De eucharistia, chapter 8, part 10
God above time, multiplication, and how the body of Christ is in the host
Loserth pp. 267.23–272.11
¶1267.23–268.9
It is further to be noted that there would be no having-been or going-to-be except by reason of time;1 and consequently, all time being taken away, God was not, nor will be, but is, absolutely, necessarily. And so in eternity this differencedifferencia: difference (logical differentia) is not formally; and consequently, since God and his eternity, an angel and its aeveityevitas: aeveity, were and will be, they must take those namingsdenominacio; denominare: naming; to name, accidental to them, from time, and so they have a when;2 which does not presuppose in them a natural period, as [it does in] creaturescreatura / creator / creatus: creature / creator / created naturally 268corruptible; and so God was and will be equivocallyequivoce: equivocally in comparison with corruptible natures, as other relationalrespectus; respectivus: relation; relational accidentsaccidens: accident are in him equivocally. The same time in number, then, measures the eternity of God, the aeveity of an angel, and so of the other things above time, as to the relational namingdenominacio respectiva: relational naming by which they are measured by time. And so it seems that not, on this account, another time, but another whennessquandalitas: whenness,3 without change of essence, is to be posited. And these things suffice here.
¶2268.10–271.24
But, returning after the digression to the difficulty touched on concerning multiplicationmultiplicacio corporis: multiplication of a body, it seems that the second teachingsentencia: teaching / sentence4 is to be held. For since it is impossible for the same body to be multiplied situallysitualiter: situally or dimensionallydimensionaliter: dimensionally through diverse places, and both the faith about the Eucharisteukaristia: the Eucharist and also common philosophy teach that there is a multiplication of substancesubstancia: substance,5 the truth of the second teaching is clear. And it is called multiplication when the same created thing is at once in time through many places as a whole, as the soul, universalsuniversale; ydea: universal; idea and instants; but time is not so multiplied, since for any instant whatever its parts are lacking to every place, as the past and future parts. Yet, speaking in an extended senseextense loquendo: speaking in an extended sense, it can be granted to be multiplied, because according to its many parts it is through diverse places; and so a common light, a common species,6 or likeness of a thing is multiplied, because it is through one great site and through every part of it according to some suppositsuppositum: supposit of it, as a universal is also wherever it has some singular. And if each such singular has being through every part of a given site, then that singular too is multiplied through the same site, as is posited of the species of a visible thing. 269But God cannot be multiplied, because he is necessarily everywhere as a whole; nor can he be defined7 by any place or time, or be somewhere according to his own motion; so on his side there occurs no multiplication, nor definition according to time. For according to the saintssancti: the saints there is not formally multitudemultitudo (of one body): multitude in him; and other things, although they are everywhere (namely the world, time, and the universals whose individuals are [everywhere]), are yet everywhere otherwise than God. For the world is not everywhere as a whole, since not every quantitative partpars quantitativa: quantitative part of it is spread out everywhere; nor is every subjective partpartes potestative / subiective / aliquote: potestative / subjective / aliquot parts of the genus body, or of such a universal, everywhere; nor does time have all its parts at once for the same instant, but by a certain dependence on motion it is one way in heaven and another way on earth. But God, according to his immensity, first and of himselfper se / per accidens: of itself / by accident; (spatial) apart, by itself8 fills every place, and according to his eternity is first and of himself through all time. No variation can occur on his side in being through place or time, but the variation must be in the created substance, whose variation is called an accident: as God of himself efficiently fills every place and body, or its principle of itself formally fills the place, so that the punctualpunctale (noun): punctual of a material essence, since it cannot be made greater or less, is of itself punctual, and its punctualitypunctalitas: punctuality is the point; and so of the quantityquantitas / qualitas: quantity / quality of a body, which follows on its first subjectsubiectum / passio: subject / attribute as risibilityrisibilis / risibilitas: risible / risibility on man; and according to the aspect by which God, immovableimmobilis / immobilitas: immovable / immovability, posits material substance according to an immovable aspect, whose situation or location is the site or place which Aristotle calls the first immovable.9 For God could not move that aspect with the first motion, which is local motion. And this is the first ground of perceptible immovability, by which we ascend to knowing the ultimate immovability 270of our God. And when we see a thing moved from place to place by God’s ordinanceordinacio; ordinancia: ordinance; of the sacrament, ordination, we call that alternationvicissitudo: alternation of motion time or duration, and we individuate place and time from the genus of substance or of motion, with the other individuating circumstances which God ordains for this. "And so we see our Lord in every alternation of the creature."10 And as God is first great and immense, of himself efficaciously and finally filling place, so he