De potestate pape, chapter 8, part 1
The name "pope", and the reason from Rome as capital
Loserth pp. 165.2–169.31
¶1165.2–166.25
It now remains to see whether the Roman pontiffRomanus pontifex: Roman pontiff must as a rule be popepapa: pope and the immediate and nearest vicar of Christvicarius Christi: vicar of Christ on earth. But as for the name "pope", note that it is not expressed in holy scripture, if I am right, but is derived from the interjection papae, which signifies wonder.1 Hence it properly befits those who are wonderful for holiness in their manner of lifeconversacio: manner of life; in which sense our Jesus is the highest pope possible, since it is written of him, Isaiah 9:6: "And his name shall be called Wonderful, Counsellor, God the Mighty, the Prince of Peace."2 And formerly all holy bishopsepiscopus; dominus episcopus: bishop; the lord bishop whatever were called holy popes. Hence Jerome’s eighth letter to Augustine speaks thus: "To the lord truly holy and most blessed pope Augustine, Jerome [sends] greeting." Again, Augustine in letter 18 to Paulinus speaks thus: "I believe your holiness has the books of the most blessed pope Ambrose; and I greatly desire those which he wrote most diligently and copiously against certain most unskilled and most proud men, who contend that the Lord profited from the books of Plato." Again, in letter 10 to Aurelius, Alypius and Augustine write: "To the most blessed lord pope Aurelius"; and this pope Aurelius was not the Roman bishopRomanus episcopus: the Roman bishop, as is clear from letter 139 to Generosus, in which he enumerates all the bishops from blessed Peter down to Anastasius, who then ruled the same 166see;3 and formerly bishops were commonly called popes. Hence Count Boniface, in letter 102, writes to Augustine: "I have received your holiness’s letter, terrifying me by its admonition; for, venerable pope, if that lawful bed has fearful approaches, with what punishment must he be punished who violates the divine reasons?"4 And in letter 3 the same Boniface addresses Augustine thus at the end: "Pray therefore, venerable pope, that such vengeance may often go forth upon enemies." Indeed, as the Archdeacon relates: "The Greeks call all presbyterssacerdos / presbiter: priest / presbyter popes";5 hence by reason of endowmentdotacio: endowment and lordshipdominium: lordship the term was baptized so that it should be appropriatedappropriare; appropriacio: to appropriate; appropriation to the Roman pontiff. But since no weight lies in keeping to a term,6 I suppose that it signifies specially that bishop who bears the place of Christ most highly, most like him and most nearly, as Peter did after the ascension, and as we say the Roman pontiffs do as a rule. But since it seems a wonderful and groundless leap to leap thus as a rule from Christ to the whole line of Roman pontiffs, therefore many devise various ways to give colour tocolorare: give colour to this fictionficticia: fiction. And some say that this proceeds by way of reason, some by way of the succession of Peter, and some by way of election.
¶2166.26–166.30
As to the first, the lord of ArmaghArdmacanus; dominus Ardmacanus: Armachanus; the lord of Armagh, in book 7 of the Questions of the Armenians, feigns a manifold reason:7 first, because Rome is the capital city of Christendom, therefore it is fitting that the capital bishop should rule there.
¶3166.31–167.12
But as to this evidenceevidencia: evidence, it seems that it accuses the highest pontiffsummi pontifices: highest pontiffs (of popes); high priests (of the Jewish priesthood), the Lord Jesus Christ, who chose Jerusalem for his passion; and this 167seems reasonable, that he who had come to redeem the whole human race should show the medicine in the middle of the habitable earth, according to that of Psalm 73:12: "But God is our king before ages: he hath wrought salvation in the midst of the earth." According to the cosmographers, Jerusalem is placed in the middle of the habitable [world]; and that place would be more fitting for the highest pontiff than Rome, a corner of Europe,8 because otherwise Christ undoubtedly would not have chosen as he did; above all since in the time of Christ and of Augustus Caesar Rome was in the full flower of its lordship, and the emperor less impious than those who followed in the time of the apostles.
