De potestate pape, chapter 12, part 14
The papacy is service, and the name of pope is equivocal
Loserth pp. 365.1–368.34
¶1365.1–367.3
Here we can feel out whether we love Christ more, by following his footsteps, than [we love] caesarean priestsprelatus / sacerdos cesarius: caesarean prelate / priest for the world’s sake. And this reason (as I believe) moved Augustine in the letter to Cyril, when, after he had addressed blessed Jerome, now dead, he said: "I call God to witness that from that time I have desired rather to be under than to be over."1 For according to the law and definition of Christ, Matthew 20, the greater, the superior or the prelateprelatus: prelate of the churchecclesia: church must be under his subjects in ministry;2 and while this servitudeservitus (laboris): servitude is wanting to a caesarean prelate he is not popepapa: pope. For neither Caesar nor God has powerpotestas: power so to change the offices of the prelates of the church while yet their name, which Christ instituted, stands;3 for God cannot [do] what is a contradiction, since then he would be contrary to himself. So although Caesar ordain that his bishop as a ruleregulariter: as a rule preside over other bishops, receiving worldly honours from the whole people, and that the whole people be generally subject to his decree, it does not on that account followsequitur: it follows that he is pope; for this can belong to a layman, as to Caesar or to another abject membermembrum: member of the devil. The nature of the papacy therefore consists in the humbler office of ministering, as it stood in blessed Peter and the others; and this it is God’s alone to grant to a creature. And it is clear that the more dangerous change wrought by the king of pride stands in this, that he blinds men, changing priests to the contrary of the office which Christ instituted for them. For when the office is made equivocalequivoce: equivocally, they must produce an equivocal church and equivocal fruits. And it is clear generally of every curatecuratus: curate or presbytersacerdos / presbiter: priest / presbyter that, by a very probable sign, he seeks the shepherd’s office unworthily when he labours so 366far off, at such cost and with such danger, to obtain ecclesiastical primacyprimatus: primacy; for if he purely or principally intends the building up of the church, the way is plain, shorter, safer and more pleasing to God: labouring without fixed bounds, as the apostles did.4 But if he intends primacy purely or first, he disqualifies himself for every statestatus (disposicionis, virtutis, …): state (of disposition, of virtue, …) of the church, since he puts the king of pride before the true king; and so it seems that the church, to be ruled as of old, should choose a presbyter for itself, or that the apostles of an unbelievinginfidelis: unbeliever; with a dative, faithless (to) people should appoint presbyters for them, whom, once the poison of the devil is perceived, they should cast off. And it is clear how foreign it is to the Roman pontiff to assign principalities to churches simoniacally;5 for this would be less discordant in a knight or another man of the people; from which it is proved that the pope, burdening himself so perplexedlyperplexus: perplexed in an office so alien and so doubtful, for the sake of a reputed temporal advantage, burdens his own office exceedinglynimis: exceedingly, since he foolishly makes himself a partaker in the crime of the men whom he so prefers. So too he is said to enlarge the power of those men which God diminishes or does not cause, and to restrict the power of those men which God amplifies. How then will the fool answer God, so headlong and so blasphemously contrary to himself? For there is no ground for holding that he has power over bishops, who are themselves more knowing and more abundantly have the keys of the church, so to restrict or looselaxare: loose their power of orderpotestas ordinis: power of order. For he cannot do this by his own power; what cords then has he about another’s power, greater than his own power, which God gives fittingly for profiting the church? He may not therefore feign blasphemy to magnify his own powerpotencia: potency / power, but he must establish the church in the primitive state and religion which Christ instituted, 367not exceeding the limitslimitare; limites: to assign (an office); limits in the gospel sacraments and sacramentalssacramentalia: sacramentals; for then he is undoubtedly Antichrist.
¶2367.4–367.13
But it is objected, by appeal toobicitur per: it is objected, by appeal to this, that if the pope must be the holiest of wayfarersviator: wayfarer and otherwise is not pope, it follows that every sin, mortal or venial, must degrade the pope; which is against the law in distinction 40, Si papa, where it is said that he is to be deposed only for heresy.6 And again the same seems [to hold] of kings, bishopsepiscopus; dominus episcopus: bishop; the lord bishop and any ministers of the church whatever; indeed the high priestsummus sacerdos: high priest in the old law was not as a rule the holiest, since he was often polluted.
¶3367.14–368.10
The answerdicitur (opening an answer): the answer is here is that the greater part of this difficulty stands in the significationsignacio / significacio: signification of a masters’ termtermini magistrales: masters' terms:7 for some understand "pope" as it signifies, by antonomasiaautonomatice / antonomastice: by antonomasia (pre-eminently), a marvellous holiness above all others whatever, as Christ stood toward his apostles.8 And so men understand [it] of the Roman pontiffRomanus pontifex: Roman pontiff in those things that savour of worldly gain and honour, but not in life according to the court of conscience before God. And in this way the three holy doctors aforesaid speak.9 But others understand "pope" as it signifies a bishop supereminent in some holiness, as Ambrose, Augustine and the rest were called popes. But after the clergy declined to civil standingcivilitas: civil standing, any were called popes who are humanly instituted principally for deciding the secular causes of the church. And the arguments run upon this equivocationequivocacio: equivocation; for Christ was pope, whom any sin whatever would degrade; so it would be foolish for a Christian to take 368the name of pope with that intention. So Peter, Gregory and other saints were wary of this, not knowing whether they are members of the devil. But in the middle [sense] holy bishops had taken the name of pope to themselves, and in the third, out of blasphemous pride and gain, they assumed to themselves indistinctlyconfuse / confusus (fides, noticia): indistinct(ly) that name of a caesarean prelate, beyond the authorityauctoritas: authority of the new or the old testament. Hence it is otherwise with the name of pope than with other names that are primarily names of offices, since "pope" signifies principally a preeminencepreeminencia: preeminence of holiness.10 And the solution is clear from the equivocation.
