De potestate pape, chapter 12, part 7
The law of christ suffices for the church without men’s laws
Loserth pp. 338.9–342.18
¶1338.9–339.25
Therefore such a preacher of the gospel would preach the life and doctrine of Christ, in which there is no danger. Second, he would expound how the saint on whom he relies, [where he relies on him] not in the law which Christ instituted, turned aside;1 third, he would consider whether we observe a manner as praiseworthy as the patronspatronus: patron on whom we rely did, since, because God is a rewarder of adverbs, the manner is most of all to be attended to;2 and fourth we would consider in the lives of the fathers whether the fathers of our order lived more closely and more holily when, living without propertyexproprietarii / exproprietarie: the propertyless / without property and contrary to us, they followed the saviour more easily and more like him.3 For a small error, which is imperceptibleinsensibilis: imperceptible; of a thing that cannot feel, without sensation by the depravity of sin, becomes by continual increase a perceptiblesensibilis (in the definition of animal): sentient and intolerable sin, to be destroyed by the whole churchecclesia: church, as is especially clear in the endowmentdotacio: endowment of the church, which grew from bare almselemosina: alms into poisonous lordshipdominium: lordship.4 So, therefore, that twofold moral principle, put into practicepractizare: to put into practice in the way of conduct (to go backward is unlawful, and of two goods the better and the easier is to be chosen), would set right the whole church; therefore all of us, without excuse, must attend to it in effect. But, returning to the second teachingsentencia: teaching / sentence, on the necessity of the laws of the church, it is clear from what has often been said that the church would be better ruled by the pure 339law of the Lord than by [the laws of the church] by themselves, or with laws devised by men added to the law of the Lord.5 This is clear from the fact that in the first way the church would be ruled more conformably to God’s honour, more directly to serving him, and more abundantly to bringing in the peace of the church. Hence it seems an antichristian heresy that God’s law is not sufficient by itself, nor as sufficient as men’s laws, to extinguish the injuries sprouting in the church;6 for to confound such unbeliefsinfidelitas: heathenism, unbelief it is said of Antichrist in Psalm 9:21: "Appoint, O Lord, a lawgiver over them: that the Gentiles may know themselves to be but men", men to the image of God, for whom he created [it] to establish a law complete in his reckoning; therefore they ought to live according to it as men and not as brute beasts.7 For God out of his highest wisdom established the law and gave it to the church for this end. Therefore if human law were more complete for this than God’s law, Antichrist would exceed Jesus Christ in powerpotencia: potency / power, in wisdom and in providence; and then the teaching of his disciples would be true, that it would be more expedient for the church that the decretal epistles were read at masses than the epistles of the apostles or the gospel; for the more necessary and more expedient a law is, the more it is to be venerated and the more meritoriously commended.
¶2339.27–340.14
Again, the law of Christ does more to bring peace with God, and disposes more to the salvation of the soul, than human tradition; now, in so far as a law does this, it is more honourable and more necessary; therefore the law of Christ excels human tradition in proportion. And since the peace which a man has with God infinitely exceeds any other peace, just as the salvation of the soul and spiritual prosperity infinitely exceed the other goods which 340are acquired through men’s laws, it is clear that God’s law infinitely exceeds men’s laws; and from the same [premiss] it followssequitur: it follows that it is infinitely more excellent for pleasing God and for suffering with the people;8 for by the observance of that law, and not otherwise, would [God] be pleased, and consequently man would be at peace with God; now, once peace with God has been gained, peace is acquired with every creature. How, I ask, would every creature not obey and profit a man whom it saw its God obeying in friendship?9 Therefore, even if the members of the devil trouble the friends of Christ, yet they profit them, as ones who obeyobedienciarius: one who obeys and as friends; for so Iscariot was a friend to Christ (John 18), and, though serving unwillingly, procured the peace of Christ.10
¶3340.15–340.26
Again, the law of Christ by itself would breed charitycaritas: charity in the people more abundantly than men’s laws by themselves or mingled with the law of the Lord. And the conclusionconclusio: conclusion, a corollary, is clear. The assumptionassumptum: the assumption is clear from this, that the law of the Lord commands, as to the goods of nature, "to offer to the one who strikes the left cheek" (Matthew 5:39–40); as to the goods of fortune, to one "who wishes to take away the coat, to give the cloak as well"; indeed, to one "who wishes to contend with you in judgment and take away your coat", to give what is owed;11 hence it is said in Luke 6:30: "Of him that taketh away thy goods, ask them not again." And this threefold patience would by itself bring in full peace, by extinguishing discords.
