De potestate pape, chapter 11, part 9
Custom, human tradition and the law of God; no secular gradation in the clergy
Loserth pp. 294.3–299.5
¶1294.3–299.5
Yet it is granted that from that, as from any evil, a certain proper benefit accrues to the churchecclesia: church. But (to use the Apostle’s words) God forbid that those evils should therefore be done.1 Further, it is granted that the praiseworthy customconsuetudo: custom of the church is to be observed, although it is not explicit but implicit in scripture; for the law of Christ would be too diffuse and burdensome if all such rites, usages or customs were expressly in it.2 Therefore it is to be believed that the Holy Spirit expressed the things more necessary to the church, and covered the lighter things together under a certain indistinctconfuse / confusus (fides, noticia): indistinct(ly) wrapping, as is clear in 1 Cor. 14:40; the Spirit says through his Apostle: "Let all things be done decently and according to order." In this are included all the usages of the church in saying service, all the rites of the private orders, and, in brief, every praiseworthy custom, clerical or lay. And at this point the greater irreligionirreligiositas: irreligion of the Christian people creeps in: that, setting aside the more preponderant things expressed in the law of the Lord, human traditions and inventions are made to preponderate, some of them heretical and some to be observed in their order. For as scripture teaches us to know these things preponderantly, so [it teaches us] to observe the least thing expressed in the law of the Lord on pain of incurring a greater penalty than anything sacred that is expressed singly in usage, or any rites, even introduced in orderly fashion among the religiousreligiosi: the religious or lay people, newly, beyond the expressed faith of Christ.3 And in this the church is blinded and burdened beyond measure, because either irrational things are introduced or rational things are weighted too much. Hence the Decretum, in distinction 12, under the 295authority of Augustine, To the Inquiries of Januarius, speaks thus (as I have often repeated): "All such things as are neither contained in the authorities of the holy scriptures, nor found established in the councils of bishops, nor strengthened by the custom of the universal church, but vary innumerably according to the diverse manners of diverse places, so that the causes which men followed in establishing them can scarcely or never be found — where the opportunity is given, I judge that they are to be cut off without any hesitation. For although it cannot be found how they are against the faith, yet they so weigh down with servile burdens religion itself, which the mercy of the Lord willed to be free, with very few and most manifest sacraments of celebration, that the condition of the Jews is more tolerable: for they, even though they did not know the time of liberty, are yet subject to the sacraments of the law, not to human presumptions."4 From these things it seems, first, that our pharisees weigh down the church with traditions, sectsreligio privata; secta: private religion; sect and exactions more unbelievinglyinfidelis: unbeliever; with a dative, faithless (to) than the pharisees of the old law had done. For they burdened more sparingly on every side; they gave preponderance to the moral precepts of the law, and when the thing figured came they saw that the figures ceased. But our pontiffs, scribes and pharisees magnify unbelieving traditions of men even beyond the traditions which God instituted, since they say that these must cease if they savour of burden and not of gain; but their own traditions, which savour of honour or temporal gain, they say cannot cease, although they are contrary to the traditions and to the life of Christ, since by them things are consecrated, and from that consecration it is not lawful to withdraw; but to diminish the liberty which is the true privilegeprivilegium / privilegiare / privilegiacio: privilege / to privilege / privileging of the church, through false men — I say, not clerics but unlearned menidiota: unlearned man, ignorant ofignorare: to be ignorant of their own word — 296would be a mark of unbeliefinfidelitas: heathenism, unbelief in a disciple of Antichrist.5 For when the reason for the deed is asked of them, either they stammer, saying in Mahomet’s manner that the reason for their tradition ought not to be given or disputed, since the will of the headcaput: head suffices by itself;6 or they argue from an insufficient likeness to the old law; or they allegeallegare / allegacio: allege / allegation without foundationinfundabilis; infundabiliter: without foundation the laws of man, as that a jurisconsult or a satrapsatrapa: satrap so defines; and (as they say) it is not lawful to seek a reason, as in God’s law, but one must stop at them as at a first principle. But the secularsecclesia laycalis / secularis: the lay church / the secular church see to it that their laws accord with God’s law, because [they accord] with utility and reason, since they profess in catholic fashion that every law or rite of man which does not have its beginning from it is heretical and to be fled like poison.7 From which it is clear that God’s law ought to be learned first by every catholic. What, I say, is another law to the faithful man? Hence God’s law has been sophistically mixed with human traditions, namely so that the tradition may be cloakedpalliacio; palliare: cloaking; to cloak and observed more colourably. Let the faithful man, therefore, observe