is first of himself lasting and eternal, of himself finally measuring the turns of all temporal things; and so the immensity and eternity of God are not accidents, nor divisible (as is supposed here). And as God cannot be another God, so through the same punctual site there cannot be at once another point or material essence, since its whole capacity is filled; for [its being filled] is nothing other than for that material essence to be sited, or at least another as great, or so great a species of quantity.11 And since a substantial formforma substancialis: substantial form or accidental form is nothing but such an essence’s being informedinformacio; informare: informing; inform, it is clear that the filling of the site is not multiplied thereby. And I speak12 of site or place (as above) as it signifiesdicere (logical use): signify a material essence’s being sited. And it is clear to logicians that it is one thing for Peter to be in a place adequate to him and another for him to be through a place adequate to him. For since there are a thousand places between him and the heaven equal to him (since, as they are wider, they are thinner), and all surrounding him on every side, it is clear that he is in as many places equal to him, and consequently so far adequate to him; and yet he is through none of those places, since through no part of such a place is there any part of Peter, since he is distant from every such [place]. So it is a far different thing for Peter to be in many places adequate to him and for him 271to be through many places adequate to him. For a thing is through a place when at some part of that designated place there is some part of it, as every material substance is spread out through place; in which way it is incompatiblerepugnare; repugnancia: to be incompatible; incompatibility for the same body in number to be extended at once through distant places. Yet it can be extended in one place and have another, spiritual, being in another, as in a sign or in power, as was said of the king.13 And so it is clear of the body of Christcorpus Christi / corpus Domini: the body of Christ / the body of the Lord that it is dimensionallydimensionaliter: dimensionally in heaven and virtuallyvirtualiter: virtually in the hosthostia; hostia consecrata: host; consecrated host as in a sign. But on this there is great disagreement about the mode of being of the body of Christ in the host. For some say that the body of Christ is present there only according to its essence, which is so far defined by the place of the host that it could be there in that mode and be nowhere else; but others admit this, because it would be far easier for God than to preserve an accident without a subjectaccidens sine subiecto: accident without a subject;14 so on them lies the difficulty how quantity is multiplied with the body of Christ, and the other accidents accompany it.15 But this difficulty does not lie on us. Grant that the body of Christ is in the sacrament of bread, or [its] power, and not the body of Christ which is extended in heaven; so that the body of Christ is not not-a-body, but is not the body of Christ there; and it is that which is extended there, but it is not extended there.16
¶3271.25–272.11
And this is the third point in which I differ from the modernsmoderni (bare): the moderns;17 nevertheless (as I have often solemnly declaredprotestacio; protestari: declaration; to declare solemnly) I am willing readily to obey a learned man [who shows] that, as regards the truth of this matter, I have been either excessive or sparing.18 And the world wonders how, after the endowmentdotacio: endowment of the churchecclesia: church, either the sacrament should be varied, or either a reason should become known or a revelation be made to our men, more estranged from Christ, more than to Paul and the earlier saints. For so, as lords, they could estrangeextraneare / extraneacio (supposicionis): estrange / estrangement (of supposition) the laws of Christ, the whole catholic 272faith.19 Nor is there doubt that the catholic truth was sufficiently taught by the authors of scripture, although it is the office of the church on pilgrimagepars peregrinans; peregrinari: the pilgrim part; to be a pilgrim, to which God has given knowledge, to exposedetegere: to expose the faith implicit in scripture20 when errors sprout about its meaningsensus (of words): meaning. And never is anything new of the catholic faith to be fabricated by them; and hence God always ordains some who attend to the logic and the meaning of scripture, since yet any pontiffpontifex (a Christian bishop, unqualified): pontiff whatever is to be believed in these things in the measure that he has adduced the testimony of the scriptures more strongly; and it is known that they, after the endowment of the church, have failed in this as in morals.
Notes
- 1 267.23: AB lack non; ABC read esse for esset; AB fuisse (C corrected). The print is translated.
- 2 Quando, the category "when", is the denomination God and the angels take from time: they "were" and "will be" only by relation to it, not by any change in themselves.
- 3 Quandalitas, "whenness": being in a when (cf. 267.15–16, where ABC read the same word). Proposed for the glossary.
- 4 Sentencia (context-dependent): "teaching", the second of the positions on the multiplication of a body set out earlier in this chapter.
- 5 268.16: A has substancie struck out in the text and sentencie in the margin ("teach that there is a multiplication of the teaching"); the print is translated. 268.13: C situaliter in marg. alia manu, D signanter.
- 6 Species here is the likeness a thing sends through the medium (the species of light and of the visible), not the sacramental species and not the logical species. Speciebus visibilis at the end of the sentence: "of the visible [thing]", the genitive singular as printed.
