De potestate pape, chapter 7, part 2
The keys are power and knowledge, given to every priest
Loserth pp. 138.32–142.12
¶1138.32–141.15
As to the second argument, from that [text] of Matthew 10, where in the listing of the names of the apostles Peter is put first, the primacyprimatus: primacy of Peter is without doubt marked, 139which Christ had intended: namely, that Peter should be captaincapitaneus: captain and chief champion, to lead Christ’s army more closely like himself, that is, in faith, humility and suffering. So Peter, asking about the life of the evangelist, who signifies the contemplative life, received an answer from God: "What is it to thee? Follow thou me" (John 21 [the last chapter], 19).1 This sense, therefore, the two arguments put forward carry, as I have often repeated, and not exercise of lordshipdominacio: exercise of lordship or secular honour, or, as Bernard says, a power of chastising in secular fashion. Just as the headcaput: head feeds and rules the rest of the body by words and by its gaze, but not by bodily assault or defence with weapons, so if the pope lacks sight, hearing and every sense for ruling the body of Christ as headcapitaliter: as head (as chief lord), what has he to do with "pope" or "head of Christ’s churchecclesia: church"?2 In truth no human election or approval can make such a man become head or joint of Christ’s church; but by lyingly presuming the name in this way he becomes head of "the assembly of the malignant" and of "the synagogue of Satan".3 For a man has of himself the powerpotencia: potency / power of going off and of being a membermembrum: member of the devil, but he has it only from God to be a member of the church; for the nearest vicar of Christvicarius Christi: vicar of Christ must be spiritual after his likeness, as Luke 9:55–56 teaches about the three apostles who desired human vengeance: "You know not," says Christ, "of what spirit you are. The Son of man came not to destroy souls, but to save." For meekness, and not war, shall possess the land of the living, as the Truth teaches in Matthew 5.4 And hence Chrysostom notes on the First Epistle to Timothy, homily 5: "The apostle does not speak," he says, "authoritatively, nor in lordly fashion, nor with power, but says 'son Timothy'"; and therefore 140Bernard says that Eugenius received the sheep of Christ "to be fed, not to be oppressed".5 For he ought to fight as a spiritual soldiermilicia; milites: knighthood; knights with the sword of the spirit, to avenge the spiritual injury done to God. But after civil standingcivilitas: civil standing was mingled with the religion of priests, pride crept into the clergy, civil exaction and monstrous lordshipdominium: lordship, so that that [verse] of Psalm 9, which speaks of Antichrist, is verified today: "Whilst the wicked man is proud, the poor is set on fire."6 And as to the point touched on about the keys given singly to Peter, as has been said, it is not lawful for any of the faithful to doubt that Peter, as general attorney, bore the person of the church, where he received the powerpotestas: power not singly for himself and any Roman pontiffRomanus pontifex: Roman pontiff whatever, but generally and preeminently for any priestsacerdos / presbiter: priest / presbyter whatever who follows [Christ] more closely, to whom any place or human election whatever is irrelevant, because the giving of these keys is a divine mystery.7 For the said keys are power and knowledge for building up the church, which, significantly, ought to be in every priest, and (as I believe) were in Paul more excellently than in Peter. For since it seems impious to posit in Peter, without reason, idleness and abuse of power, but Paul, from the faith of scriptureex fide: as faith teaches; with a genitive, from the faith of [scripture] (1 Corinthians 15:10), "laboured more than all", it seems that he had more of power: he laboured, I say, by preaching the gospel, by writing, and by suffering persecutions more abundantly. And that the key of the power of rulepotestas regiminis: power of rule, which we call authorityauctoritas: authority, belongs singly to Peter has no foundation.8 For power to rule the church 141is given to each bishopepiscopus; dominus episcopus: bishop; the lord bishop, as far as he can profit his mother, whether by preaching the gospel, or by ministering the sacraments, or by building up through prayer, contemplation and example. Hence, because of the excellence which we ought to have, these keys are said to belong singly to the priests of Christ, so that power is the material [element] of the presbytersacerdos / presbiter: priest / presbyter's spiritual key, and the formal [element] is the knowledge of God: not mathematical knowledge, not logic or scholastic disputation, but the knowledge of scripture, which a bishop ought to know and teach excellently. Hence, just as prime matter cannot be without a material form, nor the converse, so it seems to me that the power of the priestly keys cannot be without the aforesaid knowledge, nor the converse.9
¶2141.16–142.12
Hence John XXII and others who savour the world, because they had not excelled in these keys and their offices, invented keys of power and authority, by which, in gathering money, they subjected the simple to their tyranny and hypocrisy.10 For just as there are two ways, one of descending by vices to hell and the other of ascending by virtues to the church triumphant, so there are two gates or entrances. And the priest ought to have keys to lock the gates of hell against the simple who are subject to him and to open the gates of heaven to the simple; and so he ought to open the treasure of virtues to the sheep that are to be fed, and himself to enter first, by virtuous works that give example to and stir up the followingsequela: what follows / following of the sheep.11 Hence as many such powers or kinds of knowledge as a prelateprelatus: prelate has had, so many keys he has, and all of them make up only two. But that these keys are narrowed to excommunications and absolutions, the god of this world brought in, blinding the simple through pomp and avarice. 142And so I understand the decree 24, q. 1, Quodcumque, with those like it: all of them must be understood [to hold] when the power of the church militant does not err, which is the case only when it is conformed to the judgement of the church triumphant; for otherwise it cannot open the door of the kingdom of heaven even to itself.12 But if these keys, as to their matter, have been turned into earthly affection and, as to their form, swerve monstrously from the knowledge of the apostles to the art of Lucifer, it must be that such men with their keys open their own gates and teach as dogma the headlong fall of their disciples into hell.13
Notes
- 1 Matthew 10:2 (DR "The first, Simon who is called Peter"). The words are John 21:22 (DR "what is it to thee? Follow thou me"); the printed verse 19 is where Christ first says "Follow me". The evangelist is John, the figure of the contemplative life. Sibi similius: "more like himself", that is, like Christ. Capitaneus: captain, kept apart from caput.
