De benedicta incarnacione, chapter 5, part 2
That the blessed cannot cease to be blessed, and the Word would sin with the humanity
Harris pp. 68.5–72.18
¶168.5–70.3
Again, every blessed one in heaven is so inextricablyinsolubiliter: inextricably joined to God that it is incompatiblerepugnare; repugnancia: to be incompatible; incompatibility with that statestatus (disposicionis, virtutis, …): state (of disposition, of virtue, …) that the misery of sin should succeed or coexist in the soul: now Christ from the instant of the unionunio: union was more perfectly blessed as to the soul than any other, since he was the holy of holies: therefore much more is it incompatible with his soul that sin should succeed or coexist: now if the laying-asidedimittere / dimissio (naturam): lay aside / the laying-aside were possible, this could have happened: therefore that laying-aside was not possible.1 The major is proved from this. All the blessed are immortal and impeccable, as all who speak correctlyrectiloqui: those who speak correctly confess: not because they cannot sin, for many sin earlier, in their own time; but they are in the grace of confirmation and of glory, with which it is incompatible that sin or misery should coexist, or succeed after it: it is clear, therefore, that blessedness is a quality implying security of the perpetuity of full joy and of the exclusion of misery.2 Hence all theologians confess in concord that "someone is or was blessed, together with his afterwards being made not blessed" implies a contradictionclaudit contradictionem / contradictorium: it implies a contradiction. Nor does it avail to say that blessedness is blessedness by accidentper se / per accidens: of itself / by accident; (spatial) apart, by itself, for it is the ultimate abstract form by which someone is formally blessed. So, if it is not blessedness of itselfper se / per accidens: of itself / by accident; (spatial) apart, by itself, nothing else remains that would be [so] of itself.3 69As, therefore, justice cannot be not-justice, and so of similar forms, so the state of blessedness cannot be not such a state. Hence it is known to metaphysicians that such abstract forms do not admit predicationposicio / proposicio / predicacio: position / proposition / predication by accident in the way that concretes do: for if blessedness is blessedness by accident (since there is no process to infinity, but, since everything by accident is reducible to something of itself, one must come to an ultimate formal [principle] by which someone is blessed), that too is blessedness of itself and not by accident: and it is of such that I am speaking.4 This is confirmed. If the quality A is now blessedness, and can remain and cease to be blessedness, by the same token, after its being [so], it can begin again to be blessedness.5 Which being granted, it is clear that besides A, which does not suffice to namedenominacio; denominare: naming; to name a man blessed, a superadded form is required; and so not A, but a form coming to it, would be blessedness. It is clear, therefore, that since blessedness and confirmation cannot be unless they are perpetual, neither can they be except of such a kind that, by the very fact that they are present, they set a man in a state with which it is incompatible that misery should succeed or coexist; nor does blessedness depend on the future any more than other absolute qualities do; for then the blessed would not be made secure of their blessedness.6 The minor of the argument, therefore, is clear generally to every professor of the faith of the incarnation: since the soul of Christ from the instant of its creation was full of every kind of charismscarismata; carisma: charisms / chrism, having a clearer vision of the divine essenceens / esse / essencia: a being / being (existence) / essence than any other creaturecreatura / creator / creatus: creature / creator / created, and consequently full enjoyment following naturally on so great a knowledge.7 Since, therefore, "eternal life is thus to know God the Father and the Lord Jesus Christ", as the Truth testifies, John 17, it is clear that the soul of Christ from the instant of its creation is perpetually blessed.8 Nor have I heard this denied by anyone, since it follows openly from the incarnation. For if a man understands only what the mind 70hypostatically joined understands, by the topic from sufficient likeness the spirit of Jesus knows whatever Jesus himself had known, especially since he is personally the Word of God.9
¶270.4–70.32
From these such an argument is gathered. It is as determined and necessary that "this man has been assumed" as it is necessary that "the world, or something else, has been before": now he could not have been assumed unless he had thereupon been blessed: therefore it is as necessary that "he has been blessed" as it is necessary that "something has been before": now pasts of this kind cannot be loosed: therefore neither [can] the blessedness or the assumptionassumere / assumpcio (naturam): assume / assumption of our Lord Jesus Christ.10 Second, this is confirmed from this, that the soul of Christ by an elicited act saw clearly in the Word all things past or future; and consequently saw clearly the perpetuity of its blessedness; and further, since that vision could not have been lacking, or be turned into ignorance or another genus of being, it follows that that soul could not cease to be blessed or hypostaticallyypostatice: hypostatically joined to the Word. Third, this is confirmed from the testimony of Pope Leo in a certain sermon, saying: "So great was the uniting of God and man that it could neither be severed by punishment nor divided by death."11 Nor does the divine dispensationpreponderancia; dispensacio: preponderance; dispensation stand against this teachingsentencia: teaching / sentence, by which he willed his Word for a time to be a body not fully but, as it were, by way of earnestarraliter: by way of earnest then blessed, and consequently to be a soul, as to the actuation of the body and the aspect under which it regards it, however sorrowful.12 For that man is each of many natures, as to one of which he was for a time a cast-down wayfarerviator: wayfarer, and at the same time as to another a most perfect comprehensorcomprehensor: comprehensor: and so at the same time supremely rejoicing and supremely sorrowful as to diverse powers and aspects, as is shown in what follows: and I say that he had by way of earnest on the wayvia / patria: the way / the homeland the dowriesdotes (docium) beatorum; dotes corporis: the dowries of the blessed; the dowries of the body of the body: with the dowry of subtlety the bridegroom went out from the closed womb, with the dowry of agility he walked upon the waters, with the dowry of incorruptibility and of brightness he shone out in the transfiguration.13
