De potestate pape, chapter 6, part 4
The power of order and the gentile name of authority
Loserth pp. 114.30–118.5
¶1114.30–115.10
Likewise, in receiving the power of orderpotestas ordinis: power of order, one receives power and authority to this degree, because [one receives] the power of feeding the churchecclesia: church, which is the best rule and the highest jurisdictioniurisdiccio: jurisdiction that Christ ever instituted, since God’s rightius: right / law is of more difference 115than Caesar’s right.1 Nor does the power of rule depend on place or people, because it is distinguished from the act of the power, being given by God indistinctly, before place or people; therefore, since it does not vary in correspondence with such an object, it is manifest that it is at rest before such an object of jurisdiction [is given it]. For so the apostles, resting in Jerusalem, had the power of rule given by the Holy Spirit, and yet no distinct people had yet been assignedlimitare; limites: to assign (an office); limits to their knowledge.2
¶2115.11–117.15
To the first it seems to me, as I have often touched on, that every clericclerus; clericus: the clergy; cleric ought to rely purely on divine authorityauctoritas: authority, leaving aside the gentile authority devised for the kings of the gentiles, who unbelievinglyinfidelis: unbeliever; with a dative, faithless (to) blasphemed that they are God, as is clear of Nebuchadnezzar in Daniel 4;3 and hence they took to themselves the name of authority and of chief lordshipdominium: lordship. But Christ teaches his apostles to flee that paganismgentilitas: paganism, as is clear in Luke 22 and Matthew 20.4 Hence, because something of licencelicencia: licence remained in that paganism, therefore the word "authority" remained with civil standingcivilitas: civil standing, by which I understand the superiority of civil power. But after the church was endowed, the names of jurisdiction and of authority, with others like them that savour of civil standing, were irreligiously brought in. And so it is granted that one bishopepiscopus; dominus episcopus: bishop; the lord bishop is of greater power than another, which some call authority. But, referring authority to God, and denying that authority is formally in a creature, but [only] promulgation, greatness of authority would have to be denied in the apostles.5 And secondly, understanding authority as it signifies that God’s herald has power to promulgate his teachingsentencia: teaching / sentence, in this way all the apostles or evangelists 116are of equal authority, since it cannot admit of greater or less. In this sense holy scripture is of equal authority on both sides.6 But thirdly some speak of authority, groundlessly in my view, as it signifies greatnessprioritas; majoritas: priority; greatness of holiness or a multitude of charisms; and because that is unknown to us, they transfer authority in gentile fashion to human ordinanceordinacio; ordinancia: ordinance; of the sacrament, ordination, so that they posit any number of grades in pope, archbishop, rector and simple priest, with any number of subdivisions; and because these can well be made by divine authority according to the divisions of the grades of discernment and of power which he distributes, therefore human institutions are solemnized, although contrary to divine ordinance, and are observed more than God’s lawlex dei / lex Christi / lex evangelica: God's law / the law of Christ / the gospel law.7 But let him speak so of authority who knows how to ground it in holy scripture. And the papal lawsius: right / law on greatness and obedience can be understood [to hold] when the human institution of men’s offices of superiorprepositura: office of superior corresponds to the divine judgement; [then] it seems that, in proportion as someone is set in greater preeminence as regards men, so he should really be set in greater preeminence of virtues and of grace as regards God.8 And because this never or rarely happens, and there is not, as I believe, any authority of scripture left to ground it, therefore I am silent as to the laws and the deeds, saying that this can well be done by God’s absolute powerpotencia absoluta: absolute power, knowing that it was not so among Christ’s priests in the primitive church. And so it is clear in part how one must answer the first objectioninstancia; objectum: objection. To the second it is clear from what has been said how a twofold authority must be taken from holiness as from a remote sign, and not as from an equal measure; because then [authority] would be diminished or extinguished as the holiness 117of the one who promulgates [is], which is false, since unbelievers such as Balaam, Caiaphas and other damnable men prophesied.9 Yet holiness is a sign of divine authority and of the firmness, which cannot be increased, of human authority;10 and so the grades of the office of superior and of what is called civil authority crept in, with the endowment and the cupidity for temporal goodstemporalia: temporal goods, not only among secular clerics but among the friars, since they appoint tribunes, centurions, deans and others, like the Jews who kept the ceremonies of the old testament, as is noted in Exodus 18.11 But if the true eightfold humility, of which [I spoke] above, were kept, all these things would be superfluous, as they would have been superfluous in the holy apostles; and so the lack of instruction in virtue is the cause why these things are now useful.12