- 7 269.3: diffinire is active in the print; it is read in the passive sense (diffiniri, "be defined", of definitive presence in a place), which the next clause’s diffinicio supports. The print may have lost a letter.
- 8 Per se (context-dependent) is "of himself", God’s filling place by his own immensity, not the spatial "apart".
- 9 Aristotle, Physics IV.4 (212a20–21): place as "the first immovable limit of the container".
- 10 Loserth sets the sentence in italic, as a quotation; his page foot gives no source, and none was found in the Patrologia Latina or on the web.
- 11 270.17: aliam tantam aut tantam speciem quantitatis; E reads vel tantam. The repeated tantam may be a doubling; read as "another [essence] as great, or so great a species of quantity". Quia non est aliud nisi …: the subject, the site’s being filled, is supplied from repletur.
- 12 270.21: ABCD Loquitur ("he speaks"); Loserth prints E’s Loquor, which is translated. 270.22: ABCE loycis.
- 13 The king’s spiritual being in a place where his body is not, as in his sign or his power, was set out in ch. 4 (84.7–19), where the king has a threefold being in his realm, situale, intencionale et potenciale.
- 14 Wyclif names neither party. Alii admittunt hoc is read as granting the first party’s mode (present by essence, defined to the host’s place), since it would be easier for God than an accident without a subject; illos are these second, who then owe an account of the accidents.
- 15 271.19: committantur is taken for comitantur, "accompany"; C reads committanter.
- 16 271.19–22: Wyclif’s own position, in compressed predication. Non est non corpus, sed est non corpus Christi ibi: the negations are kept as he orders them; what is extended there (the bread) "is" the body sacramentally, while the body is not extended there. ABC read aut non (for aut virtus?), E lacks autem, DE lack Esto and read quia and est; the clause is hard to construe and the print is translated as it stands.
- 17 "The third point" in which Wyclif differs from the moderns in this chapter; the first two are not restated here.
- 18 The submission formula (protestacio). Docto is read as "a learned man" with the verb of showing understood ("[who shows]"); it could also be "to one taught [by God]". 271.27–28: E materie sim.
- 19 Leges Christi and totam fidem catholicam are taken as two objects in apposition; domini may also be read with leges ("as lords of the law of Christ"). 271.32: E tamquam diu. The subject is nostri, "our men", the moderns.
- 20 In scriptura implicita agrees in form with scriptura; it is read as "the faith implicit in scripture", the faith wrapped in scripture’s text. 272.2: ABC satis edocta; 272.4: E protegere for detegere; 272.9–10: E in testimonium.
How the Latin of this chapter was established
- Omitted per §3.5 / kept in the English (margin matter): reference 3. Time, the measurc of thc (267.4).
- Variants (selected: every variant of these lines that bears on the English is given in the notes; the rest are orthographic or leave the sense unchanged): 267.23 AB non om., ABC esse, AB fuisse (n. 1); 267.25 A Deus alia manu, C vel alia manu; 268.1 C corporales in textu, corruptibiles in marg. alia manu, AB sic ita, C vel erit; 268.4 E eviternitatem; 268.13 C situaliter in marg., D signanter (n. 5); 268.15 D multitudinem; 268.16 A substancie struck, sentencie in marg. (n. 5); 268.17 D quod eadem; 268.19 ABCE et om.; 268.21 ABC defuerunt; 268.24 D sic racione luminum, E gravis speciei; 268.27 D tempus suppositum, ABC est ubicunque; 268.30 D singulariter; 269.2 A ubique in marg.; 269.4 D aliter esse; 269.18 ABC variacionem; 269.21 D efficaciter; 269.28 E immaterialem; 269.31 B movere om.; 269.33 E prima causa; 270.1 ABD videmus removeri; 270.2 E ad locum om.; 270.4 E vel individuamus, D et om.; 270.7 E Et sic; 270.8 ABC efficienter; 270.13 C ita alia manu; 270.14 E punctualem; 270.17 E vel tantam (n. 11); 270.19 DE vel; 270.21 ABCD Loquitur (n. 12); 270.22 ABCE loycis; 270.(2)3 AB sibi om.; 270.(2)6 C ut om., D lociora, AB tenuia; 270.31 ABC Petrus; 270.32 D est om.; 271.2 D aliam; 271.8 ABC Et sic; 271.9 B vel in; 271.10 ABC ista; 271.14 C esse in marg., DE isto esse; 271.19 C committanter (n. 15), ABC aut non, E autem om.; 271.20 DE Esto om., DE quia, DE est (n. 16); 271.27–28 E materie sim; 271.29–30 E varietur; 271.32 E tamquam diu; 272.2 ABC satis edocta; 272.4 E protegere; 272.9–10 E in testimonium (n. 20).