¶4340.27–340.35
Nor does the unbelievinginfidelis: unbeliever; with a dative, faithless (to) objection hold, by which it is said that then the fulfilment of justice would be extinguished; for God would be bound to provide for his church from then on for the better; indeed, so it would draw near to the more perfect propertyless statestatus (disposicionis, virtutis, …): state (of disposition, of virtue, …).12 Therefore to say this would be the same as blasphemously to impute to God impotence, negligence or envy, and consequently [to say] that some lawgiver "is lifted up above all that is called God".13
¶5341.1–342.7
Hence those sink, as a consequence, deeper into heresy who say that the state of endowment is more perfect than the state of renunciation of propertyexpropriacio: renunciation of property, and consequently that the papal law by which endowment is established is more perfect than the law of Christ, by which renunciation of property is urged; for, as they say, these two laws and these two states follow one another convertibly, since otherwise human law would be altogether superfluous and would feed the people poisonously, the word of life being set aside. For a people must attend more to that king whose law it weighs more heavily; for a law and the state that it establishes follow upon each other.14 Hence it seems to me a mark of unbelief and a deceitful cunning of Antichrist that the temporal lordstemporales domini: temporal lords set up for themselves such shepherds and prophets as both are ignorant ofignorare: to be ignorant of the art of feeding and prepare the food of the mind either without order or poisonously. Now it is evident from the faith of scriptureex fide: as faith teaches; with a genitive, from the faith of [scripture] that the soul is fed by the word of God, and other words are poison to the soul; and since they do not ordain so for the cook and the food of the body, and according to Chrysostom "prelatesprelatus: prelate ought to be the stomach of the body of the church and the cook of its members", it is clear with how great unbelief the princes of the world labour, who value more, and weigh more heavily, the cook of the body than the cook of the mind.15 And those "whose God is their belly" are not "sons of peace", since the first peace, with God, is dissolved.16 And in this the teacher of the Christian faith notably falls short.17 For one must first set right the apostles and prophets in the church, and as a consequence the rest of the body of the church will be sound. And they would establish this necessary principle of faith, now discredited because of the blinding by the dust of temporal goodstemporalia: temporal goods: that every Christian 342ought to love the virtues infinitely more than honour, pleasure or temporal advantage, just as he ought to hate sin, even venial sin, infinitely more than any bodily penalty; and the same principle of faith by this, that as a thing is worse or better, so it is to be fled or loved in proportion.18
¶6342.8–342.18
From which it follows that the law of Christ is to be kept generally, even as to the counsels, and the law of men put after it. For from this there accrues a good of the soul infinitely more precious than any temporal gain. And this reason would move even an unbeliever: for it would be better, easier and shorter to observe Christ’s counsels and precepts; therefore we ought not to rely on their contraries, omitting what is more excellent. We sin gravely, therefore, when we do what is inexpedient for us and diminishes the honour of God, by withdrawing the benefit of the church.19
Notes
- 1 Cui innititur non in lege quam Christus instituit: the non in lege is taken with the relative ("relies on him, not in Christ’s law"); it could instead go with declinavit, "turned aside, not in the law Christ instituted". Either way the preacher is to show where the saint departed from Christ’s law. The margin of both manuscripts heads the passage Predicacionis modus de sanctis (338.9). The apparatus at 338.12 records hoc for lege in a manuscript.
- 2 The maxim that God rewards adverbs (the manner of the deed), not nouns, comes from the Glossa ordinaria to the Decretals on X 5.22.1 (Deus non est remunerator nominum sed adverbiorum), which Wyclif elsewhere cites as the "glossa Bernhardi" (De civili dominio II.12, ed. Loserth p. 139); Wyclif here gives only the first half. G. Patroni: the saints taken as patrons, as in 12-f.
