De benedicta incarnacione, chapter 2, part 2
The second Arian error, Christ without a soul; Augustine against Pascentius
Harris pp. 17.20–21.22
¶117.20–18.5
Second, the error of the Arians stood in this, that they say "Christ took up flesh alone, without a soul"; as Augustine recalls in his book On Heresies, heresy 49: "The Arians," he says, "named from Arius, are best known for that error by which they will not have the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit be of the same substance or naturenatura: nature; but they say the Son is a creaturecreatura / creator / creatus: creature / creator / created, and the Spirit a creature of a creature; that is, they will have him created by the Son himself. But in this, that they say Christ took flesh alone without a soul, they are less known. But Epiphanius did not keep silent that this is true, and I have learned it most certainly from their writings and conversations."1 And in this they agree with the Apollinarists, of whom Augustine writes, heresy 55, 18that they differ from the catholic churchecclesia: church concerning the soul of Christ, saying, like the Arians, that the Lord Jesus Christ took up flesh without a soul, and that the WordVerbum: the Word was in place of a soul: and so they glossglosare: to gloss the scriptures that speak of the soul of Christ, and [say] that the Word was converted into flesh, not that he took flesh from the virgin.2
¶218.6–18.20
And Augustine most elegantly destroys that heresy in letter 127 and the two following, to Pascentius, the Arian bishop; would that those of today attended to his sayings! For he writes to a captious heretic, [and] I do not think [he wrote] anything unguardedly over which he would fear a challengecalumpnia (ponere / capere): challenge (to lay a challenge against / to be open to challenge).3 "Since," he says, "the only-begotten Son of God the Father, our Lord and God Jesus Christ, after 'the fulness of the time was come', fittingly 'took up the form of a servant' for the day of our salvation; many things are said of him in the holy scriptures according to 'the form of God', many according to 'the form of a servant': of which, for example’s sake, I recall two, that each may be referred to each. According to the form of God he says, 'I and the Father are one'; but according to [the form] of a servant he says of himself, 'The Father is greater than I.'"4 For that saint did not know how to deny those scriptures in the proper sense of the wordsde virtute sermonis: in the proper sense of the words, since he grants that the personpersona: person of the Son is any one of many [things].5
¶318.21–19.4
And to this he next lays down two examples, than which God has not hitherto deigned to show men better, by which the heretic might be led by the hand into knowledge as much of the Trinity as of the incarnation.6 The first is thus. "Since," he says, "body and soul are one man, although body and soul are not one, why are not the Father and the Son much more one God, since the Father and the Son are one, according to that voice of the Truth, 'I and the Father are one'?" "Since," he says, "the outer man and the inner man are not one, nor is the outer of the same nature as 19the inner; for the outer, with the body so named, is called man, but the inner is understood as the rational soul alone; yet both of them together are called not two men but one: how much more are the Father and the Son one God?"7
¶419.5–19.25
The second example is about universaluniversale; ydea: universal; idea nature. "Men," he says, "through the fellowship and communion of one and the same nature, by which all men were one, even if at some time, according to diversities of wills and of teachingssentencia: teaching / sentence, opinions and dissimilarities of manners, they were not one, will yet be perfectly and fully one when the end is reached, that 'God may be all in all.'"8 And so it is not possible for men to be one in charitycaritas: charity or in another accident unless they are first one in substance or nature: as he makes cleardeclarare / ostendere: make clear / show in the first and third books against Maximinus, chapter 22. And that many men are one in substance or nature he proves by that [text] of the Apostle, 1 Corinthians 3, said of Paul and Apollo: "he that planteth and he that watereth, are one." Hence the Truth, John 17: "I do not pray (he said) that they and we may be one," but "that they may be one, as we also are one": not only in nature, which was already true, but also [one] of perfect charity and justice, according to the capacity of their nature, as far as can be in the kingdom of God; so that thus they may be supremely one in their nature, as the Father and the Son are supremely one in an incomparably better nature. "Never," he says, "do we read of any things that they are one, unless they are of the same substance or nature."9
¶519.26–20.13
And without doubt Arius, Sabellius, and very many heretics were blinded in that error about universals. Therefore Anselm, On the Incarnation, [chapter] 1, calls those who deny universals on the part of the thing, outside signs, heretics of dialectic.10 Hence Pascentius the Arian, after 20he had called Augustine one kindled with error, as one plunging himself into muddy water, and like a crooked and knotty tree that has nothing of straightness in it, writes what moves him to distort the teaching of Augustine, who confessed his faith to him in writing. For among other things blessed Augustine wrote to him that "the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit are one God". "Which," says Pascentius, "of the three persons is the one God? Or is there perhaps one three-formed person who is called by this name?"11 If this heretic had known how a single common humanityhumanitas: the humanity is each person of man, he could easily have seen how a single Godheaddeitas / divinitas: the Godhead / divinity, essenceens / esse / essencia: a being / being (existence) / essence, substance, or divine nature is three persons and each one of them.
