De eucharistia, chapter 9, part 8
The co-multiplied accidents pressed, and the sophist’s argument from extension
Loserth pp. 300.6–304.14
¶1300.6–301.3
Again, every accidentaccidens: accident of a multiplied substancesubstancia: substance that is independent of anything extrinsic, of which kind are quantityquantitas / qualitas: quantity / quality and qualityquantitas / qualitas: quantity / quality, is co-multiplied with it; now extension, location and many relationalrespectus; respectivus: relation; relational accidents do not depend, in the body of Christcorpus Christi / corpus Domini: the body of Christ / the body of the Lord, on anything extrinsic; therefore all such are co-multiplied with it. For it would stand, as possible to God, that every body or quantity should be by itselfper se / per accidens: of itself / by accident; (spatial) apart, by itself without a greater substance, which they grant as faith.1 From which it seems that the extension of a quantity does not depend on anything extrinsic, as neither does figurefigura / figuratum: figure / thing figured, for which extension is required. And from these it seems that a multiplied body co-multiplies its place with it; for if God annihilated the whole remainder of creaturecreatura / creator / creatus: creature / creator / created, the body would be only in its own place; and there follows a confusion of places. And of positionposicio / proposicio / predicacio: position / proposition / predication, which is sitting, standing or lying, it seems that it is in [its subject] from within (as Gilbert of Poitiers says);2 for, Peter standing, Paul sitting and Linus lying, and the rest of the world annihilated down to them, they being continuously preserved unmoved, it would be hard to feignfingere (a miracle): feign how position would vary in them, since it is continuously preserved when the subject is moved in a cart, or when the poles of the world or its centre are annihilated. And the same seems [to hold] of distance, of immediacy and of the other relationsrespectus; respectivus: relation; relational, which it would be most evident are not preserved; for it may be that bodies most distant are infinitely near, since an infinitely long straight line, multiplied, could be intercepted between [things] however 301near, as is clear of the length of the body of Christ intercepted between any part of the Eucharisteukaristia: the Eucharist and another.
¶2301.4–301.27
Again, wherever there is quantity or quality to the body of Christ, there it is [the case] that it is so quantifiedquantus: quantified and qualified; and consequently, throughout the whole hosthostia; hostia consecrata: host; consecrated host it is [the case] that the body of Christ is seven feet long and gloriously qualified, as in heaven. And here the philosophers wonder (since a quality without a subject has its natural operation as efficacious as a substance so qualified) that the heavenly quality in the noble subject, the body of Christ, is suspendedsuspendere; suspencio: to suspend; suspension from action; and the unionunio: union by which the heavenly quality would be united in the host would strengthen the action, for according to the philosophers every powermotrix (anima, virtus): moving united is stronger than itself dispersed;3 indeed, since according to the teachingsentencia: teaching / sentence of the perspectivistsperspectivi: the perspectivists the form of the collectioncollacio: conferral / collection helps toward the action of light,4 and in the body of Christ, if it is there, there is a clarityclaritas (of the glorified body): clarity more splendid than the sun, and at every point the figure Mukephi, which according to Witelo is the most efficacious figure possible for gathering lights,5 it seems that it would act very perceptiblysensibiliter: perceptibly. And this perhaps moves those who say that they see in the host the body of Christ with the bodily eye; now the gospel says that it was granted alonesingulariter: alone, only / in a singular way / in the singular (grammatical number, Euch. 215.15) to apostles taken apart to see, namely, the glory of the transfiguration of the body of the Lordcorpus Christi / corpus Domini: the body of Christ / the body of the Lord before [his] death; therefore, since they do not say with Peter, "It is good for us to be here", it is believed that they lie about the vision of the four dowries of the body of Christ in the host.6
¶3301.28–302.6
And as to quantity, a faithful theologian, even a lay one, would not believe a preacher [saying] that the body of Christ is seven feet long in any part of the host whatever.7 Nor is there doubt that, 302if that seven-foot length of the body of Christ which is in heaven is there, it is there [the case] that the body of Christ is seven feet long; for it would be as incredible to the faithful that that seven-foot corporeity is there with the dimension of the breadpanis / vinum: bread / wine through the same place, as that the body of Christ is there.
¶4302.7–302.23
Again, they will not deny that the body of Christ is there divisible or great; for it has there head, feet and all the other organs, figures and positions of parts, lest it be a monster; and consequently a part is there less than its whole. For it is quite discordant to grant that Christ has there his feet above his head, all his inward parts outside his skin and all his organs turned inside out, although no greater impossibility is posited than that the quantity of the body of Christ is there with its subject; and since it does not informinformacio; informare: informing; inform there, as the accidents of the bread lack a subject and inform themselves, by the same token every part of the body of Christ would lack there the account of a part of the body of Christ, and so the body of Christ would be there lifeless and headless; indeed, the mouth of Christ and all his parts would be there indivisible [yet] quantified;8 and yet this need not be, since the whole quantity of the body of Christ is through each of its parts.
