De benedicta incarnacione, chapter 8, part 1
Against Christ’s identity of species, the first two objections
Harris pp. 123.0–127.4
¶1123.0–123.0
[It objects in three ways against the identity of speciesydemptitas specifica: identity of species of Christ with others, and resolves the objections.]
¶2123.2–123.12
From these things the solution is clear of the arguments commonly made to prove "Christ is not univocallyunivoce: univocally man with others." First, by this: nothing is placed in a species through something accidental to it: now the humanityhumanitas: the humanity of Christ is accidental to him: therefore he is not in a new species because of it: now before the incarnation he was not of the same species with us: therefore neither after, because of an adventitious unionunio: union. This is confirmed by the topic from likeness. For if a man newly acquires whiteness, or any other form inhering accidentally, he is not by this of a different species: therefore, by the same token, neither is Christ, because of a humanity so adventitious.
¶3123.13–123.21
As to that, it is clear from what has been said that something false is assumed.1 For the WordVerbum: the Word, who before was above every species, by the assumptionassumere / assumpcio (naturam): assume / assumption of the humanity was made in our species and "under the law" (Gal 4:4). And as to the likeness, the difference of the reasoning is clear from what has been said. For if, per impossibile, whiteness or another inhering form were that by which the subjectsubiectum / passio: subject / attribute would be something, or other than it had been before (as by the humanity the Word becomes something other than he had been before), the argument would proceed by the topic from likeness: but the antecedent is impossible.
¶4123.22–124.16
And if sophistical arguments are multiplied to prove "whatever is the Word was eternally the Word", the solution is clear from what has been said about forms. For something, since it is some 124substantial formforma substancialis: substantial form or naturenatura: nature, is now the Word which was not the Word in the first instant of time.2 For before "the Word was made flesh" (John 1:14) "in the fulness of time" (Gal 4:4), he was not man;3 and it is certain that to be a man is to be something: so when he was becoming man, he was becoming something which he had not been before. Nevertheless every suppositsuppositum: supposit, hypostasisypostasis: hypostasis, or personpersona: person which is, or which was, the Word, was eternally the Word. But far be it to conclude from this, "therefore whatever".4 For the Word is something other, but not someone other, after the incarnation than he was before. And so to one asking, "Who is now the Son of God who was not always?", "The same", the answer isdicitur (opening an answer): the answer is: [meaning] that no one is or can be the natural Son of God except one who absolutely necessarily always was.5 But to one asking, "What is the Son of God that he had not been before the incarnation?", the answer is: "Human nature, or humanity; and that is the quiddityquiditas: quiddity of the supposit or person."
¶5124.17–124.23
And the solution is clear to such quibblesargucie; argucia: stratagems, quibbles; a quibble as: "Every person which is the Word was eternally the Word: now whatever is now the Word is a person which is the Word: therefore whatever is now the Word was eternally the Word." Indeed all such deductions, [made] sophisticallysophistice: sophistically, are cured by knowledge of the fallacyfallacia: fallacy of accident.6 For quiddity in a genus is accidental to the person of the Word, as quality is accidental to created substance.
¶6124.24–124.29
And if, third, it is argued thus: "This Word in the beginning was the Word (John 1:1), and this Word is this humanity; therefore this humanity in the beginning was the Word", it is clear that it is the same as if it were argued thus: "In the beginning it was [so] that this is the Word; and this Word is that man; therefore it was then [so] that it is man"; for so "humanity" signifies, without qualificationsimpliciter / secundum quid: without qualification / in a certain respect, abstractivelyabstractive: abstractively.7
¶7124.30–125.23
And if, fourth, the sophistsophista: sophist rejoinsreplicatur; replicatum: it is rejoined; rejoinder by conversionconversio (eucharistic): conversion from exclusivesexclusiva: the exclusive [proposition] or exceptives, "Only this is now the Word" (pointing to the person of the Word) "and this was eternally the Word; 125therefore nothing now is the Word except what was eternally the Word",8 it is evident that the antecedentconsequens / antecedens: consequent / antecedent is true and the consequentconsequens / antecedens: consequent / antecedent false. For although only this is the Word, yet not only this humanity is the Word: since the Godheaddeitas / divinitas: the Godhead / divinity, which is something other than that humanity, is the Word and was eternally the Word. And it is clear that, although only man and only God is the Word, not only the humanity is the Word, nor is nothing besides the Godhead the Word.9 For something other than the Godhead and something other than the humanity is the Word; but neither someone other nor something other than God or man is the Word. For if only the Godhead were Jesus, then the Father, in divine things, would not in any way be greater than Jesus (John 14:28). And it is evident how exclusives and exceptives are to be fitted to their universals; so that, this being said, "every Jesus is a humanity", it is permitted correspondingly to give this exclusive, "only a person which is a humanity is Jesus", and proportionally the exceptiveexceptiva: exceptive [proposition]; and a not wholly conformable sophistrysophisticacio: sophistry may be had about any other man, who is man of himselfper se / per accidens: of itself / by accident; (spatial) apart, by itself, but adventitiously by bodily nature.10 Hence each of us in the final resurrection will be something other than he was in death, because another nature; since in the resurrection he will be both bodily nature and incorporeal nature, but in death only incorporeal nature.11 But he will not be someone other: rather, solely the same self, since he cannot be other than the same person.
