De eucharistia, chapter 9, part 5
The saints call it bread; the decree, the pope’s dispensing, and the truth of the words
Loserth pp. 288.11–292.14
¶1288.11–290.3
But many have said that it is impossible that this teachingsentencia: teaching / sentence about accidents is true. And so (to use the words of the critic)1 I ask who are those who presume to sow this teaching, without foundationinfundabilis; infundabiliter: without foundation and newer, against the definitions of the holy fathers which the Holy Spirit put in them. One must have recourse (I say) to one first [thing] which is to be the measure of all the others, since those are not to be believed because they are those,2 nor can it be taught that they, pronouncing so as such, were enlightened by the Holy Spirit. So far from us be the presumption of beggingmendicacio; mendicare; mendicitas: begging; to beg; beggary that we be believed as ourselves in this ancient teaching, laid asleep for a time on account of a sin which God knows; but [that we be believed] as heraldspreco (Dei): herald (of God) of scripture and of the saintssancti: the saints and ancient doctors who say it. Hence Lanfranc, in his little book against Berengar, confesses willy-nilly that the holy doctors, such as Ambrose, Jerome and especially Augustine, generally call this sacramentsacramentum (the Eucharist); sacramentum altaris: sacrament; the sacrament of the altar breadpanis / vinum: bread / wine and never accidentaccidens: accident, because (as he trulyvere: truly says) this sacrament has signs which naturally signify the form of bread.3 289Since, then, sacred scripture and the holy doctors with the law of the churchecclesia: church speak thus, we ought without doubt to speak so, in their sense, and to gloss them4 [as meaning] that by "accident of bread" they understand the bread itself, just as they on the other hand assert of us; and the manner of speaking can be founded on this, that the riches of the world, which in their natures are substancessubstancia: substance, are called accidents, because they befall or lie beside the rich themselves, just as it befalls bread that it is a sign of the body; so that sign is called its accident. Nor is there doubt that it is not an accident univocallyunivoce: univocally, as "accident" is restricted to the nine genera, or as the philosophers, Augustine and other saints speak. Hence I used to expound the adversaries [as meaning] that such an accident naturally signifies both the subject and itself, and signifies itself first causally but not as to inferenceconsequencia: inference;5 so the subject, by means of such signification of its accident, admits equivocallyequivoce: equivocally the predications of both; and since to one awake the signification of the accident cannot be laid asleep,6 but the distinct signification of the substance is laid asleep by reason of the body of Christcorpus Christi / corpus Domini: the body of Christ / the body of the Lord, so it is said that the accident remains without its subject in act; hence the philosophers call the universal, time and the perceptible beings in act through the soul, when they are actually apprehended, and otherwise they are called beings in potencypotencia: potency / power.7 But although that saying, as to the adverse teaching, was given more colourcolorare: give colour to, yet I do not know whether they had meant it. Hence, as to the first, on the decreedecretum; decreta: decree; the decrees of the church as to the faith,8 I wonder greatly how they do not see that no bishop (insofar asin quantum (reduplicative): insofar as he is of Avignon or of Rome) has powerpotestas: power to decide this, since he does not (insofar as he is such) have pre-eminently the knowledge of the faith of scripture or liveliness of reason; nor 290does he have, as such, pre-eminently grace or virtuemotrix (anima, virtus): moving to rule himself and the people in the faith of our Lord Jesus Christ.
¶2290.4–291.2
Nor is there doubt that for doing this work one or the other of these is required, or both. And the assumptionassumptum: the assumption is clear from many such bishops after the endowmentdotacio: endowment of the church, who were unletteredydiota: unlettered man heretics and chief Antichrists; indeed, though it be granted that whatever place they inhabit were full of virtue and grace standing of itselfper se / per accidens: of itself / by accident; (spatial) apart, by itself (so continually do they adulterate them),9 still all this would be irrelevant to them, since [what is needed is] to make these qualities informinformacio; informare: informing; inform, without which they avail nothing for the singular work of the Lord.10 Let them see, then, whether among those on the roadviantes: those on the road they follow Christ most closely, and of this let them rejoice together without boastingpompare; pompacio; pompa: boast; boasting; boasting, considering that according to their own traditions, distinction 20, chapter 1,11 as to causes to be decided according to their law their caesarean power is pre-eminent, but as to the truth of scripture and morals more credence is to be given to Augustine and the other doctors. Hence the teaching of Gratian in [Causa] 25, question 1, Ideo permittente Domino,12 seems unbelievinginfidelis: unbeliever; with a dative, faithless (to): that, "just as Christ was the lord of his law, and yet willed to obey it and to fulfil it, so the first see, so the pope, gives rightius: right / law and authorityauctoritas: authority to the canons, and sometimes shows himself lord of the canons, whether his own or others’, by commanding, defining or acting to the contrary"; "it is lawful" (he says) "for him to grant special privilegesprivilegium / privilegiare / privilegiacio: privilege / to privilege / privileging against general decrees. Indeed in every canon the condition is understood as impliedsubintelligere: understand as implied: unless 291the authority of the Roman church has commanded or permitted it to be done otherwise."
