De eucharistia, chapter 8, part 2
The absurdities that follow from multiplying one body
Loserth pp. 236.31–240.30
¶1236.31–237.2
From all of which is inferred the possibility of the existence of the same body through different places,1 and that the same 237body can be through the same place as many times as one pleases.
¶2237.3–237.9
But against this it is rejoinedreplicatur; replicatum: it is rejoined; rejoinder, first, by this: that such a body is only once through a given place, since after it once entered it, it never went out, as I suppose. Therefore, just as you were not a man as many times as you have eaten (as the logicians say), because you are a man once, continuously, so it seems it must be said that you are only once in this place.2
¶3237.10–237.16
This is confirmed from this, that otherwise every body would be in place infinitely many timesinfinicies: infinitely many times, for it could be drawn out of the place infinitely many times while it remains continuously in the same,3 and so many times is it in place; for as often as God drew it out of any place, so often would he find it in that place; which would not be, unless God put it in the same so many times.
¶4237.17–237.21
And let us speak of some mode [of "so many times"],4 not as it signifiesdicere (logical use): signify the alternation of time but as it signifies a multitude of natural order; and then one must say: "God cannot put a creaturecreatura / creator / creatus: creature / creator / created anywhere unless he puts it there infinitely many times."
¶5237.22–237.27
Likewise, it seems that every material substancesubstancia: substance is infinitely rare and with this infinitely dense, for it could be put through a given place so many times that it would be infinitely dense, and so dense is it now;5 and by the same token it would be infinitely rare in the case in which God drew it out infinitely many times.
¶6237.28–237.32
Likewise, it seems that every body intensified and remitted in qualityquantitas / qualitas: quantity / quality is as infinitely intensifiedremitti / intendi (of a quality, merit): be remitted / be intensified as remittedremitti / intendi (of a quality, merit): be remitted / be intensified, for by multitude and subtraction of itself from itself it could, with precisely the same quality, be of this [degree].6
¶7238.1–239.14
Again, it seems that every body is infinite in whatever bodily namingdenominacio; denominare: naming; to name of it;7 for a body can be infinite without the acquisition of any quantityquantitas / qualitas: quantity / quality beyond that which it has, and however great it can be, other things being equal, so great is it now: therefore every body is infinite. The inferenceconsequencia: inference is clear from this, that every quantity it can have, other things being equal, it has now. And the assumptionassumptum: the assumption is proved by taking A, a foot-longpedalitas: foot-length cube: then, it being multiplied through six places in which it touches itself along six different surfaces, and continuationcontinuacio: continuity being made, it is clear that A is equivalent to a six-foot quadrangle without any quantity being generated as a whole;8 I suppose again that each second proportional partpartes proporcionales: proportional parts of this A, with the whole residue, is multiplied through twelve places and continuation is made along unequal surfaces, and it is clear that A will be equivalent to one body double the six-foot one; and so to infinity in every dimension, this principle being asked for:9 "if there are two quantifiedquantus: quantified things and one is laid upon the other, and it neither exceeds nor is exceeded by it, then they are equal." For A is equal to the place or site through which it is so extended. Nor does it avail to say that a new quantity is generated, for none is generated as a whole, just as no surface, point or line is generated in A. Since, therefore, the greatnessprioritas; majoritas: priority; greatness of a quantity is reckoned by the multiplication of points,10 it is clear that A is not made greater in the case posited; and by the same token it would not be made less when it is again demultiplieddemultiplicare: demultiply; indeed, one half of A with its quantity being coextended with the other, and so to infinity down to a point-site, it seems that both 239A and its quantity will remain continuously equally great, for it will lose no quantity but will acquire some by accidentper se / per accidens: of itself / by accident; (spatial) apart, by itself. From which it seems that it will acquire or lose no magnitude, and so every quantified thing would be infinitely great and infinitely small; indeed, a world as great as this one is, and infinitely greater, could be constituted through a point. Who then knows whether it is so in fact, since it could be done more briefly with point-sized matter as regards blessedness or any end of itselfper se / per accidens: of itself / by accident; (spatial) apart, by itself? Nor does reason or experience conclusively proveconvincere; conviccio: prove conclusively; conclusive proof the opposite. How then would so great a multitude of things, superfluous by the abbreviated word of God, which orders means most compendiously to the ends it intends,11 be posited by a philosopher to whom there is no revelation?
¶8239.15–239.29
Again, by this way all measure of place would be taken away, as also every species of figures; for if God can so generally multiply the same body in number, he can also generally multiply site, place and figure. Nor do we know when he does so, since it would be more compendious, more philosophical and in every way more consonant with reason, if it were possible. God, therefore, multiplying a point-site through the whole world, could not locate anything more compendiously, for, the foundation granted, it would be the place for every creature, and so it could be, on earth,12 "all in all". This therefore being granted, it seems first that every place is indivisible and consequently none greater than another; for an indivisible site multiplied would be every place. From which it seems that nothing is greater than another as to bulk.
