Beringarius, (print as transcribed) [SUB]
- 111: impericiores (print impericiores (bt imperiociores)) [SUB]
- Variants (complete against the page-foot apparatus for these lines; page.line · reading):
- 110.23: DE Sacerdotum; C over an erasure, another hand, Si per negligenciam (n. 1).
- 110.25: C has tres in the margin in another hand.
- 111.2: AB omit hoc. 111.4: D argitat (for accusat) false. 111.5: D omits patet.
- 111.10: B ad doctrinam. 111.14: D inter ipsos. 111.16: AB parte. 111.18: E maneat. 111.19: AB probat.
- 111.22–24: A sed … sentenciam in the margin. 111.23: AB omit non possunt; C adds in the margin, another hand (n. 5).
- 111.26: ABCD approbate (n. 6). 111.28: C quam in the margin, another hand. 111.29: ABC vel aliquo (n. 7). 111.30: D animo. 111.31–32: C sit … virtutes in the margin, another hand.
- 112.4: ABCD infedeliter. 112.5: AB corpus sit; C corpus Christi sit.
- 112.12: CE vel lucri. 112.13: ABD omit Sed. 112.16: D inprimis. 112.18: ABE quam talis.
- 112.20–22: C unde … alicuius in the margin, another hand. 112.21: B factum for falsum. 112.22: AB sint; C corrected.
- 112.25: AB presbiter seu sacerdos; C presbyter seu struck out. 112.29: AB omit est; B accepcior; D est esse debet. 112.32: D cuius.
- 113.1: D mens equivocatur; ABCD in de quidditate. 113.3: D in celum. 113.13–14: D signat. 113.15: E sacerdotis. 113.20: ABCE inquit (n. 11).