¶8125.24–126.6
And that great philosopher, holy Job, wove that metaphysics in, in chapter 19, when he said: "in my flesh I shall see God my saviour: I myself," he says, "and not another."12 Hence Gregory, Morals 18, chapter 32: "Although Christ is something from the Father, something other from the mother, yet he is not someone from the Father, someone other from the virgin: but he himself is eternal from the Father, temporally from the mother; he himself who made, he himself who was made; he himself the author of the work, he himself the work of the author; remaining one from both and in both natures; neither confused by the coupling of the natures, 126nor doubled by the distinction of the natures."13 Behold another testimony of a holy doctor on the teachingsentencia: teaching / sentence so often stated.14 And so Augustine is to be understood in the Dialogue to Felicianus, about the middle, and more often elsewhere, when he says: "For although the body is one thing, the soul another, yet one and the same man is called both body and soul."15
¶9126.7–127.4
Second, as a main headprincipaliter; principalitas (of the body's presence): principally; principality, it is argued against the identity of species of Christ with others from this, that he is man only by accidentper se / per accidens: of itself / by accident; (spatial) apart, by itself, and anyone else of himself. But it is clear from what has been said that it does not follow; since that accident by which Christ is formally man, which the Apostle calls "humanationhumanitacio: humanation" and "habit", is of the same kind as the forms by which Christ’s brothers are formally men, and is not an accident without qualificationsimpliciter / secundum quid: without qualification / in a certain respect.16 But because Christ is a giant of twofold substance, namely Godhead and humanity, of which the lower is contingently in the higher,17 therefore the humanity, in the sense set out, is said to be an accident to the Word of God. And if it is asked whether Christ is of himself man, it seems to me that he is. For since "Christ" signifiesdicere (logical use): signify two forms, namely the Godhead and the humanity, identified in the same person, and can stand without qualification for either:18 it is clear that, understanding him as to the humanitysecundum deitatem / secundum humanitatem: as to the Godhead / as to the humanity, he is as much of himself man as any individualindividuum: individual of his kind; since he is as truly caused from qualitativepars qualitativa: qualitative part and quidditativequiditativus: quidditative parts of like kind, and depends as much on body and soul, on species and genus with their differencesdifferencia: difference (logical differentia), as Peter. Nor is there colourcolor (non est color): colour (a plausible ground), if Christ is man by accident because [he is so] as to the Godhead, [for saying] that he is not man of himself:19 for apart from the Godhead there is the humanity of Christ, which is of itself man, since universaluniversale; ydea: universal; idea humanity is of its essence. And so, as the Word of God is born by a twofold birth, so it seems to me that by a twofold 127rationality he is, quite equivocallyequivoce: equivocally, rational. For as to the created substance he is caused by humanity and common rationality, like other creaturescreatura / creator / creatus: creature / creator / created: and hence the first mode of predicating of itself, from the Posterior Analytics 2, belongs to him.20
Notes
- 1 Falsum assumitur: the logician’s assumere, "take as a premiss" (the minor, humanitas Christi est sibi accidentalis, 123.5–6), not the assumption of the nature at 123.15.
- 2 Aliquid, quia aliqua forma substancialis vel natura: forma and natura are nominative, "since it is some substantial form or nature", the humanity. Read loosely as a cause ("by some form"), the sentence would say the Word became the Word by a form.
- 3 In plenitudine temporis is Wyclif’s form; Gal 4:4 Vulgate ubi venit plenitudo temporis, DR "when the fulness of the time was come". The two phrases are joined as one quotation in the print’s punctuation.
