De potestate pape, chapter 12, part 5
The wicked prelate worse than the devil; two heads, two clergies
Loserth pp. 330.13–333.5
¶1330.13–333.5
Likewise Augustine, On the Degrees of Abuses, chapter 9:1 "Let the king know," he says, "that as he has been set first in the kingdom of men, so also in punishments, if he has not done justice, he will have the primacyprimatus: primacy. For all the sinners whatsoever whom he has had under him in the present he will have above him, implacably, in the punishment to come."2 And the same holds more evidently of the popepapa: pope, as Chrysostom teaches in Homily 51 of the Opus imperfectum, and as is clear in Distinction 40, Si papa:3 "As a priest," he says, "is glorified above all the people if he has done well, not only for his own justice but for that of all, because he is the cause of the justice of all, so also, sinning, he is punished above all, not only for his own sins but for those of all, because he becomes the cause of sinning to all." Hence the testimony of Chrysostom in the same place is effective: "Those," he says, "who feign themselves to be Christians, though they are Antichrists, seem to be in the churchecclesia: church and act hypocritically against the church"; indeed, in Homily 44 331this saint says that an evil man is "worse than the devil, indeed the worst evil", that is, he has the character of a malice surpassing the devil, the beasts and any other evil creature. "The devil," he says, "is put to flight by a man’s justice and virtuemotrix (anima, virtus): moving, but a perverse man persecutes such a one more cruelly; the devil does not overcome a man except through a man, but Antichrist overcomes a man by himself." Therefore, where the devil’s meander does not avail, he supplies the temptation through a man, against whom it profits nothing to bless oneself, the art by which the devil is put to flight.4 If, then, a man mocks the people by ecclesiastical censurescensura: censure, coming in the name of Christ, who is a greater Antichrist?5 Thirdly, LincolnLincolniensis: Lincoln, in his sermon to the pope, declares that, as the most divine work of a wayfarerviator: wayfarer is to make like to God souls fallen from him by sin, so the highest work of Satan, of Antichrist and of a heretic runs contrary to this divine art, and this those who preside over this curia do.6 If they command anything contrary to the commandments of Christ, if for gain they ordain anything that draws away the office of the shepherd, or if they suspendsuspendere; suspencio: to suspend; suspension, weaken or retard the powerpotestas: power of this curia, then, he says, "the revelation of the son of perdition is at the doors".7 If, I say, the pope accomplishes these things and perseveres in them constantly and finally, he is without doubt Antichrist; so that, as Christ succeeded the priests of the old law, adding to his law a praiseworthy interpretation, so Antichrist will succeed the caesarean bishops, adding to the law of Christ a culpable obscuring.8 And on both sides the same kind will be kept; 332which is done blindly and wickedly by setting over [the people] an unfit superiorprepositi: superiors, by suspending the office of a good prelateprelatus: prelate, and by wholly neglecting to stir oneself, forbidding the exercise of Christ for overcoming the devil.9 And he declares that the curia is the cause of many such things; which can be discerned by this, that it disagrees with the threefold definitiondescripcio: definition of the pope recited above. But as to the first point, concerning a headcaput: head that terminates ecclesiastical causes, it is clear that Christ is a most sufficient head, as he proved for three hundred years and more, when the church prospered; and his law is most effective for this, since God issued it to this end. But perhaps after the endowmentdotacio: endowment of the church there must be a foreign lawgiver, say Antichrist; now this is to the desolation of the church; therefore it would be the same to assert that there must be such a head of the church for terminating ecclesiastical causes, and to say that one must desert Christ and his law and embrace Antichrist with his laws and accomplices; for it was unworthy that Christ’s apostles should be occupied in such things in such a way. Therefore one must consider a twofold sectreligio privata; secta: private religion; sect of the clergyclerus; clericus: the clergy; cleric, namely the clergy of Christ and the clergy of Antichrist, contrary to the former:10 the clergy of Christ rests in that head and his laws, but the clergy of Antichrist leans either wholly or preponderantly on the laws of Antichrist, and yet is cloakedpalliacio; palliare: cloaking; to cloak as being the clergy of Christ and of the church, so that the people may be the more deceitfully led astray. And these, being so contrary, must lean on two contrary heads with their laws. And the evidence of the fact teaches the definitions of the membersmembrum: member. 333It is evident, indeed, that the clergy of the church limps, divided into two parts, namely into the part of Christ and the caesarean part. Therefore the laity, supported by men so unlike in opinion and life, must needs stagger.11
Notes
- 1 De duodecim abusivis saeculi, the ninth abuse (rex iniquus), transmitted under the names of Augustine and Cyprian; Loserth: Augustine, Opera (Maurist) VI, Appendix, p. 215 (= PL 40, 1086). Modern scholarship, since Hellmann’s edition (1909), assigns it to an anonymous Irish author of the seventh century.