¶3117.16–118.5
To the third it is clear that the power of order is a powerpotestas: power of rule, which each has inasmuch as he is a presbytersacerdos / presbiter: priest / presbyter; which only those recognize who have known universalsuniversale; ydea: universal; idea; and that power is distinguished from the power of order or of rule that exceeds the most remiss degree of power.13 And so the same bishop has many powers of order or of rule, as is clear above. Nor does a prelateprelatus: prelate give a curatecuratus: curate a new power of rule unless he is a faithful herald of God, who gave [it] before; indeed, it seems to me that the priest was already a debtor to the same people over whom he is set by his bishop, since the apostle, Romans 1:14, confesses himself a debtor to Greeks, Latins and barbarians;14 nevertheless, by the new vow and the charge received, he is the more bound. But the riteritus: rite of the gentile church in this matter seems to give licence for gathering temporal advantage even to one unqualifiedinhabilis: unqualified (to hold office) as regards God; and such jurisdiction, not bridled by scripture, would bring in the sectreligio privata; secta: private religion; sect of Antichrist above all.15 If, therefore, our [bishops] have episcopal powers equal 118with the apostles, they show themselves damnable, in that by idling they so far abuse those powers. But if they have had earthly powers above the apostles, they have this falsely and antichristianly from "the prince of this world".16
Notes
- 1 The third objection (A in the margin: "3"), answered at 117.16. Adeo … quia, "to this degree … because", is loose; the sense is that receiving orders confers the highest jurisdiction. Cum plus sit differencie ius Dei quam ius cesaris does not construe cleanly: the sense is that God’s right stands further above Caesar’s. A word may be lost at the page turn (114.33–115.1).
- 2 Luke 24:49 and Acts 1:4, the apostles staying in Jerusalem until the Spirit came; limitatus, "assigned", as a people assigned to a bishop.
- 3 Dan. 4 (Vulgate 4:27, "Is not this the great Babylon, which I have built … by the strength of my power"). The boast that the king is God is closer to Judith 3:13 (DR "that he only might be called God") and 6:2 ("there is no God, but Nabuchodonosor").
- 4 Luke 22:25–26 ("The kings of the Gentiles lord it over them … But you not so"); Matt. 20:25–26.
- 5 The first of three senses of auctoritas (the second and third follow at 115.31 and 116.3): if authority belongs to God alone and a creature has only promulgation, no apostle had more authority than another.
- 6 Utrobique, "on both sides": in both testaments, or in every part of scripture alike.
- 7 At 116.3 Loserth’s apparatus reads "tercio; adde: videtur", proposing videtur after tercio; the print does not have it and construes without it. Ordinacio here is the arrangement of grades, so "ordinance".
- 8 The manuscripts read correspondent and sic videt (apparatus 116.19–20); Loserth prints correspondet and sic videtur, which we translate.
- 9 Num. 22–24 (Balaam); John 11:51 (Caiaphas "prophesied that Jesus should die for the nation").
- 10 Firmitatis inaugmentabilis auctoritatis humane: holiness signals the firmness of human authority, a firmness that does not grow with holiness. We take inaugmentabilis with firmitatis; it could also agree with auctoritatis.
- 11 Exod. 18:21, the "rulers of thousands, and of hundreds, … and of tens" (Vulgate tribunos, et centuriones, et quinquagenarios, et decanos).
- 12 The eightfold humility is treated earlier in this treatise, ch. 3, 59.8 ff.: the eight conditions of the truly humble from Grosseteste’s sermon on humility (see 03-e n4).
- 13 Gradus remississimus, "the most remiss degree", the lowest degree in the scholastic intension and remission of qualities: the bare priestly power, which higher powers of order exceed.
- 14 Rom. 1:14, Vulgate Graecis ac barbaris, sapientibus et insipientibus debitor sum (Douay "To the Greeks and to the barbarians, to the wise and to the unwise, I am a debtor"). Wyclif adds "Latins".
- 15 Gentilis may agree with ritus ("the gentile rite of the church") or with ecclesie ("the rite of the gentile church"); we follow the word order.
- 16 John 12:31, Douay–Rheims.
How the Latin of this chapter was established
- Plate readings; page · reading · note):
- 117: qui (10 is the line number)
- 117: illa
- 117: Grecis
- 117: Latinis