¶3291.3–291.17
And this teaching clearly teaches that all the decretalsdecretalis: decretal and decrees of the Roman church, insofar as they are not founded in scripture, are superfluous and unjust. Superfluous indeed, because they depend on the will of a person exceedinglynimis: exceedingly turnable to every kind of sin. The legistlegiste: legists therefore must consult his intention, which is the origin of the law, for his law is of no worth except insofar as it has been approved by him; indeed, since (whether the pope will or no) he permits the contrary of his law to be done, its efficacy is annulled and its superfluity declared. It is, secondly, unjust, because it is to be revoked whenever it pleases the pope, and it is not to be revoked unless it is unjust; therefore it is continually unjust in readiness.13 Since, then, we do not know the will or deed of that pope or of the earlier ones, therefore we rest in the faith of scripture, whose authority we know to be immovableimmobilis / immobilitas: immovable / immovability.
¶4291.18–291.23
Nor do we believe any other pope as to the faith, except insofar as he has founded himself in scripture, in which we know that neither Peter nor any other apostle usurped so great a lordshipdominium: lordship, but that they consulted God by lot when singular inspiration failed them. It is clear in Acts 1 of the election of Matthias.14
¶5291.24–292.14
As to the second, on the truth of the words of the sacrament, it is clear that they are most true, since they are the constant and wholesome teaching of the Lord of truth; and since bread or wine is demonstrated everywhere,15 and neither the said transubstantiationtranssubstanciacio: transubstantiation nor identificationydemptificare / ydemptificacio: identify / identification nor impanationinpanacio; impanacio: impanation can be, there remains only the tropical meaningsensus tropicus: tropical meaning, namely that this figuresfigurare: figure sacramentallysacramentaliter: sacramentally the body of Christ. And that bread or wine is demonstrated, the fourfold 292gospel sounds (as I have recitedrecitare: recite often); and the holy doctors say the same in accord, namely Ambrose, Jerome and especially Augustine, and others following them, as do the useusus (ecclesie): use and laws of the churchleges ecclesie: the laws of the church with those who write postils upon them, such as Rabanus, On the Sacrament of the Altar,16 and others, who all say that bread can be the body of Christ, will be and is the body of Christ, which they pray may come about.17 Now that would be most foolish unless this came about by the power of the sacramental words, and consequently unless bread were demonstrated in the words of consecrationconsecracio: consecration; and consequently it is necessary to add the aforesaid meaning to the words of Christ. Hence not only the newer doctorsnovelli: the newer [doctors] but also the community of human art cry out not onlynedum: not only that [the body is made] of bread, but that by the omnipotence of the word of God the bread itself will become the body of Christ.18
Notes
- 1 Reprehensoris: the critic of 287.13–15, whose question ("who then are we who presume…?") Wyclif turns back on the adversaries. Sentencia: "teaching" (glossary entry), the position taught.
- 2 Cum illi non sunt credibiles, quia illi: "because they are those [men]", on their own say-so; illi are those who call the teaching impossible. Unum primum has no noun: we supply "thing".
- 3 Loserth refers to Lanfranc, Opera, pp. 159, 163, 191, 192, and quotes: Quod vero panis dicitur: consueto sacrorum codicum more id fit, qui res quaslibet saepe vocant nominibus illarum rerum ex quibus fiunt ("that it is called bread comes about by the accustomed manner of the sacred books, which often call things by the names of the things from which they are made") (De corpore et sanguine Domini c. 20, PL 150, 438A).
- 4 Glossare eos: "them" taken as the adversaries, who gloss the saints’ "bread" as accident ("just as they … assert of us"); Wyclif returns the gloss, reading their "accident of bread" as the bread. If eos are the saints, "gloss them" is only "expound them".
- 5 Loserth: "this place seems to be corrupt" (289.13); E ad infirmos for adversarios, D signat for significat. Translated as printed. Prius causaliter sed non quoad consequenciam: prior in the order of causes, not in the order of inference.
- 6 The print’s vigili is taken as a dative, "to one awake"; the MSS read vigil ("the signification of the accident is wakeful and cannot be laid asleep"), to the same sense. ABCD sed signo (289.18–19).
- 7 Potencia: glossary entry, here Aristotle’s "potency" set against act.
- 8 "The first" of the three heads of 287.13–15, the decree; the second, the truth of the words, follows at 291.24; the third, the devotion of the people, at 293.33.
- 9 The print inhamarant (ABCD inhamerant) is no word; Loserth suggests incamarant (Du Cange: incamarare = adulterare), which we translate. Per se stante: "standing of itself" (the glossary entry’s first sense), virtue and grace taken apart from any subject they inform.