¶4167.14–167.31
Again, it seems that this reason, since it stands continually, accuses the popes who followed, who for the most part did not rule Rome but, grown fat, rested at Avignon,9 and [accuses them the more] since a stronger reason would now be present, in that that place of the empire is said to be of the pope’s lordship.10 And so a manifold reason remains: first and principally, the reason for ruling this people; since, as the reasons of gifts grow, the reason for ministering more humbly and more readily ought to grow, according to blessed Gregory.11 For according to the Apostle, 1 Tim. 5[:8]: "He that hath not care of his own and especially of those of his house hath denied the faith and is worse than an infidel";12 therefore the pope should provide especially for the Romans in spiritual goods, since he is made their lorddominus; dominari: lord; to exercise lordship / to lord it and curatecuratus: curate. By reason of lordship he ought to defend them in secular wise, and by reason of [being] their spiritual and particular father he ought, like Paul, to beget and cherish them spiritually.13
¶5167.32–168.26
Again, if the reason for the papacy of the Roman pontiff depends on this reason, since this reason is very changeable according to fortune, it followssequitur: it follows that the papacy must vary proportionally. For 168in the time of the apostles and long after, Rome was not the city of Christendom, or, more fully, [it was] the city of the synagogue of Satan,14 since the emperor and the greater part of the people were unbelieversinfidelis: unbeliever; with a dative, faithless (to); indeed, as the lord of Armagh declares in book 7, chapter 16 of the Questions of the Armenians, the Roman empire is restricted to such a degree that it is less in secular lordship not only than the empire of the Great Khan of Cathay, but now besides than the empire of the Persians, the empire of Uzbek, the empire of the Sultan and the empire of the barbarians;15 indeed, according to the report of those who have visited remote countries, there are many cities which surpass Rome. Therefore it is far from catholic for a man to say that that place or people necessitates that its bishop be the best follower of Christ. And therefore the lord of Armagh says below, in chapter 18: "It seems to me," he says, "that the papacy and the Roman pontificate are not so connected that they could not be separated for a reasonable cause."16 And in conformity with this the second reason is removed, by which it is feigned that in the head of the world, where there is a more general confluence of people, it17 would receive the doctrinedoctrina: doctrine of Christ more effectually, and it would be more aptly exemplified how the Roman princes should be subject to Christ; and also, thirdly, that the fount of the clergyclerus; clericus: the clergy; cleric should stand beside the fount of secular lordship, so that the knighthoodmilicia; milites: knighthood; knights might strengthen the clergy,18 and the clergy counsel the princes and rule according to the gospel of Jesus Christ.
¶6168.27–169.31
But this threefold fiction is not reason, because as a whole it contains the opposite. For Nero, Diocletian and the line of tyrants who succeeded them were the chief obstacles to the gospel and the law of Christlex dei / lex Christi / lex evangelica: God's law / the law of Christ / the gospel law running in the empire, as is clear from well-known chronicles; indeed Constantine, succeeding, by poisoning 169harmed the church more lastingly;19 and again the clergy out of avarice harmed the empire exceedinglynimis: exceedingly, and, what is more, gave the princes a pernicious example of every kind of sin, and, what is most faithless, grown fat, fell dumb to rebuke or to teach. For before the endowment Peter, Clement, Marcellus and other holy Roman bishops loved Caesar and his people even to death, by teaching and rebuking. But after they were endowed they laboured under faint-heartednessvecors; vecorditer; vecordia: faint-hearted; faint-heartedly; faint-heartedness and blasphemy: faint-heartedness, in fearing to tell princes and peoples their vices; nay rather, with the milk of flattery they softened and dissolved their lords, so that by giving them temporal goodstemporalia: temporal goods against the rule of Christ they harm both themselves and them. And thirdly they break out into greater, ungratefulingratus: displeasing (to God) blasphemies, saying that they did not have that endowment from Caesar, but by rightius: right / law of succession to Christ and Peter, who [they say] exercised lordship in this way in the highest degree. Therefore it does not teach them20 to visit princes and to impart to them something of spiritual doctrine, but to reside wherever they will, to summon emperors and kings, and to receive from them, imperially, the most abject worldly servicesservicium: service. Peter did not do so; therefore it undoubtedly jars with the school of Christ, since after the multiplication of temporal gifts they ought to have busied themselves, by visiting the donors, in paying back more humbly better things. But who so ungrateful to Christ the abbot would not be ungrateful to his neighbour?21 For Christ, for love of us, came supremely poor and needy, as is said in 2 Cor. 8 toward the end,22 and so that we clerics, and especially the vicars of Peter, might live likewise.
Notes
- 1 Loserth compares Wyclif’s English works, ed. Matthew, p. 471, and Hus (his p. 256), who reuse the etymology (Matthew p. 471, De papa ch. 7: the name "is newe foundun" and betokens "wundirful"; the Hus page not checked; Loserth also cites Freeman, William Rufus I, 292). R. A in the margin, at 165.14: Nota Augustinus mirabiliter contra Wy[clif], the annotator’s protest against the argument from the letters that follow.
- 2 Wyclif’s citation omits the Vulgate’s Pater futuri saeculi, "the Father of the world to come", and reads Deus fortis as one title; DR’s "God the Mighty" fits it.
- 3 Loserth’s references (Augustine, Opera II, Maurist numbering): Jerome to Augustine, Ep. 112 in Jerome’s collection (PL 22, 916; Ep. 75 in Augustine’s, PL 33, 251); Augustine to Paulinus, Ep. 31 (al. 32); Alypius and Augustine to Aurelius, ibid. p. 87 (Ep. 41); to Generosus, Ep. 53 (al. 165), with its list of Roman bishops down to Anastasius. Wyclif’s letter numbers are those of his own collection. "Alypius" is the modern form of the print’s Alpius.