¶370.33–71.15
Third, the same is clear through [one] leading to the impossible.14 For if 71the humanityhumanitas: the humanity hypostatically joined could be laid asidedimittere / dimissio (naturam): lay aside / the laying-aside and so be damned for sin, and both the flesh and the soul are personally the Word himself, it followssequitur: it follows that the Word of God could sin and be damned; which it is impious to say. The inferenceconsequencia: inference is clear, the foundation being supposed, since it is argued from an inferior to its personal superior, to which personal action belongs of itself. It follows, therefore: "This humanity can sin: this humanity is the personpersona: person of the Word: therefore the person of the Word can sin." For the person of the Word is not onlynedum: not only this humanity but something else, since [it is] the divinitydeitas / divinitas: the Godhead / divinity; so it is superior to, or more common than, this humanity.15 Hence, as it follows that the Son of God was born humanlyhumanitus: humanly, lived among [men], suffered, died, and was buried, and ascended, because the humanity, which was the said Son, was so, so also it would follow that the Word sinned, if the humanity, which was the said Word, sinned.
¶471.16–72.18
This is confirmed from the testimony of the more modernmoderni doctores / moderniores doctores: the modern doctors / the more modern doctors [doctors], who say that this humanity could not be hypostatically joined while sinning unless the Word thereupon sinned; and, what is more, by reason of the prior union the Word is named, according to the more modern, as having lain for the three daystriduum (in triduo): the three days in the tomb, and in a quite similar sense as having sinned, in the case in which the naturenatura: nature laid aside had sinned at that time.16 What, I ask, is the cause of the difference, that the sense of the Holy Spirit in this article of faitharticulus fidei: article of faith, "Christ descended into hell, was dead and buried", is "not that person, but a part of him, for the time in which it was not a part or hypostatically joined, was so", and that one would not grant, in a most similar sense, that the nature laid aside and afterwards reassumed, if it sinned in the meantime, would name the Son as so sinning?17 Let it be posited, then, that on the day of the Parasceve the soul of Christ completed the freeing of the fathers from limbolimbus: limbo, and at that time the body is driven by a demon, battering many men, and that on 72the holy sabbath the soul is reunited to the body, the hypostatic union being suspended, and sins before none by adultery, homicide, blasphemy, and every kind of sin; and after none repents, and begets lawfully, and justly condemns many to death, the humanity being assumedassumere / assumpcio (naturam): assume / assumption on the first [day] of the week into the unity of the suppositsuppositum: supposit of the Word of God:18 a case which the modernmoderni doctores / moderniores doctores: the modern doctors / the more modern doctors [doctors] admit, and more marvellous ones, as necessarily possible; in which case it seems, according to the glossglosa: gloss they give to the articles of faith, that all the said operations in the three days would redound upon Christ, or else one would be feigning, from the prompting of the Holy Spirit, an impossible and unaccustomed sense.19 It is certain, therefore, that Christ did not stifle these men, lose the aureolelaureola: aureole of virginity by the begetting of seed, incur irregularityirregularitas: irregularity, or that traces of sins remained in him. And by a conformable reason he neither lay buried nor descended into hell, unless by a conformable reason the aforesaid namingsdenominacio; denominare: naming; to name in the case posited belong to him; or else the teaching stated above must be said: that the hypostatic union remained for the said three days to both.20
Notes
- 1 68.10 sed si: A B C read coesse. Secundo Christus si, opening a new step ("Second: Christ ..."); the print, with O, keeps a single argument. A B C alia for illa (68.11); O possibiliter, contingisse (68.11), and vel added by a second hand (68.7).
- 2 68.19–25: the passage Harris prints in square brackets, Eciam securitas … igitur etcetera, is wanting in C and in O and stands only in A B (in B partly in the margin). C and O agree across the families against the print, and the sentence construes without it (patet ergo … miserie. Unde omnes theologi …), so it is left out of the English above. It runs: "Also, the security of the perpetuity of full joy and of the exclusion of misery is of itself such a security, since one must come to an ultimate formal [principle], by which formally and by no other someone is secure of the perpetuity of full joy and of the exclusion of misery. Now it implies a contradiction that [misery] should coexist with such [a security] in its subject, or that after it misery should succeed in that same subject: therefore etc." At 68.14 non quia non possunt peccare: the blessed are "impeccable" not in that they never could sin, for they sinned on the way. A B C reliquie for rectiloqui (68.13).
- 3 68.29–31 per accidens / per se: "by accident / of itself", the two kinds of predication (Harris italicises them as terms). An abstract form such as blessedness is what it is of itself; only a concrete subject is blessed by accident. At 68.26–27 C reads contradiccionem anime esse.