¶4368.11–368.14
Secondly it is objected, by appeal to this, that on this way every man ought to be pope, as he ought to be the holiest of wayfarers. For he ought to be pope and holier than anyone now on the roadviantes: those on the road.
¶5368.15–368.34
The answer here is that in this matter one must beware of the logic of the composite and divided sensesensus compositus / divisus: composite / divided sense. For there is no holiness in which a sinner may excel but that he ought to be holier, since otherwise he would not sin. Nevertheless, neither in the state of the way nor in the state of the fall ought a man, in the composite [sense], to be the holiest of wayfarers, since, with all sin taken away, there would [still] be a gradation of holinesses exceeding one another.11 But after the fall there is no other saint living the common life but ought to be holier. But, as I believe, every predestinatepredestinatus, -i: the predestinate (sg. "a predestinate [person]") [man] must end in a degree of holiness, not the highest, but the one due to him. Hence it seems a Luciferian presumption that a Christian take to himself the name of such a preeminence of holiness. So the saints with one accord rejected it. What then should move the Roman bishopRomanus episcopus: the Roman bishop, beyond an obligation hidden with God, to assume such a name to himself by a spontaneous human profession? For the profession and the office are changed from the apostolic office and custom to the law and office of Antichrist.
Notes
- 1 The letter to Cyril on Jerome’s death is the pseudo-Augustinian Epistola ad Cyrillum de magnificentiis Hieronymi (PL 22.288: Testis enim est Deus … plus affecto omnibus subesse, quam praeesse). Loserth (365.4) suggested Augustine, Ep. 134.1 to Apringius (PL 33.511, cui non tam praeesse quam prodesse desidero), which is only a parallel. T. The manuscripts read Augustinus; Augustinum is Loserth’s.
- 2 Matt. 20:26–27 (DR "whosoever is the greater among you, let him be your minister"), given in Wyclif’s words, so not quoted. R. B in the margin (365.8): Prelatus vere non est dum viciose deficit a ministerio, "he is not truly a prelate while he fails viciously in ministry".
- 3 Stante vero nomine eorum: we take vero as the particle ("while yet their name stands"), so that the contradiction is a changed office under an unchanged name; it could also be the adjective, "while their true name stands".
- 4 Indiffinite: without bounds of place or charge, as the apostles laboured where they were sent; set against the distant primacy sought at Rome.
- 5 Principatus ecclesiis assignare: to give churches their rulers, i.e. to provide prelates (Loserth’s side-note, "The pope should not appoint prelates").
- 6 Decretum D.40 c.6 Si papa (Loserth; the modern form is ours). Loserth italicises the clause quod solum debet deponi pro heresi as the canon’s; we leave it unquoted, since Wyclif reports it.
- 7 Magistralis is Loserth’s text; A reads ingracilis (367.15). R. B in the margin (367.10): Papa quid signat, "what 'pope' signifies".
- 8 Dicit here, and below (ut dicit episcopum, papa dicit … preeminenciam), is "signifies", the logicians’ use (Loserth’s side-note: "connotes").
- 9 The three doctors are Jerome, Bernard and Lincoln, cited at 361.1–2.
- 10 Aliis nominibus primo officiorum: other names that signify an office first, whereas "pope" first signifies holiness.
- 11 Foret gradus excessuum sanctitatum, literally "there would be a degree of excesses of holinesses": even without sin, holiness would come in degrees, so no one is bound to the highest.
How the Latin of this chapter was established
- Plate readings; page · reading · note):
- 366: debent abicere. (366.12, debent lost in every scan, read on the plate; the print opens a new ¶ at Et patet, kept within this ¶ here)
- 365: si plus (one main token covers two printed words)
- 365: prelato
- 365: ∅ (folio bar after sive (252ᵃ in margin) read as i)
- 366: remote (faded leaf; print "remote,")
- 366: Et (main lost the line "Et patet quam extraneum est a Romano ponti-" and kept only "fice"; this slot takes the line’s first word, the rest (with pontifice whole) is the GAP row at pos 75)
- 366: patet quam extraneum est a Romano pontifice (print line "Et patet quam extraneum est a Romano ponti-|fice,"; Et given at pos 74, ponti-fice joined) [GAP]
- 366: propter reputatum commodum temporale (print "ambiguo, propter reputatum commodum tempo-|rale nimis"; ambiguo already at pos 103) [GAP]
- 366: ipsis (main splits ipsis into ir + sis on the faded leaf; whole word given here, next token ∅)
- 366: ∅ (rest of ipsis, given whole at pos 157)
- 366: sciencioribus (main splits it into 5circirir + r; whole word given here, next token ∅)
- 366: ∅ (rest of sciencioribus, given whole at pos 159)
- 366: et
- 366: copiosius
- 366: claves
- 366: ecclesie
- 368: testamenti
- 368: preeminencie [NW]