- 4 The letters of Count Boniface stand in the appendix of spurious pieces in Augustine’s Opera II (Loserth: App. p. 1; and Ep. 14, al. 194, App. p. 4; PL 33, 1095 and 1098, spurious Epp. 2 and 14). C. Divinas … raciones: perhaps "the divine accounts" or "ordinances"; we keep the literal "reasons".
- 5 Loserth reports a gap in the manuscripts after Archidiaconus. S. The Archdeacon is presumably Guido de Baysio, archdeacon of Bologna, author of the Rosarium on the Decretum, the canonists’ usual Archidiaconus; the passage has not been traced.
- 6 Non est vis in servacione termini: the canonists’ vis non est facienda in verbis, "no stress is to be laid on words". Wyclif lets the word go and fixes the sense.
- 7 FitzRalph, Summa in quaestionibus Armenorum 7 (chapter 15, Paris 1512, fol. 48r, where Richard sets out these reasons, including the one fount for a "twofold stream of rule" and the martyrs’ blood (cf. 168.22–26, 171.24)). G. Fingit: "feigns", the verb of ficticia "fiction" (166.24).
- 8 Loserth prints quam for the manuscripts’ quia (167.8). C. Angulus Europe Roma: "Rome" is in apposition with "a corner of Europe".
- 9 The papal court had resided at Avignon from 1309 to 1377 (Clement V settled there in 1309; Gregory XI entered Rome on 17 January 1377). Loserth reports papa in the manuscripts for papas (167.15).
- 10 Cum pocior racio nunc subesset: cum may be concessive ("although a stronger reason would now be present"); either way the clause depends on accusat.
- 11 Gregory, Homilies on the Gospels 9.1: "when gifts increase, the accounts (rationes) for the gifts also grow" (PL 76, 1106; Gregory goes on: tanto ergo esse humilior atque ad serviendum promptior quisque debet, Wyclif’s humilius et promcius ministrandi). C. Gregory’s racio is "account", the reckoning to be rendered; Wyclif plays on it beside racio "reason", which we keep throughout.
- 12 Wyclif’s Qui non providet … negat departs from the Vulgate’s Si quis … curam non habet, fidem negavit; the English follows his Latin with DR’s wording.
- 13 1 Cor. 4:15, "in Christ Jesus by the gospel I have begotten you."
- 14 Apoc. 2:9, "the synagogue of Satan".
- 15 FitzRalph, Summa 7.16 (Paris, 1511, fol. 48; Loserth after R. L. Poole; seen in the 1512 print, fol. 48r, where the list is spoken by FitzRalph’s interlocutor John). The same chapter (fol. 48r–v) gives the objector’s case for Jerusalem, in medio terre (Ps. 73:12) and the city of the martyrs, which Wyclif turns to his own use at 167.1–8 and 172.14 ff. Loserth glosses Canis as Khan and Cathay as China; B reads Usboth for Usbeck (Özbeg, khan of the Golden Horde). FitzRalph writes only imperio soldani; the Mamluk sultan of Egypt is our presumption.
- 16 FitzRalph, Summa 7.18 (Paris 1512, fol. 50r: non tamen sic michi videtur annexi quin ex rationabili causa … valeant separari). T. Loserth prints quin; the manuscripts read quando (168.18).
- 17 Ipse most likely takes up populus in confluxus populi, "the people"; it could be the pope himself.
- 18 The Latin has milicia cleri corroboret, literally "that the knighthood of the clergy might strengthen", with no object; we take cleri as the object in sense. A word may have fallen out (e.g. clerum).
- 19 The legend that at Constantine’s donation a voice was heard saying "today poison is poured into the church" (Higden, Polychronicon IV.26, Rolls Series V, 130: Hodie infusum est venenum in ecclesia Dei; cf. 130.4).
- 20 The subject of docet is not stated: most likely the endowment, or the claim just named; possibly the teaching of their school. G. Ingratus (169.15): "ungrateful" toward a person, here Caesar the donor (the glossary).
- 21 The print reads Christo abbati, "Christ the abbot"; Loserth reports Christi in the manuscripts, "Christ’s abbot". G. Ingratus here is "ungrateful" toward a person (the glossary).
- 22 2 Cor. 8:9, "being rich he became poor for your sakes". Loserth notes that the citation is rather 8:9 than the chapter’s end.
How the Latin of this chapter was established
- Plate readings; page · reading · note):
- 165: CAPITULUM OCTAVUM.
- 165: pontificem
- 165: Et
- 165: Deus
- 165: sanctitatem
- 165: quos
- 165: Aurelio (25 is the line number)
- 166: accessus (hyphenated ac-cessus; main token covers whole word)
- 166: ra- (hyphenated ra-cione; main token holds first half)
- 166: illum
- 167: Deus
- 167: deterior
- 167: racio
- 168: ut
- 168: Canis
- 168: contratas [NW]
- 168: illum
- Omitted per §3.5 / kept in the English (margin matter): reference Rome waTthe (166.27).
- Apparatus not otherwise noted: 169.24 Loserth expands the manuscripts’ P. to Petrus. The print is translated.