De potestate pape, chapter 7, part 7
The seventh argument: Peter at the council and how a vicar should correct
Loserth pp. 156.26–160.4
¶1156.26–160.4
By these things the reply to the seventh is clear, in which Peter’s preeminencepreeminencia: preeminence is proved by that [passage] of Acts 15, that Peter humbly put himself forward for the labour.1 There was not then among the apostles any contention about the office of superiorprepositura: office of superior; but an eightfold true humility compelled Peter to answer before the others.2 And would that the modern popepapa: pope were willing to exercise that key of the knowledge of the faith after Peter’s pattern; for then he would not try to impose 157heavy ceremonies on the faithful, even beyond the Jewish ritesritus: rite, but, without them and without obedience exacted by Peter, would define their liberty to stand in this: that the grace of the Lord Jesus Christ sufficed them and the Gentiles for salvation.3 And after this James, as a companion and familiarly, addresses the people in these words: "Men, brethren, hear me. Simon hath related how God visited to take of the Gentiles a people to his name. For which cause I judge that they are not to be disquieted, who from among the Gentiles are converted."4 Here it is noteworthy that the Holy Spirit does not write him "the most blessed pope Peter", but calls him Simon, a companion, out of humility; and [writes] that James spoke thus not by Peter’s authorityauctoritas: authority but by the Lord’s, and therefore said in the singular "I judge", a word that today would be severely condemned as boorish and discordant. Nor is it valid to allegeallegare / allegacio: allege / allegation James’s holiness against modern bishopsepiscopus; dominus episcopus: bishop; the lord bishop, for the pope is just as far from the holiness of Peter, who neither reproved James in this nor claimed that James spoke so by his authority. As, then, the bishops are far from the holiness of James, so the popes are exceedinglynimis: exceedingly far from the holiness of Peter. Whence, then, does the pope have authority to claim from bishops what is not exemplified in Peter’s jurisdictioniurisdiccio: jurisdiction over the other holy apostles or converts? Now Peter claimed no exercise of lordshipdominacio: exercise of lordship over his other brethren, but humbly obeyed the apostle who rebuked him.5 Let the pope therefore recall that no one ought to obey him except in so far as he has spoken God’s law as God’s instrument, nor is [anyone] bound to believe him except in so far as he is bound to believe that God speaks in him; and this will move him to allege the law of the Lord, in which is all 158truth, and to rely on the preeminence of holiness; for otherwise he is, as Antichrist, most of all to be disbelieved, and above all to be fled by the company of the faithful. And thirdly let him recall that Rehoboam, out of the pompous exercise of lordship which he learned from the counsel of the young men, said falsely that his "little finger" was mightier "than the back of" his "father", and through this the kingdomregnum: kingdom was divided, as is clear in 3 Kings 12:10, and as Chrysostom notes in the first homily of the Unfinished Work.6 And let him apply his words and works to this, [to see] whether it implies that he exalts himself "above all that is called God", demanding an exercise of lordship which Christ cannot demand; and he will see that it is above all by reason of this that Christendom is divided, for the faithful had withdrawn from him because of his stinking lordshipdominium: lordship, and hence on both sides the conversion of unbelieversinfidelis: unbeliever; with a dative, faithless (to) to the law of the Lord is hindered.7 So foreign, I say, does his manner of lifeconversacio: manner of life seem from Christ, that it varies from him far more than the manner of life of the priestssacerdos / presbiter: priest / presbyter of the old law [varied] from Moses, who had remained [with him] in sense, words and doctrinedoctrina: doctrine, but withdrew in life and work. But this pope seems foreign to Christ, since he disagrees with him both in life and in doctrine; for in Matt. 24:11 Christ says that "this gospel" about the false christpseudochristus: false christ "shall be preached in the whole world, for a testimony to all nations";8 but the PseudoPseudo (as a noun): the Pseudo, far from being set there to be a witness to Christ on earth, persecutes those who bear witness to this gospel. Hence it seems that Christ does not trust these as much as the priests of the old law, since in Matt. 23:3 he commands his own: "All things whatsoever they shall say to you, do: but according to their works do ye not. For they say, and do not."9 And it is said that our prelatesprelatus: prelate, from their greater distance from Christ through the caesarean endowmentdotacio: endowment brought in upon [them], neither say nor do. 159For whereas blessed Gregory set out with all his heart on the journey to convert the English, the modern pope assignslimitare; limites: to assign (an office); limits himself as a law that he is not to preach, lest he fall into heresy, for which alone he is to be deposed, as appears from distinction 40, Si papa.10 But these things are scandalous: first, because the pope would know how to guard himself against heresy before he accepted such a dignity; second, because the pope, who is said to have so great a plenitude of powerplenitudo potestatis: plenitude of power, could define that whatever he said would not be heresy, or at least could declare solemnlyprotestacio; protestari: declaration; to declare solemnly that he has no mind to turn aside from the law of the Lord.11 Third, heresy is more dangerous in discord of life; indeed, by the same token no superiorprepositi: superiors would preach, since for heresy, and especially real heresy, he deserves to be deposed; and the pope, for a manifold cause, would sooner flee that danger. Therefore it is nothing but an antichristian and self-accusing "excuse in sins".12 Self-accusing, I say, because as such he openly judges that he is a stranger to [being] vicar of Christvicarius Christi: vicar of Christ; and in other matters it is commonly said that he cannot sin. And so the vicar of Petervicarius Petri: vicar of Peter should note what was repeated in the seventh, how in Matt. 18, because of the primacyprimatus: primacy, it was said to Peter singly that he should correct his brother;13 where three things are to be noted by the vicar of Peter: first, since he must correct his brother, he must first of all keep himself irreprehensible, for charitycaritas: charity must begin from itself. Second, it is to be noted that the vicar of Peter must be prudent, assiduous and attentive in the manner of correcting, so as not to excommunicate before the end of the third correction, at which he sees that his brother is not to be corrected more fitly [otherwise].14 Third, he must note that he is a companion and minister of the churchecclesia: church; for otherwise 160he would not bring in for himself the testimony of the many, and, fourth, tell it to the church as the greater; for so he was sent by the small church of the apostles, as is clear in Acts 8.15
Notes
- 1 Acts 15:7–11. A has a marginal note at 156.26 whose text is cut off in the scan of the apparatus (presumably Ad 7).