- 4 Ergo quicquid is the print’s, with O. A B read quicquam without ergo ("far be it to conclude anything from this"), C quod quitquam. The print is kept: the point is that the universal quicquid does not follow from omne suppositum.
- 5 Idem (124.11) is the print’s, with O; A B C read eidem ("to him the answer is"), which makes the sentence run parallel to Sed querenti ... dicitur quod below. The print is kept. "The same" answers the question: the Son of God now is none other than the one who always was.
- 6 Sophistice is taken with deducciones tales, "made sophistically"; with sanantur it would make the cure sophistical. The fallacy of accident: what holds of the person does not hold of whatever is now the person by an accidental form.
- 7 Simpliciter abstractive: the abstract humanitas, taken without qualification, signifies the fact "that it is man"; so "this Word is this humanity" amounts to "this Word is that man", and the conclusion only says that what is now man was the Word in the beginning (John 1:1).
- 8 Per conversionem ab exclusivis aut exceptivis: the logicians’ rule that an exclusive ("only A is B") converts to a universal with the terms exchanged ("every B is A"), and an exceptive ("nothing except A is B") likewise.
- 9 Nec nichil preter deitatem est Verbum: a double negative, kept: it is false that nothing besides the Godhead is the Word, since the humanity is the Word too.
- 10 Non conformissimam (125.16) is the print’s; A B C omit non ("and a most conformable sophistry"); O’s abbreviation (ɔformissia˥) leaves its reading uncertain. The print is kept: in other men the case is like Christ’s but not the same, since their bodily nature is adventitious to a man who is man of himself.
- 11 Alia natura ... natura corporea ... natura incorporea are taken as nominatives (he will be another nature); they could be ablatives ("by another nature", "by bodily nature"), as adventicie natura corporea is just above.
- 12 Job 19:26–27, Vulgate in carne mea videbo Deum meum: quem visurus sum ego ipse ... et non alius; DR "in my flesh I shall see my God. Whom I myself shall see ... and not another". Wyclif’s Deum salvatorem meum is not the Vulgate’s.
- 13 Gregory, Moralia XVIII.52.85, PL 76, 90B (old division c. 35; Wyclif’s 32 matches neither), abridged (verified). 125.30 ipse qui fecit ipse qui factus est, with A B C and Gregory’s text, against the print’s ipse, qui fecit, factus (O).
- 14 Sepe dicta, with A B C O, against the print’s supradicta: A B C read de s͡cia sepe dicta, O de sm͡a sepe dicta. The noun is Harris’s expansion, sentencia, kept.
- 15 Vigilius of Thapsus, Contra Felicianum Arianum, among Augustine’s works, c. 11, PL 42, 1166: quamvis aliud animus, aliud corpus, unus tamen atque idem homo et corpus docetur et animus; Wyclif inverts the pair and has dicitur (verified).
- 16 Humanitacionem et habitum (126.12) is the print’s, with O; A B C read humanitatem et hominem. The Apostle’s word is habitus (Phil 2:7, "in habit found as a man"), which supports the print.
- 17 Gigas gemine substancie: Ambrose’s hymn Intende qui regis Israel (Veni redemptor gentium), geminae gigas substantiae, on Ps 18:6, "hath rejoiced as a giant to run the way" (PL 16, 1411; verified).
- 18 Ydemptificatas is Harris’s emendation; every manuscript reads ydemptitas, and A B C add que sunt before it ("which are identity in the same person"). Neither reading construes well, so the print is kept. Christus (126.18) is the print’s, with O; A B C read Iesus: the argument turns on the name Christus (126.19). Supponere simpliciter may be the logicians’ simple supposition; rendered by the glossary’s "without qualification".
- 19 Color: a plausible ground. The construal is: if Christ is man by accident when taken as to the Godhead, that gives no ground for denying that he is man of himself.
- 20 The first mode of per se predication (the predicate in the definition of the subject), Aristotle, Posterior Analytics I.4, 73a34–37; Wyclif’s "2°" is not explained, perhaps a slip; Harris’s index has 2 Post. Anal. without a locus (verified for I.4).
How the Latin of this chapter was established
- Plate readings; page · reading · note):
- 124: argucias—Omnis (print as transcribed) [SUB]
- 125: dicto—omnis (print as transcribed) [SUB]
- 125: Iesus—et (print as transcribed) [SUB]
- Omitted per §3.5 / kept in the English (margin matter): reference John i. 14. (124.3); reference 25 Job xlx- 26"27- (125.25); reference So Gregory (125.27); reference Augustinus (127.11).