the justice of the law, and prepare himself to suffer wrongs and penalties for the omission of the laws of men. For this speeds the wayfarerviator: wayfarer directly to his end, and the opposite leads him astray or delays him. It is granted, therefore, that rites and laws decently drawn off from the law of the Lord are to be observed in their order. But let the Christian beware of excess in the study and observance of them; suspendedsuspendere; suspencio: to suspend; suspension, then, on the law of God, without further anxiety, let him be content with the breath of the Spirit, which directs without these extravagants.8 What, I ask, is a gentile or pharisaic riteritus: rite to the faithful man, except in so far as it modestly makes easier the observance of God’s law? Hence those sinned gravely who introduced 297sects and distinctions of the laws of the church, by which the meditation of God’s law is diminished; since it would be better that the apostolic life were purely observed, and that, difformity set aside, men tended to the uniformity of the state of innocence, although gradationgraduacio; graduati: graduation / gradation; graduates in secular lordshipdominium: lordship is lawful and necessary, sin being supposed.9 Hence nothing is more unbelieving than to inferconcludere: to infer from the gradation of secular lordship a gradation of secular exercise of lordshipdominacio: exercise of lordship and honour among clerics. For since that state is higher, more conformed to the state of Christ and of the saints, it must tend to greater unity, ruling the lay state, and not be modelled on a state so difform as the one it rules. Yet it is granted that there are degrees in that apostolic state, but contrary to the secular state; for here the greater is the poorer, the more serviceableservitivus: serviceable, and the better fitted to run on pilgrimage with fewer temporal goodstemporalia: temporal goods. Hence all presbyterssacerdos / presbiter: priest / presbyter ought to be fellows, as the Apostle teaches, together with the decree, concerning himself and Peter; nevertheless the servant becomes higher out of greater humility.10 Hence (as I have often said) the lay part is divided into the popular part and the secular part set over it, of which the first is good and the second better. But the clerical part, because of its fellowly uniformity, remains undivided and the best, which "Mary hath chosen";11 hence those stammer dangerously who say that kings are not lords of their kingdoms but bare defenders, or otherwise (as they say) one would have to grant degrees of such lordship among clerics. Let these men search the scriptures, and they can see how often the author of scripture, by word as well as by deed, grants lordship to those of the middle state, since he himself obediently gave tribute to Caesar, but excluded lordship from himself and his apostles and their successors, 298as is clear above.12 Let them judge, therefore, between the evidencesevidencia: evidence: "God forbids lordship to the priest of Christ and gives lordship to the secular; therefore so it ought to be." And: "Caesar, or the papal law, denies that lordship belongs to the secular, and says that any secular lordship whatever ought to belong to the pope and the bishops; therefore it is true."13 And so with these arguments from likeness: "Christ excluded himself and his apostles from secular lordship; therefore by the same token this ought to be observed by his vicars"; and "Secular lords and prelatesprelatus: prelate claim civil exercise of lordship for themselves, the first lawfully and the second by false usurpation; therefore by the same token all clerics ought to exercise lordshipdominus; dominari: lord; to exercise lordship / to lord it in this way." Into such reedy quibblesargucie; argucia: stratagems, quibbles; a quibble break out those who thirst for secular lordship; and such confusion must be multiplied in Christ’s clergyclerus; clericus: the clergy; cleric, as it was in part multiplied in the clergy of the old law, until Antichrist has destroyed his members.14 Therefore, since one must act as is fitting according to the variation of place and time, it is clear that while the malice of covetousness reigns we must follow Christ’s way the more diligently; for when a greater danger threatens, the one in peril ought to lean the more on aid. For so did Christ the priest, coming in the highest degree of renunciation of propertyexpropriacio: renunciation of property, when the covetousness of the priests reigned most. And this is the Apostle’s reason, as I expounded before: "Redeeming," he says, "the time, because the days are evil."15 Hence the degenerate blaspheme exceedinglynimis: exceedingly who say that it is as useful and as fitting for the state of the clergy now to be enrichedditare: to enrich further as the power of working miracles was necessary in the primitive church. In truth, then, neither the possessionedpossessionatus (adj.): possessioned clergy nor a layman would give bodily almselemosina: alms to a beggar, just as the apostles would not diminish anything of the power of working 299miracles; indeed, the power which the Evangelist had "to change fragments of the stones of the shore into gems and the leaves of the woods into gold" would be more useful to the world than any temporal possession whatever, as even Simon Magus would testify.16
Notes
- 1 Allusion to Rom. 3:8 ("let us do evil that there may come good? Whose damnation is just"), not a quotation; absit is Paul’s formula ("God forbid", e.g. Rom. 6:2).
