De eucharistia, chapter 5, part 5
Anselm and Augustine against an accident without a subject
Loserth pp. 131.14–135.2
¶1131.14–133.11
Hence,1 as Ambrose, Hugh and other disciples of the truth say, that the same essenceens / esse / essencia: a being / being (existence) / essence which before was not a sacramentsacramentum (the Eucharist); sacramentum altaris: sacrament; the sacrament of the altar afterwards becomes a sacrament by virtue of the words of Christ, and so, as to figurationfiguracio: figuration, is converted into the body of Christcorpus Christi / corpus Domini: the body of Christ / the body of the Lord, as Anselm says;2 and so the substancesubstancia: substance of the breadpanis / vinum: bread / wine and winepanis / vinum: bread / wine does not remain in act of consideration as before, as the philosophers say, who posit that the perceptible and time are put in act by sensationsensacio: sensation and intellection.3 For he did not understand4 that there is an accident without a subjectaccidens sine subiecto: accident without a subject, since in De veritate, in the last chapter, he writes thus: "For when the body exists its colour must exist, and when the body perishes it is impossible that its colour remain."5 For although he says it in the person of the disciple, yet he afterwards approves it, by positing a difference between colour and its subjectsubiectum / passio: subject / attribute, and rectitude and its sign. For rectitude does not depend on that sign as colour depends 132on the subject. For when Augustine and the other saintssancti: the saints speak in their dialogues as disciples, and pass on and do not reject [what is said], beyond doubt what they posit as disciples they approve as masters. Hence in confirmation of this teachingsentencia: teaching / sentence6 I allegedallegare / allegacio: allege / allegation Augustine above, that an accidentaccidens: accident cannot be without a subject, both in his dialogue and elsewhere. For natural reason teaches that there cannot be an accident without a subject, because there cannot be a subject without its accident; therefore much more the converse; for according to all who understand themselves, the bond and dependence of accident on subject would be greater than, or as great as, the converse. And the argument is clear from this, that if any creaturecreatura / creator / creatus: creature / creator / created is, then there is its dependence on God, which is an inseparable relation; and so a material substance cannot be without continuous and discrete quantityquantitas / qualitas: quantity / quality, without the relation of its parts to its every point, and so of infinitely many other accidents. Are we to believe that the analogous termanalogum: analogous term accident7 is naturally prior to the genus of substance, which is the base for every accident, so that accident can be throughout the whole world without substance, and not the converse? so that the genus of substance would depend on the genus of accident, not the converse; indeed, a species of material substance would depend on a body of the genus of quantity, not the converse, since they agreeconveniencia / convenire (in): agreement / agree with each other, as quantity can be rarefied and condensed to any degree, as they are forced to say in the Eucharist. And so substance can be changed as to quantity8 without the acquiring or losing of quantity, since quantity can be so; and so a point could be enlarged to infinity, since just as foot-lengthpedalitas: foot-length is foot-length by accidentper se / per accidens: of itself / by accident; (spatial) apart, by itself, so quantity is quantity by accident. 133But Augustine holdssentire (an opinion: sensit quod): hold far otherwise of quantity, as is clear in De Trinitate V, [chapters] 9 and 13;9 he speaks thus: "Just as therefore we do not say three essences, so we do not say three magnitudes." "In things," he says, "which are great by participation in magnitude, for which it is one thing to be and another to be great, as a great house and a great mountain and a great mind, in these things therefore magnitude is one thing, and that which is great from that magnitude another; and magnitude is not at all the same thing as a great house; but true magnitude in God is God himself, and not an accident to him."
¶2133.12–135.2
From these [words] the logicloyca (of speaking about the sacrament): logic of this saint is clear, which he uses in proving the distinction of the accidents. And it is clear, secondly, that he does not call accidents things that could be of themselvesper se / per accidens: of itself / by accident; (spatial) apart, by itself10 (as was said in chapter 3). And, thirdly, the error is clear of those who posit that the quantity of a creature of the first genus is not distinguished from its substance.11 For the error in the matter of the Eucharist casts them down deeper, to implying that every substance is God, because beyond doubt, if there is no distinction between the magnitude of a material substance and its essence, then (as Augustine argues) it is God; and I believe that the error by which an accident is worshipped as God has led into errors of this kind,12 blinding many in logic and metaphysics; and these are the ones who say "the sacrament of the altar is a quantity which is a greater or lesser time", as they say one hosthostia; hostia consecrata: host; consecrated host is a moment and another the Lord’s day, but a third they say is a week or a month; these so magnify their knowledge that they say they know now distinctly at what hour the final judgement will be; for they must say that this sacrament 134is a successive quantityquantitas successiva: successive quantity. For they set up for themselves as a principle this porismporisma: porism of the devil: "If any created beingens / esse / essencia: a being / being (existence) / essence is distinct from substance, then it can be of itself"; and from this they sink themselves in infinite errors, saying that an accident cannot be anything but an accident, just as a substance cannot be anything but a substance, because otherwise the quiddity of its nature would befall it;13 nevertheless "accident" can be understood in two ways, namely as a neuterneutraliter; adiective: as a neuter [noun]; as an adjective [noun] or as an adjective: understanding it as a neuter, the sacrament of the altar is an accident, but not in the second way, since it befalls nothing; nor does God supply the placevicem supplere / vicis supplecio: supply the place / the supplying of a place of the material cause in this, although every creature is accidentally in God, but there remains in the accident posited of itself a certain naturalness toward formally inhering; and so a certain accidentalityaccidentalitas: accidentality such as cannot be in a substance. But they would speak more consistently by positing that there is in every14 substantial formforma substancialis: substantial form a certain remote obediential naturalnessnaturalitas obediencialis: obediential naturalness, just as in every accidental form there is a certain remote obediential naturalness, that it should inhere in a material substance; for he who can so change natures that an accidental form exists and acts of itself, not onlynedum: not only producing accidental forms but substantial forms, which seems to be proper to natural substance: he, I say, can make substantial forms inhere in matters, most of all since he can wholly suspend the actuations of the forms that remain; which is more than to remit or change appetites and actuations. Therefore a man of this school would fear for himself lest he blasphemously deny the infinite, absolutely necessary powerpotencia: potency / power15 of his God. Hence I use this art: I do not admit such unusual cases, fearing blasphemies, unless it is proved to me that this is within God’s power; and that done, I am ready to grant what is proved, 135and things infinitely more excellent than they posit to belong to God and to his sacrament.