- 3 Spissius, literally "more densely", taken as "more closely" (with less slackening of the rule). The speaker shifts to the first person plural (consideraremus, nostri ordinis): the preacher is imagined as a member of a religious order.
- 4 Insensibilis ex pravitate peccati: "imperceptible by the depravity of sin", i.e. too small to be perceived as sin; Wyclif sets insensibilis against sensibile in the same sentence.
- 5 Quam per se vel cum adiectis … legibus hominum adinventis: the subject of per se is unexpressed; we take it as the laws of the church just named. G. Sentencia: the second position under discussion in the chapter, "teaching", not a judicial sentence.
- 6 At 339.11 the manuscripts read sed ut (the apparatus gives the reading without its lemma in the OCR); the print’s nec eque sufficiens ut is translated.
- 7 Psalm 9:21 (Vulgate numbering), quoted as in the Vulgate. Wyclif’s gloss runs on from homines sunt, which Douay renders "to be but men". C. Quibus creavit legem … condere: the infinitive has no clear subject; we take it as God’s creating men so that a law complete in his reckoning should be established for them. The construction is doubtful.
- 8 Paciendum cum populo, "suffering with the people", is the print; the sense of the argument (peace with God and with creatures) suggests pacificandum or a like word, "making peace with the people". We translate the print.
- 9 Cui videret Deum suum amicabiliter obedire: obedire takes the dative, so cui is the one obeyed and Deum the subject: God himself obeys the man (cf. Joshua 10:14). Suum may refer to the creature or to the man.
- 10 John 18 (the betrayal); Christ calls Judas "Friend" at Matthew 26:50.
- 11 Matthew 5:39–40, paraphrased: the Vulgate has the right cheek (dexteram) and "turn to him also the other"; dare et pallium answers to dimitte ei et pallium; the order of coat and cloak follows Luke 6:29. C. Dare debitum, "to give what is owed": the third clause, against Matthew’s "let go thy cloak also", is taken as yielding the coat as though it were owed. B reads tunicam contendere at 340.23.
- 12 The objection’s ground is answered in the quia clause: if men’s laws were extinguished, God would not leave justice wanting but would provide better for the church. Ex hinc, "from then on". The propertyless state is that of the church without endowment.
- 13 2 Thessalonians 2:4; Wyclif has super for the Vulgate’s supra.
- 14 At 341.10 B reads legi, and at 341.11 preponderant. C. Populum illum regi magis intendere: regi is taken as the dative of rex, "attend to that king"; it could also be the passive infinitive, "that people must be ruled", which leaves magis intendere without a construction.
- 15 Ps.-Chrysostom, Opus imperfectum in Matthaeum, hom. 38 (on Matthew 21:12; PG 56.839–840), cited as Chrysostom: priests are the stomach of the church, which takes in the food, "cooks it in itself" and distributes it through the whole body; Wyclif paraphrases. No reference in Loserth. Both manuscripts note in the margin (341.20) that those who prefer the cook of the body to the cook of the mind sin gravely.
- 16 Philippians 3:19; Luke 10:6 ("the son of peace").
- 17 Doctor fidei christiane is not identified; it may be the prelate as teacher of the faith in general. B reads defecit (341.27).
- 18 Illi autem stabilirent: illi is taken as the apostles and prophets once set right. Et idem principium fidei per hoc quod … has no verb of its own; we take stabilirent as understood: they would establish the same principle by the rule of proportion. Both manuscripts mark the two principles in the margin (342.1, 342.3).
- 19 Facimus nobis inexpediens, et honorem Dei diminuens: the participle is taken in parallel with the adjective, "what is inexpedient … and diminishes"; utilitatem ecclesie subtrahendo gives the means.
How the Latin of this chapter was established
- Plate readings; page · reading · note):
- 338: Sed (the main token read the English side note "but"; this slot is the only one for the printed Sed)
- 339: tradicio
- 340: copiosius (15 is the line number)
- 340: accederet (30 is the line number)
- 341: illum
- 341: preponderat
- 341: toxice [NW]
- 342: Ex
- 340: per (first half of per-|cucienti; box misplaced on Domini)
- 340: V 39, (print has V and 39, separated by a space; box misplaced)