- 4 69.5–9: the conditional si enim … beatitudo is interrupted by the parenthesis, and et illud … est beatitudo is taken as its apodosis: whatever is blessedness by accident leads back to a form that is blessedness of itself. B substancialibus for similibus (69.2).
- 5 69.11 post esse: taken as "after its being [so]", i.e. after having ceased; the phrase is bare, and a word may be lost (post [desinere] esse?). O omits manere et. The argument: a quality that could stop and start being blessedness would need a further form to make it blessedness, and that form, not it, would be blessedness.
- 6 69.20 absolute: Harris suggests abstracte ("abstract", cf. forme abstracte, 69.4); the print is kept.
- 7 69.23 carismatum: the glossary entry, here "charisms", gifts, not chrism. A C generaliter for naturaliter (69.26); O cariorem for clariorem (69.24).
- 8 John 17:3 (DR "Now this is eternal life: That they may know thee, the only true God, and Jesus Christ, whom thou hast sent"): Wyclif gives the verse’s sense in his own words. Veritas, "the Truth", is Christ. A B C beatificata for beata (69.29).
- 9 69.31–70.3: homo is taken as any man, whose understanding is his mind’s; so, by likeness, the spirit of Jesus, a mind hypostatically joined, knows what Jesus knows, who is personally the Word. Alternatively homo is "the man" Jesus himself. Per locum a sufficienti similitudine: "by the topic from sufficient likeness", an argument from a like case. A intelligit (rasura) mens, C intelligit quod mens; O cognoverit.
- 10 70.4–11: what has been cannot not have been: if the assumption is a past as necessary as any past, so is the blessedness bound up with it. Pretericiones: "pasts", truths about the past. Solvi: "be loosed", the verb of the John text in 05-c.
- 11 Leo, "in a certain sermon": Sermo 68 (De passione 17) c. 1, PL 54, 373A: cum in tantam unitatem Dei et hominis natura convenerit, ut nec supplicio potuerit dirimi, nec morte disjungi (verified). Distingui for disjungi is Wyclif’s or his exemplar’s. A B C unio for unicio, potest for posset (70.18–19).
- 12 70.21 arraliter: "by way of earnest" (arra, the pledge paid ahead of the whole sum): the body’s blessedness given in part beforehand. A B C add esse after tunc. Racionem, qua ipsam respicit: the aspect under which the soul regards the body; O quam, dolosam. Sentencia is the glossary entry, here "teaching".
- 13 70.24–25 multarum naturarum quelibet: "each of many natures" (Godhead, body, soul; cf. the three natures of 01-a). Comprehensor: one who has attained the end, against viator. The dowries are the gifts of the glorified body, here shown beforehand in the virgin birth, the walking on the water, and the transfiguration. A B C ut ostenditur ut dico (70.28–29); O enituit for emicuit.
- 14 70.33 per deducens ad impossibile: per with a bare participle, as printed, "through [one] leading to the impossible", the reductio ad impossibile; a noun (argumentum?) may be lost. A B C illud for idem.
- 15 71.5–10 ab inferiori ad suum superius personale: from the lower term (this humanity) to the higher (the person of the Word): the person is both the humanity and the Godhead, so it is the wider, "more common" term. B omits humanitas … aliud (71.9) and reads quam communior quam (71.10); O ista, omitting est (71.11).
- 16 71.16–22: the more modern doctors grant that the Word is named from the prior union as having lain in the tomb; Wyclif turns the admission against them: the same naming would make the Word a sinner in the case put. O modernorum (71.16); B C potest (71.17); O peccaverit (71.18).
- 17 71.22–28 Que … causa diversitatis … quin … concederet: taken as one question: why read the article of the part (the body buried, the soul in hell), yet refuse the like reading for a sin of the nature laid aside. O peccaret for peccare; O qui (71.25), copulativa (71.26).
- 18 72.1 †reuniatur: Harris’s dagger. A C reniatur, B revivatur, C in the margin revinatur, O reunciatur; Harris says read revinciatur ("be bound again") or reuniatur. The manuscripts do not agree, and the print is translated. The case runs from Good Friday (parasceve, the day of preparation) through the sabbath to prima sabbati, the first day of the week; nonam, "none", is the ninth hour. O perfeceret libacionem patrum a libo (71.29–30).
- 19 72.10 fingeret: its subject is not expressed, and is taken as "one"; C finge (lacuna), O fīgᵗ. A B dant autores, C dat autores, "the authors give" (72.8); O omits quod.
- 20 72.18 ad utrumque: to both, body and soul. Sentencia supradicta: Wyclif’s own teaching, argued in the chapters before, that the union remained in the three days. A B C aureolam for laureolam (72.12); O suffocare (72.12); A B sibi posito insunt (72.16).
How the Latin of this chapter was established
- Plate readings; page · reading · note):
- 71: hec humanitas, (bt ran together; print hec ³ humanitas (two words)) [SUB]
- Omitted per §3.5 / kept in the English (margin matter): reference s. John xvii. 3. (69.28); reference l Cor. i. 25. (72.30).