Notes
- 1 The period opens with ut loquuntur … quod ("as they say … that"), a construction that never closes: the quod-clause gives what Ambrose, Hugh and the others say, and the two et sic clauses draw from it. Translated as it stands.
- 2 Ambrose, Hugh (of St Victor) and Anselm are named without a work. Ambrose’s words on the bread made the body by Christ’s word are De sacramentis IV.4.15–16 (PL 16, 441: ut sint quae erant, et in aliud commutentur … post consecrationem … jam corpus est Christi), cf. De mysteriis 9.52. Hugh: De sacramentis II.8.9 (PL 176, 468: the bread’s substance nec … nihilum redactam … sed mutatam potius). Quoad figuracionem convertitur is Wyclif’s gloss on the Anselm De corpore Christi text quoted at 130.4–19 (panem … in corpus mutari), not a quotation.
- 3 "The philosophers": Aristotle, for whom the perceptible is in act in sensation (De anima III.2, 425b26–426a26) and time is not without the soul that numbers it (Phys. IV.14, 223a21–29). ABCD read sensibilem.
- 4 Intellexit: the subject is Anselm, just named; "understand" in the sense "take it that".
- 5 Anselm, De veritate, the last chapter (c. 13), in the disciple’s mouth; Loserth: Dial. De veritate, p. 114 (ed. Gerberon). C has perempto in the text, pereunte in the margin; DE omit esse; C reads a signo at 131.30.
- 6 Sentencia, the glossary entry, here "teaching": the position that an accident cannot be without a subject. The earlier place (superius) is ch. 3, 72.3–73.18: the dialogues De quantitate animae 4.6, where the words are the pupil Evodius’s, and Soliloquia II.12.22–13.23, and alibi the letter to Dardanus.
- 7 Analogum accidentis: accident taken as an analogous term, said of the categories other than substance by analogy and not as one genus; set against genus substancie.
- 8 Mutari in quantitatem, literally "be changed into quantity"; the run of the argument (rarefaction and condensation without gain or loss of quantity) asks for "as to quantity". Cum conveniunt invicem is taken of substance and quantity agreeing, so that what is said of the one is said of the other. E reads perdicione; DE posset.
- 9 Loserth: De Trin. V.8 and V.10 (Maurist ed. VIII, 838); the chapter numbers 9 and 13 are Wyclif’s. Loserth notes that Augustine’s text at sed vera magnitudo runs otherwise: Sed illa est vera magnitudo qua non solum magna est domus quae magna est et qua magnus est mons quisquis magnus est ("but that is true magnitude by which not only is a house great that is great, and by which a mountain is great, whatever mountain is great"). Wyclif’s form is translated.
- 10 Per se, the glossary entry: "of themselves", existing on their own without a subject. The reference is to chapter 3, 72.3–73.18, Augustine’s three testimonies and the refusal to gloss them nisi fiat miraculum. E omits res.
- 11 Quantitatem primi generis creature: the quantity of a creature in the first category, substance. Wyclif names no one; the position that quantity is not distinct from substance is Ockham’s, De sacramento altaris c. 28 (ed. Birch 1930; cf. 67.1).
- 12 Huiusmodi is Loserth’s; the manuscripts read huius, without modi ("into the errors of this [one]"). C reads cecantes.
- 13 Accideret: "befall", the verb of accidens: if an accident could be other than an accident, its own nature would be accidental to it. The adversaries’ position runs from Statuunt to inesse substancie, the distinction neutraliter vel adiective included; Wyclif’s answer begins at Sed consequencius.
- 14 Loserth prints cuiuslibet forme substanciali, which does not construe; C reads cuilibet, which is translated (it matches cuilibet forme accidentali after it). D reads conveniencius for consequencius.
- 15 Potencia, the glossary entry: God’s power, so "power".
How the Latin of this chapter was established
- Plate readings; page · reading · note):
- 131: prius fuit (print as transcribed) [SUB]
- 132: accidenti, (print as transcribed) [SUB]
- 133: IXᵒ (print as transcribed) [SUB]
- 133: IIIᵒ). (print as transcribed) [SUB]
- 134: poterit per (print as transcribed) [SUB]
- Variants (selected; page-foot apparatus, lines 131.14 ff.): 131.17 AB figuram (C corrected); 131.21 ABCD sensibilem; 131.25 DE omit esse, C perempto in the text, pereunte in the margin; 131.30 C a signo; 132.12 D quod econtra; 132.23 C et non econtra; 132.24 D species specie, D omits substancie, AB omit a; 132.28 DE posset; 132.29 E perdicione; 133.14 E omits res; 133.24 codd. huius without modi, C cecantes; 134.11 B omits cause; 134.16 D conveniencius; 134.17 C cuilibet (translated, note 14), D omits forme; 134.27–28 E vel actuaciones.
- Departure from the print: 134.17 cuiuslibet translated as C’s cuilibet (note 14).