¶620.14–20.20
Sabellius too, if he had seen that distinction of persons stands with unity of nature, so that he would not have been blinded in that most foul paralogismparalogismus: paralogism (Peter is the nature of the speciesnatura specifica: the nature of the species; Paul is the same nature of the species; therefore Peter is Paul), would have seen that it is not necessary that the Father be the Son, although each is the same most simple substance.12 And so of the other heresies sprouting for lack of the logic of the scriptures.
¶720.22–21.22
For many desire to authorizeautorizare: authorize a new logic foreign to scripture, and hence they say that they correct it as impossible by the force of the wordsde vi vocis / de vi sermonis: by the force of the words.13 And Augustine recalls that against the said Pascentius. For against those who deny the scriptures about Christ he speaks thus: "Men," he says, "who understand too little what is said on account of what, headlong want to have their views; and, the scriptures not having been diligently searched, they seize on the defence of whatever opinionopinio: opinion, and from it they are turned aside either never or with difficulty, while they desire to be thought learned and wise rather than to be so. For the things that were said on account of the form of a servant 21they want to transfer to the form of God."14 "This name," he says, "Jesus Christ, was assumedassumere / assumpcio (naturam): assume / assumption from the dispensation of mercy and of the humanity taken up, because the very Son of God was made son of man, not by changing what he was, but by assuming what he was not." And he proves at length from the scriptures that both Christ and the Holy Spirit are the same God with the Father, and specially by that [text] of the Apostle, 1 Corinthians 8: "We know that there is no God but one. For although there be that are called gods many and lords many, yet to us there is but one God, the Father, of whom are all things, and we in him: and one Lord Jesus Christ, by whom are all things, and we by him."15 From this it plainly followssequitur: it follows, for one who is not obstinateprotervus: obstinate, that Christ is the same God with the Father. Hence those skilled in scripture say that "god" and "lord", taken by itself, is said by antonomasiaautonomatice / antonomastice: by antonomasia (pre-eminently) of God and of the Lord of lords.16 Yet I know that the obstinate man can, as today, deny any part of scripture in the proper sense of the words, and say that "the Word was God" nuncupativelynuncupative: nuncupatively, and that all things were not made by Christ, but all things short of him; and so he is God and ensouled, but neither God of gods nor ensouled univocallyunivoce: univocally with us.17 But even the heretics did not so play the sophistsophisticari: to play the sophist, not so denying scripture as today, since they were better grounded in logic and metaphysics than our own people.
Notes
- 1 Augustine, De haeresibus 49 (the Arians), citing Epiphanius (PL 42, 39; verified), quoted closely but shortened: Augustine also glosses substantia as essentia, οὐσία. T. stetit (17.20): B M stat; suscepisse: O M suscipere.
- 2 Augustine, De haeresibus 55 (the Apollinarists), PL 42, 40 (verified), freely: in Augustine the Apollinarists, pressed by the Gospel, grant a soul and deny it only the mens, pro hac ipsum Verbum in eo fuisse; his verb is dissenserunt. C. et Verbum in carnem fuisse conversum still hangs on dicentes, across the clause et sic glosant … Christi; hence "[say]". T. differunt (18.2): A B C discesserunt "departed", O disserunt.
- 3 Augustine’s letters to Pascentius ("letter 127 and the two following"; O Ep. 21 vel 5), in the Maurist numbering Ep. 238–241 (PL 33, 1038–1052; 240 is Pascentius’s own letter); the quotation that follows is Ep. 238.10, PL 33, 1042, where Augustine has accepit for Wyclif’s suscepit (verified). Wyclif’s number 127 is not traced. C. non puto … formidaret is read as Wyclif’s comment on Augustine’s care; A B C, with formidarem and a stop before Non, make it first person, perhaps Augustine’s own words: "I do not think [I wrote] anything unguardedly over which I should fear a challenge."
- 4 Gal. 4:4; Phil. 2:6–7 (suscepit for the Vulgate’s accipiens); John 10:30; John 14:28. The opening Quia clause has no main clause: the period runs on into de illo multa … dicuntur.
- 5 Nescivit … negare: "did not know how to deny", that is, would not have it in him to deny. Personam Filii … esse multorum quodlibet: the person of the Son is each of the many things scripture says of him, God and servant alike. A B C persona would make the person the subject of concedit, which does not construe; O concedat.
- 6 non (18) is omitted by A B, which reverses the sense ("by which God has hitherto deigned to show men better things"); the print is kept.
- 7 unus homo … non sunt unum: the masculine unus (one man) is set against the neuter unum (one thing): body and soul are one man without being one thing, and the Father and the Son are unum (John 10:30). Exterior cum corpore nuncupato: "the outer, with what is named the body"; C reads interior comunia … exterius. T. racionali (19) is O’s reading, printed against A B C racionabiliter "is reasonably understood as the soul alone".
- 8 sentenciarum: Augustine’s plural, the differing views men hold; the row’s "teaching". T. erunt (19): A B C erant, which loses the future the argument needs; O omits erant … unum. S. 1 Cor. 15:28.