¶9239.30–240.2
Secondly, it seems to follow that nothing could, other things being equal, be moved locallylocaliter: locally, and there would be a full illusionillusio: illusion of the senses as to every sensationsensacio: sensation, and especially as to sight; for natural bodies would have their natural location 240and the sight according to which they would cause the appearance of motion.13
¶10240.3–240.10
Thirdly, there seems to follow an incompatibilityrepugnare; repugnancia: to be incompatible; incompatibility in terms, since it is only through an individual site not multiplied that anything whatever has its positionposicio / proposicio / predicacio: position / proposition / predication. How then is a site multiplied through the whole world, since every site would be everywhere, because in this indivisible site? And every difference of position would be taken away, and consequently every sign of day or night and every figure of a man, and infinitely many errors about them would follow; whose opposites are implied.14
¶11240.12–240.30
As to the differences of figures, it is clear that they presuppose the difference of site, which is taken away; for, A being designated a triangle that is half of a square, and it being multiplied through two immediateimmediatus; immediacio: immediate; immediacy places15 so that one end of A’s base is applied to the other end of the same base, so that continuation is made at its every point, it is clear that, the other half being annihilated, one square would come to be; and so a figure however great and of whatever species can be even through a single point multiplied; for, A, a point, being multiplied through every point-site that now is in the world, and the whole residue annihilated, it is clear that nowhere will site or figure be lacking. And the emptiness is clear of the response by which it is said that a figure is constituted only through quantity as a whole not multiplied; for if the same personpersona: person can be multiplied, filling sites equally as so many men [would], by the same token the same quantity and figure [can], for otherwise it would not be multiplication but the position of the person through one site.
Notes
- 1 Per diversa loca, per eundem locum: "through" keeps Wyclif’s per, a body extended through the place it fills; the same idiom runs through the chapter.
- 2 The rejoinder turns on the logicians’ adverbs of number (quociens … tociens): being in a place, like being a man, is held to be had once and continuously, not counted afresh. Comedisti is perfect, "you have eaten".
- 3 De loco ipso remanente continue in eodem: taken as an ablative absolute on the body ("while it remains"); ipso could instead go with loco ("out of the place itself, [the body] remaining …"). The sense is the same.
- 4 De aliquo modo is obscure; ABC read de alio modo ("of another mode"). Taken as a mode of the count tociens, which dicit (signifies) either succession in time or a multitude in the order of nature. Flagged as a doubt.
- 5 Et ita densa est modo: on the natural-order count of ¶4 the body is already put through its place infinitely many times, so it is already infinitely dense.
- 6 Esse huius ends the sentence without a noun; a word (gradus, "degree", or the like) may have been lost at 237.32. Supplied in brackets. ABCD read precipue for precise (237.31).
- 7 Denominacio is the naming of a body from its accidents (great, long, heavy); the side-note gives "attributes". Cum illis paribus: "other things being equal", here and below.
- 8 Secundum se totam "as a whole": no quantity comes to be that is new in every part; the cube’s six copies, joined (continuacio), cover six times the place.
- 9 Petito hoc principio: the principle is asked to be granted (postulated), not the fallacy of begging the question (glossary: peticio principii).
- 10 Punctualium (238.26), "points"; ABCD read multitudinem for multiplicacionem. Minoraretur is the print (C in an erasure); ABD minoratur (238.28).
- 11 Verbum Dei abbreviatum recalls Rom. 9:28, "a short word shall the Lord make upon the earth" (Vulg. verbum breviatum; cf. Isa. 10:23). Per verbum taken as "by [the standard of]" the word that does nothing superfluous; C has per … Dei in another hand (239.12–13), E superflue.
- 12 "All in all", 1 Cor. 15:28, "that God may be all in all", here of the multiplied point. Ad terram is odd ("on earth" is a guess; perhaps from super terram of Rom. 9:28 above); flagged.
- 13 The bodies would keep their natural location, and sight would show them a motion that is not there. B reads quem carent (240.1).
- 14 Quorum opposita implicantur: the opposites of those errors are implied (are true), so the errors are false; taken as the close of the reductio.
- 15 Loca immediata: places with nothing between them, adjoining (cf. immediate "without intermediary").
How the Latin of this chapter was established
- Plate readings; page · reading · note):
- 239: ymmo (print as transcribed) [SUB]
- 240: consequentur (print as transcribed) [SUB]
- Variants (complete for the lines of this chunk, pp. 237–240.30): 237.7 D simul; 237.8 AB solum om.; 237.10 D alter; 237.13 AB et quocienscunque, B namque without -que; 237.14 ABCD inveniret illum; 237.15 D ipsum poneret; 237.17 ABC de alio modo (note 4); 237.22–23 D subiecto fit, E substancia fit; 237.24 E quociens; 237.25 D illa; 237.26 E eam; 237.29 E fit; 237.31 ABCD precipue (note 6); 238.3 E apposicione; 238.4 C in an erasure quam iam habet; 238.5 E posset; 238.9 ABCD et argumentum; 238.10 D multiplicando, DE eum; 238.15 ABC A om.; 238.23–24 C nova — nulla in another hand; 238.24 C generatur om., C totum; 238.25 ABC pectus; 238.26 ABCD multitudinem punctualium; 238.28 ABD minoratur, C in an erasure minoraretur; 238.29 D multiplicate, D quo extensa; 238.29–30 ABCD mediante; codd. punctalem, C corrected; 239.4 E deperdet; 239.11 ABCD non fit; 239.12 E superflue; 239.12–13 C per — Dei in another hand; 239.15 ABCD iuxta hanc; 239.16 E potest om.; 239.17 B multipliciter; 239.24 C cuilibet om.; 239.30 B sequi; 240.1 B quem carent; 240.4 D indivisibilem; 240.12 AB illa; 240.13 C pre before supponunt in another hand; 240.14 C que; 240.14–15 E multiplicato eo; 240.18 ABCD mediante; 240.24 D sermonis; 240.25 D quia dicitur; 240.25–26 D per quantum; 240.26 D multiplicata. None is translated.