- 2 Modo implacabili: so Loserth, from the source; the manuscripts read modo plagabili (330.18), which does not construe as well. We translate the print.
- 3 Pseudo-Chrysostom, Opus imperfectum in Matthaeum, hom. 51; Loserth: Chrysostom, Opera VI, pp. 925–928. Decretum D.40 c.6 Si papa (Loserth "Cap. VI"; the modern form is ours). The second extract ("Those who feign …") Loserth places at Op. imp. p. 928; "Homily 44" (331.1) he does not identify: the passage is hom. 24 in Migne (on Matthew 10:17), so XLIV is probably a slip for XXIV.
- 4 Meander: the winding of the river Maeander, a common figure for tortuous wiles. Benedicere: to bless oneself (with the sign of the cross), the art that puts the devil to flight, but which avails nothing against a man.
- 5 "Coming in the name of Christ" alludes to Matthew 24:5 ("many will come in my name"). Pocior is the comparative of potissimus (329.28).
- 6 Robert Grosseteste. The "sermon to the pope" is the memorandum Grosseteste read before Innocent IV at Lyons in 1250 (in Brown, Fasciculus rerum expetendarum II, 250–257), which has "in januis est revelatio Filii perditionis" and "the cause, fount and origin of this is this curia". Loserth’s hesitant "seems to be" Epistolae no. 128, p. 432, shares some themes but not these words. C. Contrarie is taken as the adverb ("runs contrary").
- 7 2 Thessalonians 2:3 ("the son of perdition") and Matthew 24:33 ("at the doors"), joined. C. Potestatem huius curie: the curia’s own (pastoral) power, which its presidents hamper; Grosseteste’s context suggests cure, the pastoral charge, a reading the apparatus does not give.
- 8 Legi sue: "his law", the old law as Christ’s own; sue could refer to the priests ("their law").
- 9 Prohibens: a nominative participle left without a subject; it describes the one who sets over and suspends.
- 10 Loserth: Hus takes over the whole passage on the twofold clergy (De ecclesia, ch. 15; Opera, p. 226). Both manuscripts note in the margin Clerus duplex Christi et Antichristi.
- 11 "Limps … into two parts" echoes 1 Kings 18:21 (DR 3 Kings 18:21), "How long do you halt between two sides?" C. Tam dispares is taken with ipsos, the two parts of the clergy; it could go with laycos, "the laity, so unlike in opinion and life".
How the Latin of this chapter was established
- Plate readings; page · reading · note):
- 330: sicut
- 330: et
- 330: pena futura (one main token covers two printed words)
- 330: habebit
- 330: XL
- 330: Si papa (one main token covers two printed words)
- 330: Quomodo
- 330: non (25 is the line number)
- 331: dyabolo
- 332: preficiendo [NW]
- 332: ∅ (the is the English side note (Falsity of the plea that the ...))
- 332: Sed
- 332: ∅ (folio bar after duobus (244ᵃ in margin) read as i)