¶5302.24–302.32
But far be it from a faithful man to grant of his God the absurditiesinconveniencia; inconveniens: an absurdity (in argument) · troubles, ill consequences (in affairs) to which this heresy leads.9 For since the body of Christ has there quantitative partspars quantitativa: quantitative part distinct from qualitative partspars qualitativa: qualitative part, it must be that each kind of parts, as it has the name there, so has there the account of the name. And the confirmation is that the body of Christ would be there; merely (which is to the adversaries supremely possible) it would be great; how great, then, would it be there, if not as great as its quantity is?10
¶6303.1–303.7
Likewise, quantification is as spiritual a thing as quantity; since, therefore, quantity is there with figure, [it must be] that its informinginformacio; informare: informing; inform is there too; for otherwise one must blaspheme against God, saying that he can somewhere preserve quantity in a subject whose informing he indeed suspends, but cannot undo that suspension.11
¶7303.8–303.15
And in these I suppose from logicloyca (of speaking about the sacrament): logic that, if quantification will be anywhere, then there is a quantified thing there; for otherwise motion and every relation would be multiplied through the whole world. Infinite are such arguments, on account of which the catholic says that the body of Christ is there virtuallyvirtualiter: virtually and in signsignum / signatum: sign / thing signified: not the body of Christ as it is in heaven, but its vicarial sign, as was said at the end of the preceding chapter.12
¶8303.16–303.21
But against this it is objectedinstatur; obicitur: it is objected logically: for it seems, first, that the body is extended in the host, because the bread is there extended, and so [something] extended, because a thing extended; and so the perceptiblesensibilis (in the definition of animal): sentient sacramentsacramentum (the Eucharist); sacramentum altaris: sacrament; the sacrament of the altar would be the reality of the sacramentres sacramenti: reality of the sacrament, which is against the laws of the churchleges ecclesie: the laws of the church; and there would follow great confusion and incompatibilityrepugnare; repugnancia: to be incompatible; incompatibility of the things said before.
¶9303.22–304.7
As to what has been said, it appears how one must in this matter note the equivocationsequivocacio: equivocation which exclude contradiction and throw light on the variation of the answer, and especially the equivocation of predicationposicio / proposicio / predicacio: position / proposition / predication and of "the body of Christ". For according to tropical predicationpredicacio ydemptica / tropica: identical / tropical predication the saintssancti: the saints, with scripture, grant "the body of Christ is bread", or "a sign sacramentallysacramentaliter: sacramentally signifying it"; and in a conforming meaningsensus (of words): meaning they grant "the body of Christ is on the altar", and "mysticallymistice: mystically, that bread", and so "the body of Christ which is in heaven, born of the virgin and crucified, is on the altar": not [as] that body itself, nor anything 304identicallyydemptice: identically, but it is tropicallytropice: tropically a sign sacramentally signifying it. And so they understand the laws and the sayings of the saints: that the perceptible sacrament is not identically the body of Christ.13 And just as the sophistsophista: sophist rejoinsreplicatur; replicatum: it is rejoined; rejoinder, "the body of Christ is on the altar extended", by equivocating in the predication, as by taking the predicate in the neuter gender made a substantive, and yet the body of Christ is not extended there.14
¶10304.8–304.14
But secondly the sophist rejoins: "If this is extended there and this is the body of Christ, then the body of Christ is extended there"; and by the same token it followssequitur: it follows that the body on the altar is the body of Christ, since the bread is there which, wherever it is, is the body of Christ. For otherwise there would follow a confused multiplication of absurdities and an exceedingnimis: exceedingly entanglement of sophismssophisma: sophism.
Notes
- 1 Staret de Deo possibili is taken as "it would stand, as possible to God" (consistent with God’s power). Per se is "by itself", a quantity with no subject; sine maiori substancia, "without a greater substance", is rendered as printed. "Which they grant as faith": the adversaries hold the accident without a subject as of faith.
- 2 Gilbert of Poitiers, Liber sex principiorum, tr. II c. 5, De posicione (Loserth at 300.21, citing the 1512 Venice Organon: Sedere namque non magis est posicio quam accumbere neque minus); that it says position is intrinsic is not confirmed: the text was not read, and Albert’s commentary appears to discuss whether position inheres or only assists. Linus is Peter’s successor in the lists of Roman bishops; the three are an example.