- 9 Augustine, Contra Maximinum (printed Maximinianum), "books 1 and 3, chapter 22" (A B C 23). Wyclif apparently counts the Collatio cum Maximino as book 1 and the two books Contra Maximinum as books 2 and 3. Book 1 is then the Collatio, PL 42, 722 (Qui plantat et qui rigat unum sunt … sed ambo homines erant, ejusdem substantiae; Non dixit, Ut ipsi et nos unum), and book 3, chapter 22 is Contra Maximinum II.22.1, PL 42, 792. That chapter gives the argument that men one in charity must first be one in nature, non solum natura … meliori natura nearly word for word (Augustine potuerint, as A B C), and the challenge that Wyclif condenses as Nunquam … legimus (verified). The Homines … omnia in omnibus before it is Ep. 238.13, PL 33, 1043; 1 Cor. 3:8; John 17:11, 22. Non rogo ut ipsi et nos unum simus is not in the Gospel: it is the exegete’s negative gloss, set against ut ipsi unum sint. T. The print’s quotation marks open at Homines (19.5) and close only at nature (19.25); the English closes Augustine’s words at "all in all" and quotes the last sentence, which carries its own inquit. Non solum natura … meliori natura is Augustine’s argument, unmarked. A B C read sumus. Sumus enim non solum unum natura quod verum est iam; perfecte caritatis is a genitive without its noun, hence "[one]".
- 10 Anselm, Epistola de incarnatione Verbi 1, on the "heretics of dialectic" for whom universal substances are only a breath of the voice: c. 1 (Schmitt II, 9–10; PL 158, 265A, Migne’s c. 2), dialecticae haeretici, qui non nisi flatum vocis putant universales esse substantias (verified). Ex parte rei extra signa: in reality, apart from the signs that signify them (O signum).
- 11 Pascentius’s abuse of Augustine and his question, from Pascentius’s own letter, Ep. 240 (PL 33, 1051): sicut sitiens nimio calore accensus, si invenerit aquam coenosam et se inde ingurgitaverit … sicut arbor curva et nodosa, and Quis e tribus unus Deus? an forte est una persona triformis, quae hoc nomine nuncupetur? (verified). Wyclif makes the heat that of error and adds personis. C. Quis, inquit, Pascencius: Pascentius is the subject of inquit, and the question his; it is the "what moves him" of the sentence before.
- 12 quod (20.15), with A B C O, against the print’s quoque ("so also"): "so that he would not have been blinded"; the clause becomes the result of his seeing, and vidisset the main verb. G. natura specifica: the nature of the species, as in ydemptitas specifica; not "a particular nature". The paralogism treats the common nature, which each is, as if it were the person.
- 13 se ipsam corrigere: ipsam is taken as scripture, which they "correct" as impossible when taken by the force of its words; it could refer to the new logic, which makes no sense of corrigere. De vi vocis is kept apart from de virtute sermonis (17).
- 14 Augustine to Pascentius, on those who transfer to the form of God what is said of the form of a servant: Ep. 238.14, PL 33, 1043 (verified); the PL prints patentes where Wyclif has precipites. The print opens a quotation at Homines and a second at Hoc, inquit without closing the first; the English closes it at "form of God".
- 15 "This name Jesus Christ …": Augustine to Pascentius, Ep. 238.18, PL 33, 1045, joined to 238.21, PL 33, 1046 (quia ipse Filius Dei factus est Filius hominis, non mutando quod erat, sed assumendo quod non erat) (verified). Augustine’s 1 Cor. 8:5–6 there has sive in coelo, sive in terra and nos in ipso, so A B C’s addition and Wyclif’s ablative are his. 1 Cor. 8:4–6, with Wyclif’s departures translated: he omits idolum nihil est in mundo, and sive in caelo sive in terra siquidem sunt (which A B C add); nos in illo for the Vulgate’s nos in illum (DR "we unto him").
- 16 non protervo: a dative, "for one who is not obstinate". Authonomatice: by antonomasia, the common noun used as the proper name of the one it fits par excellence.
- 17 quod Deus erat verbum nuncupative is John 1:1 (Deus erat Verbum) held to be true "nuncupatively", by naming only; per Christum non sunt omnia facta sed omnia citra ipsum turns John 1:3. T. et sic … animatus (21) is omitted by B; A lacks ac, with an erasure of two letters. O reads anima for the second animatus.
How the Latin of this chapter was established
- Plate readings; page · reading · note):
- 18: de (print as transcribed (de se ait, next line)) [SUB]
- 19: Maximinianum (print as transcribed (next line)) [BT-ONLY]
- 19: verum, sed (print as transcribed) [SUB]
- 19: summe unum (print as transcribed (next line)) [BT-ONLY]
- Omitted per §3.5 / kept in the English (margin matter): reference Johnx. 30. (18.17); reference Johnxiv.28.de (18.18); reference Johnx. 30. (18.29); reference ad Cor. 3° (19.18).