- 2 octuplex, "eightfold", is unexplained and doubtful; translated as printed. The contention about greatness: Luke 22:24.
- 3 Acts 15:10–11, Peter against laying the yoke of the law on the Gentile converts. "The key of knowledge": Luke 11:52; diffiniret libertatem eorum stare in isto: "define their liberty to consist in this".
- 4 Acts 15:13–14, 19 in Wyclif’s form: he omits primum ("first") in 15:14 and ad Deum ("to God") in 15:19.
- 5 Gal. 2:11–14. notum est above: "it is noteworthy"; "the most blessed pope" is the style of papal address.
- 6 3 Kings 12:10 (DR; 1 Kings in modern Bibles) in Wyclif’s indirect form, potencior for the Vulgate’s grossior (DR "My little finger is thicker than the back of my father"). Chrysostom: the pseudo-Chrysostom Opus imperfectum in Matthaeum, hom. 1; Loserth, foot to 158.9: "Opp. tom. VI (Ed. Migne) p. 622".
- 7 2 Thess. 2:4. si implicat se extollere: we take implicat as "implies"; it could be "whether he involves himself in exalting himself". "On both sides": of the divided Christendom.
- 8 The words are Matt. 24:14, printed "XXIV, 11". Wyclif reads hoc evangelium de pseudochristo where the Vulgate has hoc Evangelium regni ("this gospel of the kingdom"), and in universo mundo for in universo orbe: "about the false christ" is his gloss, taking the gospel to be the warning of Matt. 24:23–24. pseudo is the Pseudo, his name in ch. 6 for the false pope.
- 9 Matt. 23:3 without the Vulgate’s ergo and servate et (DR "All things therefore whatsoever … observe and do").
- 10 Gregory the Great set out to convert the English before he was pope: Bede, Hist. eccl. II.1, has his request and offer but says the Romans would not let him go; the journey itself (three days out, then recalled) is John the Deacon, Vita Gregorii I.22–24 (PL 75, 72). Decretum D.40 c.6 Si papa: the pope is judged by none "unless he is found to deviate from the faith" (Loserth, foot: "Cap. VI"; the modern form is ours; PL 187, 215, under Boniface’s name: a nemine est judicandus, nisi deprehendatur a fide devius). limitat takes the glossary’s "assign"; the sense is "prescribes". A and B note in the margin at 159.5 Papa quare non predicat.
- 11 sciret, diffiniret, protestaretur are potential subjunctives ("would know", "could define", "could declare"): the argument is ironic, since a pope who claims plenitude of power could remove the danger by a definition.
- 12 "Excuse in sins": Ps. 140:4 (ad excusandas excusationes in peccatis, DR "to make excuses in sins"). heresis realis: heresy in deed, as against heresy in words; cf. in vite discordia just before.
- 13 Matt. 18:15–17 is addressed to the disciples; Wyclif reads it as said to Peter (cf. Peter’s question at 18:21). septimo replicatum: "repeated in the seventh", i.e. the seventh argument. B reads ut for ubi (159.24). The print says "three things" but four follow (Loserth’s side-notes number them 1–4). A and B note in the margin at 159.21 Vicarius Petri debet notare dicta Petro.
- 14 apcius: "more fitly"; the third correction is the telling to the church (Matt. 18:17). "Charity must begin from itself": ordered charity begins with oneself.
- 15 Matt. 18:16–17 (the witnesses; "tell the church"). Acts 8:14: the apostles at Jerusalem sent Peter and John to Samaria. multitudinis testimonio is dative or ablative where testimonium is expected; translated by sense.
How the Latin of this chapter was established
- Plate readings; page · reading · note):
- 158: 10 (old-style 10)
- 158: universo (print has v)
- 159: et (20 is the line number)
- 160: adhiberet
- 160: ∅ (page-opening slip repeating end of p. 159; main scan already holds it)
- Omitted per §3.5 / kept in the English (margin matter): reference 6.-7. Cf. Rom. XV, 20. (156.33).