- 2 The argument requires "too diffuse and burdensome" (nimis); the print (plate-confirmed) has minus "less", which inverts the argument; we read nimis (our emendation; Loserth gives no variant).
- 3 At 294.26 Loserth marks sacrum "ita cod." (so the manuscript): he doubted the word but printed it. C. Sacrum is neuter and agrees with aliquid (usu sacro would be needed for "sacred usage"); Loserth marks it ita cod.. Anything sacred that has come in by usage is set against the least thing expressed in the law of the Lord.
- 4 Decretum D.12 c.12 (Omnia talia), from Augustine, Ep. 55.19.35 to Januarius; the identification is ours; Wyclif’s legalibus tamen sacramentis follows Gratian’s text, where Augustine has sarcinis. Loserth’s italics bound the quotation, as here.
- 5 The clause deminuere autem libertatem … foret nota infidelitatis discipulo Antichristi is taken as Wyclif’s own judgement: to diminish the church’s true liberty (Augustine’s "free" religion) marks a disciple of Antichrist. It could also continue the pharisees’ reasoning ("it would be, they say, a mark of unbelief"). Vocem propriam ignorantes: they do not know what their own name (clericus) means; perhaps "their own language".
- 6 Machometice, "in Mahomet’s manner": Wyclif’s charge that Islam forbids its law to be disputed. Voluntas capitis: the head is the pope.
- 7 Seculares are here the secular lords and their lawmakers (glossary: secularis: the referent matters). Ab ipsa refers to lex Dei.
- 8 Extravagantibus plays on the Extravagantes, the papal decretals "wandering outside" the collections. Suspensus is "hanging on" the law of God, intent on it.
- 9 Distincciones may glance at the distinctions of the Decretum. Graduacio is context-dependent (the glossary): of rank and lordship here, "gradation", not academic "graduation"; difformitas, difformis "difformity, difform", the want of uniformity, against uniformitas.
- 10 Paul on himself and Peter: Gal. 2:9–11 (the right hands of fellowship; Paul’s resistance to Peter); the decree is not named; it is probably Decretum C.2 q.7 c.33 (Jerome: Paul rebuked Peter, knowing himself 'not unequal'; greater and less 'not by dignity but by life'), with c.37 (Peter and Paul equal in merit though different in rank). "The servant … higher": cf. Matt. 23:11.
- 11 Luke 10:42, "Mary hath chosen the best part".
- 12 Tribute to Caesar: Matt. 17:26 and 22:21. Medius status: the secular lords, between the clergy and the commons.
- 13 The two arguments are set side by side for judgement; the second is ironic (igitur verum).
- 14 Locis a simili: the topical place "from likeness". Destruxerat is pluperfect where a future perfect is meant; membra sua are Antichrist’s own members.
- 15 Eph. 5:16; Loserth’s reference reads "Eph. V, 10" in the OCR of the page foot.
- 16 The Evangelist is John: the legend that he turned rods of the woods into gold and pebbles of the shore into gems (Isidore, De ortu et obitu patrum 72, PL 83, 151C, quoted in the Legenda aurea c. 9); Loserth’s italics bound the phrase as a quotation, and he refers to De ecclesia p. 189 and p. 81 above. Simon Magus: Acts 8:18, who offered money for the apostles’ power.
How the Latin of this chapter was established
- Plate readings; page · reading · note):
- 294: illa
- 295: in
- 295: tribuitur (italic t) [NW]
- 295: verunt (cogno | verunt split by folio bar (234ᵈ in margin), not a hyphen; this line’s part) [NW]
- 296: et (20 is the line number)
- 296: eliquate [NW]
- 297: unitatem
- 297: socialem (hyphenated socia-|lem (25 line number); main token holds the whole word)
- 298: mali
- 295: oneribus (LEFT-nw: hyphenated one-|ribus)
- 295: licet (line number 30 glued (read as so))