- 10 Quia facere qualitates istas informare has no governing verb: we supply "what is needed is". Virtue and grace in the place avail nothing unless they inform the bishop.
- 11 Decretum D. 20 c. 1 (modern form ours). Loserth: some words have dropped out here; the sentence does not occur in c. 1; compare the ordinary gloss on D. 20. The thought is Gratian’s dictum before c. 1, D. 20 d.a.c. 1 § 1: the expositors in sacrarum quidem scripturarum expositionibus eis praeponuntur, in causis vero definiendis secundum post eos locum merentur.
- 12 Decretum C. 25 q. 1 c. 16 (modern form ours), which Wyclif names by its incipit; the words he gives are Gratian’s dictum after it, d.p.c. 16 § 1 (Sacrosancta Romana ecclesia ius et auctoritatem sacris canonibus impertitur … seu iubendo, seu definiendo, seu aliter agendo, se decretorum dominos … esse ostendunt), whence his sentencia Graciani; "very loosely quoted" (Loserth). Ius: "right", the canons’ binding force, not "law".
- 13 Continue parate iniusta: "unjust in readiness", always ready to be found unjust, since every such law stands to be revoked at the pope’s pleasure.
- 14 Acts 1:23–26, "and the lot fell upon Matthias" (1:26). ABCE alio for alii (291.18).
- 15 Demonstratur: what the demonstrative pronoun of the words of institution points to; "demonstrated" throughout. AC read ubique nec sonat quadruplex evangelium dicta (291.27), displacing the next clause.
- 16 Rabanus, De sacramento altaris: Wyclif’s title; no work of Rabanus bears it. The matter is in his exposition of the canon of the mass, De sacris ordinibus c. 19, De ordine missae (PL 112, 1192), on ut nobis corpus et sanguis fiat: Quis unquam crederet, quod panis in carnem potuisset converti … nisi ipse Salvator diceret.
- 17 Quod orant ut fiat: "which [thing] they pray may come about", the bread’s becoming the body. D quod fiat.
- 18 The bracketed words supply the ellipsis of nedum quod de pane. Communitas artis humane: taken as the common way of speaking in the human crafts, which name a thing by what it is made of. C has addicere on an erasure (292.11).
How the Latin of this chapter was established
- Variants (selected from Loserth’s page foot; line numbers are the printed page’s):
- 288.18–19 D deceri. 288.20 D fuerant. 288.23 sopita: ABC sapita. 288.24 sanctorum: ABC scienciarum, C corrected in the margin sanctorum; DE et antiquorum. 288.30 D signant.
- 289.2 C sic (before loqui) in the margin in another hand. 289.5 ABC et post. 289.9 E corporis Christi. 289.10–11 ut accidens: C on an erasure; ABDE vel accidens. 289.13 adversarios: E ad infirmos; Loserth: the place seems corrupt (n. 5); D signat. 289.16 D signat; C significat on an erasure. 289.17 ABCD sue. 289.18 the MSS vigil (n. 6). 289.18–19 ABCD sed signo. 289.22–23 C omits actu — sunt. 289.24 ABCE et illud; D Secundum illud. 289.28 ABC videt. 289.31 ABC vivacitate.
- 290.1–2 D super se ipsum ad regendum. 290.5 assumptum: ABCD argumentum. 290.7 ABCD precipue. 290.9 D per se; D sic quod. 290.10 ABCD inhamerant; Loserth: rather incamarant (n. 9). 290.12–13 C Videant ergo viantes. 290.15–16 Loserth: words have dropped out after capitulo (n. 11). 290.17 D supereminet (OCR garbled). 290.22 D nolunt. 290.25 D suarum.
- 291.5 iniusta: AB in ista; C iniusta in another hand. 291.10 D vel nolit; D permittat. 291.14 C ergo — iniusta in the margin. 291.15 D pape duplicis; ABCE pape etc.; E et ceteris. 291.16 D vel prioris. 291.18 ABCE alio. 291.19 AC se fun-, C -daverit in the margin; ABDE omit nec. 291.21 C consuluit, in the margin consuluisse. 291.24 D Quoad primum. 291.26 AB omit sentencia; C adds it in the margin in another hand. 291.27 AC ubique nec sonat quadruplex evangelium dicta (n. 15). 291.30 ABCE partem Christi.
- 292.2 D concordanter. 292.7 D quod fiat; D aut. 292.8 E de virtute. 292.9 C omits nisi. 292.10 ABC demonstretur; D perconsequenter. 292.11 C addicere on an erasure.
- Plate readings; page · reading · note):
- 290: XXᵃ (print as transcribed) [SUB]
- 290: quandoque ostendit (print as transcribed) [SUB]
- 291: figurat (print as transcribed) [SUB]