- 3 "Every power united is stronger than itself dispersed" is a philosophers’ maxim, the school form of Liber de causis prop. 17 (16): Omnis virtus unita plus est infinita quam virtus multiplicata, which Thomas illustrates by many men hauling a ship together. Virtus here is "power", a faculty of acting, not moral virtue.
- 4 Sentencia is the position the perspectivists teach ("teaching"), not a sentence. Collacio is taken in its sense "collection", the gathering of rays, not "conferral".
- 5 Witelo, Perspectiva; Loserth (301.19) refers to Wyclif’s Sermones II, 385 for Witelo. The figure Mukephi is left as printed: Witelo’s Arabic name for the parabola (Perspectiva I.98: parabola, et est illa quam Arabes dicunt mukefi); IX.43 shows that a concave mirror of parabolic section gathers all the sun’s parallel rays to one point, where fire may be kindled.
- 6 Matt. 17:1 (DR "bringeth them up into a high mountain apart") and 17:4, where Wyclif omits Domine (DR "Lord, it is good for us to be here"). The "four dowries" of the glorified body are clarity, agility, subtlety, impassibility. Sed evangelium dicit is rendered "now": it brings the premiss closed by ideo. ABCD read quod bonum; ABC nobis.
- 7 Loserth (301.30) compares Jan Příbram, who quotes this sentence verbatim among the articles of Wyclif he rejects (quod fidelis Theologus etiam Laicus non crederet praedicanti, quod corpus Christi est septipedale), Professio fidei antiquae, in Cochlaeus, Historia Hussitarum, p. 540.
- 8 Os Christi is taken as os, oris "the mouth", with head and feet before it; it may be os, ossis "the bone". Indivisibiles quante is construed "indivisible [yet] quantified": parts that are quantified yet have no parts, as with an accident that informs no subject.
- 9 Inconveniencia is "absurdities", the unfitting conclusions of an argument, not troubles in affairs.
- 10 The sentence does not construe cleanly as printed; it is rendered as it stands, taking solummodo with foret magnum ("merely … it would be great"). A conditional may be meant: "if the body of Christ were there merely [as] great …"; a lost si is possible (302.29–31). D reads quod scilicet and quod ergo.
- 11 Quod sua informacio sit ibidem lacks a governing verb; "[it must be]" is supplied (303.2). D reads aliter servare; C bene dissolvere.
- 12 Signum eius vicarium, "its vicarial sign": the sign that stands in the body’s place, as sensus vicarius at 296.12. The reference is to the end of ch. 8.
- 13 Intelligunt leges et dicta sanctorum is taken with the saints (or those who grant these propositions) as subject. Another construal makes the laws and the sayings the subject: "so the laws and the sayings of the saints mean that …". The propositions granted are given in quotation marks, since their mode of truth is the matter.
- 14 Extensum taken "in the neuter gender made a substantive" means "an extended thing" (the bread), so that "the body of Christ is extended" is granted only in that equivocal sense. Et sicut … et tamen has no closing correlative; the English keeps the break. In C et sicut stands on an erasure.
How the Latin of this chapter was established
- Plate readings; page · reading · note):
- 302: partes (print as transcribed) [SUB]
- 303: capituli. (print as transcribed) [BT-ONLY]
- 304: ydemptice (print as transcribed) [BT-ONLY]
- 304: Christi (print as transcribed) [SUB]
- Variants (selected: those that touch the English): 300.7 B ad for ab; 300.14 D intensio; 300.17 locum in the margin, another hand; 301.8 D cum qualitas vel quantitas; 301.9 D operam; 301.16 ABC iuvat ad lacking; 301.24 ABC figuram transfiguracionis; 301.25 ABCD quod bonum; 301.26 ABC nobis, ABCD nobis est hic; 302.2 ABDE est before septipedale lacking (C on an erasure); 302.14 AB quam quantitas, DE impossibile quod quantitas; 302.29 D quod scilicet; 302.31 D quod ergo; 303.3 E oporteret; 303.4–5 D aliter servare; 303.7 C bene dissolvere; 303.8 D in loyca; 303.17–18 C quia … extensum in the margin, another hand; 303.24 ABC racionis variacionem, C margin responsionis, E responsiones; 304.1 D ydemptifice, C ydemptice in the margin; 304.4 C et sicut on an erasure; 304.9 E ergo corpus after tunc, D ibi lacking; 304.10 DE corpus Christi sit in altari; 304.11 D panis quicunque; 304.12–13 ABCE confusio.
- Departures from the print: none in the Latin; "[it must be]" supplied in the English at 303.2 (n. 11).