- 2 Bernard’s potestatem seculariter castigandi has no reference from Loserth here and is not in De consideratione; cf. the sense of IV.3.7 (PL 182, 776: Quid tu denuo usurpare gladium tentes …?). Quid sibi et pape vel capiti …: the idiom of quid mihi et tibi, "what has he to do with" the titles "pope" or "head". Sicut … quod si: the comparison is completed by the conditional, construed "so if".
- 3 Psalm 25:5 (DR "the assembly of the malignant"); Apocalypse 2:9 (DR "the synagogue of Satan"). Articulus: a joint or limb of the body. Presumendo sic nomen: construed "presuming the name in this way" (of head).
- 4 Potencia here is ordinary power, a man’s ability to go astray, not Aristotle’s potency. Luke 9:55–56 (DR); Luke 9:54 names two apostles, James and John, where Wyclif says three. Miticia … possidebunt terram vivencium: a paraphrase of Matthew 5:4 (DR "Blessed are the meek: for they shall possess the land") with the "land of the living" of Psalm 26:13; left unquoted.
- 5 Chrysostom, homily 5 on 1 Timothy: Loserth, Opera XI, 527 (139.31); Chrysostom on 1 Tim. 1:18: Paul charges him "not so much with arbitrary or despotic authority as like a father" (NPNF, read in English only). Fili Thymothee: 1 Timothy 1:18 (DR "O son Timothy"). Bernard, De consideratione II.6.13 (PL 182, 749: Pascendas utique, non premendas suscepisti), Loserth’s ubi supra (140.1), quoted already at 138.24.
- 6 Miles: the Pauline figure, "soldier" (Ephesians 6:17, DR "the sword of the Spirit"). Psalm 9:23 in the Vulgate (DR), which Loserth gives by the Hebrew numbering as Psalm 10:2 (140.9).
- 7 The editor’s semicolon after ambigere parts the verb from its quin clause; the two are construed together. Matthew 16:19. Generalis attornatus: the legal proctor who acts in another’s person. A in marg. (139.30, again 140.19): "Peter received the keys not singly [139.30 simpliciter] for himself but generally for the church"; A in marg. 140.7 Ad 2, B "To the second in the second argument", A 140.10 "To 2 in the second argument": both readers mark the answer to the second argument.
- 8 1 Corinthians 15:10: Wyclif’s plus omnibus laboravit for the Vulgate’s abundantius illis omnibus laboravi (DR "I have laboured more abundantly than all they"). Autem here sets Paul against Peter inside the cum clause ("but"). Clavis … quam dicimus auctoritatem singulariter Petro competere non fundatur is construed with competere as what is unfounded; alternatively "the key …, which we say belongs as authority singly to Peter, is not founded". AB in marg. 140.19: "The keys [are] power and knowledge for building up the church"; 140.25: "Paul had more of power".
- 9 Materiale / formale: the pair of matter and form: power is the matter of the key, knowledge its form. Forma materialis: the form that exists in matter. Matri sue: the church as mother.
- 10 Quia non excesserant: Loserth suggests adding parum (141.17: "because they had gone not a little too far"); the print construes and is translated. Seculum sapientes: sapere "to savour". AB in marg. 141.17: "How the abuse of the keys comes about".
- 11 Sacerdos autem: autem continues the figure of the gates ("and"). Sequela is the flock’s following of Christ, not "what follows".
- 12 2 Corinthians 4:4 (DR "the god of this world hath blinded"). Gratian, Decretum C. 24 q. 1 c. 6 Quodcumque (form ours; Loserth, foot: "Cap. VI"; Augustine, In Ioh. tr. 50, PL 187, 1267); B reads Quicunque (142.1–2). Potestate … non errante is an ablative absolute, rendered "when the power … does not err".
- 13 Portas suas: the gates of hell, the second of the "two gates" above. Quoad materiam … quoad formam takes up the matter (power) and form (knowledge) of the key.
How the Latin of this chapter was established
- Plate readings; page · reading · note):
- 139: a Deo (one token covers two printed words)
- 139: Quid
- 139: tu
- 139: sed fili (one token covers two printed words)
- 140: ∅ (English side-note word)
- 140: supereminenter (hyphenated superemi-nenter; main token covers whole word)
- 140: ∅ (second half of superemi-nenter, main scan already holds whole word)
- 142: aliter (one word; print = aliter (no s); margin figure after it is a line number)
- Omitted per §3.5 / kept in the English (margin matter): reference Peter’s (142.13).